GrandpaGB
Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
GrandpaGB
ParticipantMaybe it starts with good intentions, but it always ends in failure. Don’t use theory, look at the results when you try to socially engineer a society.
“As Marx wrote, capital comes into the world “dripping from head to toe, from every pore, with blood and dirt.” More than societies who abandoned capitalism put into mass graves?
You shouldn’t be surprised that your ideas don’t work and always result in dictatorships, as the Marxist-Leninists and Trotskyists fight among themselves over theory. You’ve had your day of bloodbaths and failures, but this time you’ll get it right? They all said that.
GrandpaGB
ParticipantThat society is divided between workers and capitalists is Marxism simplified. Take away the capitalists and we all live happily ever after. Prove it? A man who wrote the Communist Manifesto in a bygone ear nearly two hundred years ago said so and it’s here in a SPGB link. So we take away capitalism in various countries during the 20th century and what happens? It doesn’t work and they all ended up in dictatorships.
Removing capitalism as an economic solution only works if it’s successful, if it doesn’t it’s not communism?
Where are the workers of today cheering to give communism another go as they were in the 1970s? They’ve been replaced by the minorities; the Islamists, gays, trans, Greens … None of who have a communist agenda and don’t give a toss about capitalism, or communism. It’s why you’re a tiny isolated minority still shouting in the wind for a decades old idea of a workers take over, but it’s all theory and wishful thinking.
Don’t you find it a little odd that you’re supporting an idea that is never going to happen? Wishing it would is completely different. A bit like me wanting the government to triple my pension, but that’s never going to happen either. Nice idea though.
Why not try thinking for yourselves instead of relying on others to do it for you? Rather than cheering for something that is never going to happen, why not be grateful for what you have got and fight to keep capitalism out of it.
A welfare state that your Grandparents would have cut off their right hand for. Why not cheer for the Chinese model that includes but curbs the excesses of capitalism and above all, works. Maybe wonder why if Marxism is such a good idea, no one is voting for it. Or why the Communist Party disbanded in 1991 and splintered into tiny in-fighting groups of Marxist-Leninists versus Trotskyists, each of whom will tell you they’re right and all the others are wrong.
And there follows another link to theory, wishful thinking and what someone else tells you.
GrandpaGB
ParticipantBut back to China …
Results matter. Capitalism is blamed for our ills, but then look at China and there are no explanations for how they successfully used capitalism to make their economy boom and remove hundreds of millions from poverty with not a Marxist in sight.
Shall we stop for a moment and remember the tens of millions who went into mass graves as a result of those following Marx’s teachings?
Perhaps we should move away from centuries old ideologies and focus more on what works? Call the Chinese way the real post-capitalism to replace our ailing laissez faire capitalism and be thankful for our welfare society?
Surely, the lesson is that economic systems should be judged by the prosperity they deliver, rather than by the ideological purity of the theories behind them.
GrandpaGB
Participant” the government of the country which represented us. ”
Governments do not represent the working class, even though the working class are duped into electing them. Governments represent the capitalist interests of the nation-state. So when one uses “we” one is identifying with the exploiting class. Unless you are a capitalist? I don’t mean someone who just supports capitalism, but someone who lives on rent, interest and profit, surplus value, on the shoulders of the workers.
I’m afraid the government do represent us. Whoever it is they’re the one people voted for. If the SPGB was voted in wouldn’t some committee represent us? No, I never owned a business, or ever had someone work for me. I’ve worked for what I’ve got and I’m not about to give it away for some fairy tale of sharing it with the world. Count in the rest of the workers in Britain who also feel the same way.
GrandpaGB
ParticipantThere’s a lot there robbo, but briefly …
Because we live in a society with a capitalist economy. Other economic systems have been tried and failed; communism, planned economies, mixed economies. That doesn’t mean capitalism is perfect, but it’s the best of the bunch. It’s existed for 400 to 500 years and the others have come and gone. Now you explain to me why no one is voting for your idea of a cashless, stateless, everything free society?Of course our culture reflects our behaviour and yes, I favour regulated capitalism over anything you’re suggesting which will never happen. You do know that, don’t you?
Let’s talk reality.
If you’re working and your salary was suddenly tripled, would you still want an equality based society where everyone shares what you now have? Ditto if you won the lottery? There are some who are altruistic by nature, but they’re few and far between.
There are small communities that practice your form of anarchism/communism where a bunch of people who all have nothing get together and agree to share the nothing they’ve got with others who also have nothing. Among them won’t be anyone who has anything and is willing to share it with others.
As I live in a capitalist society I’d prefer to be a millionaire. My job is to convince a million people to send me a pound each. That’s not going to happen and is just wishful thinking. But Grandpa you’ll say, ‘in our society you won’t need money.’ I won’t? Does that mean I get my cottage in the countryside and a Rolls Royce? And they all lived happily ever after?
But hold on a minute, who said ‘No you can’t, because you don’t need it.’ Woah, who are you to tell me what I need or don’t need?
‘We’re the People’s Committee who decide what you get and only we have a cottage and a Rolls Royce as we have unanimously decided we need it and you don’t.’ Isn’t that how it always ends?GrandpaGB
ParticipantThere’s that “we” again. So I take it you will be handing yourself over to the authorities in Beijing and demanding they punish you with death for starting the Opium Wars, helping the Manchu throne to crush the T’aip’ings, and deliberately diverting arms supplies meant for Canton to the warlord of Kwangtung?
The children in Liverpool’s cotton mills will have been gratified to hear they ruled the roost.
On a British website I take it we’re British? The ‘we’ meaning Britain. You have to read the ‘we’ in context with what’s being said, so no not me as an individual or the factory workers, but the government of the country which represented us. There’s another one for you, ‘us’. And no, I wasn’t responsible for the opium wars and I’m not interested in semantics. So anyway, which part of the op didn’t you agree with?
GrandpaGB
ParticipantIf you’re a believer all well and good. I prefer not to follow and make up my own mind with my own world view. My world view took me a lifetime and the ideas I had half a century ago are nothing like those I have now. Eventually, we all ditch the rose coloured glasses we had when we were young and realise we’re not going to change the world, or even make one iota of difference.
How many tens of millions went to mass graves in the USSR or died slow deaths in Gulags by those following Marx’s ideology? A curse on utopian ideologies!
GrandpaGB
ParticipantGrandpaGB, I’d be interested to read your comments about this thread:
Which post, there are many of them.
People are arguing their ideological positions of markets and using Marxism to try to explain Maoism. Once we ruled the roost, then the U.S. took over and now China is rising. All dominant countries have a shelf life, all rise and fall, but what China has shown is that controlled capitalism can work. Let Marx explain that one away.
GrandpaGB
ParticipantStandard textbook mythology.
Hardly out of a textbook, I was there. Which part of it don’t you agree with?
GrandpaGB
ParticipantI see a lot of poster attacks happening on various forums. The MAGA American’s are the worst, but in general cult like places where everyone sings from the same hymn sheet. I’m quite happy to explain what I believe in, but it’s not what someone in a pamphlet said I must believe.
My world view is a result of my own experiences and knowledge, not someone else’s. I can knock you out a quick 500 word essay on how wonderful the world would be in a classless, cashless society, but it would be just copying what someone else thinks.
There’s also no point in putting up links to what SPGB say. It’s like someone putting a link to Reform’s website and believing what they read there. In your own words helps a lot and on topic is a Godsend.
GrandpaGB
ParticipantGramps, for a supposed “expert” on China, you thought Mao took power by a coup?
No, not me, history. I’m not an ‘expert’ I just lived and worked there for many years. Here’s your china thread.
GrandpaGB
ParticipantGrandpa “Thatcher was speaking on behalf of the majority who voted for the Conservatives.”
This actually demonstrates the paucity of your research and your ability to use words inaccurately.
Thatcher got 43.9% of the votes in 1979, 42.4% in 1983 and 42.2% in 1987.
That is not a majority, it’s a plurality.
If, as you say, been teaching Wnglish to non English speakers, it sounds to me like you’ve been stealing a living for a lot of years.
It’s a majority of the votes counted. We can agree or disagree, but it’s how the system works. As for my job, I taught English and social and political science as a core subject, but that’s got nothing to do with the thread topic, has it.
GrandpaGB
ParticipantHow a society under free-access socialism/communism would be run isn’t a strange question and how people would want it to run isn’t an answer.
People are inherently greedy, it’s why our society is run by capitalists and the greediest get to the top. It’s why there’s so much corruption in government, why the skilled engineer demands more than the labourer sweeping the floor and why you’ll try and sell your car for as much as you can get and not what it’s actually worth. You can’t remove those traits by social engineering and wishful thinking.
The average worker isn’t bothered about “enlightened self-interest”, they’re looking for as much as they can get for their labour and that’s been the position for centuries. The engineer is no more likely to share what he has with a labourer than a millionaire with the engineer.
What were the recent junior doctors and train drivers strikes about? A classless, moneyless society or more pay? It’s not that a free-access society would break down at the first opportunity, it’s that it would never get off the ground in the first place. It’s only a good idea if I can control the distribution. 🙂
Of course many people won’t work if they can live for free. If you’re currently working and I said I’ll give you what you can now buy with your wage for free, why would would you want to drag yourself off to work every day? And if you’re on benefits you’re already living for free.
It’s not just me that is objecting, it’s the whole of society. Why not have a pamphlet explaining why for 80 years the workers have not elected one SPGB member to parliament? Or, why the SPGB has only 300 members out of millions of workers? Did you know that The Monster Raving Loony Party has more members than the SPGB? These aren’t disparaging remarks, they’re facts and when you can answer them maybe you’ll start thinking for yourself instead of someone else having to do it for you.
GrandpaGB
ParticipantYou’re not taking the slightest notice of what anyone says but just repeating and repeating your mantras. But I bet you’re loving it. People actually taking enough notice of you to reply. I bet that doesn’t happen very often.
Yes I do read what people say, but I’m not a lemming and don’t join the follow the leader script. I explain why I don’t agree and it seems to upset the majority. I explain what you’re cheering for is not socialism, but communism and that it doesn’t work.
Reading your first post on this thread, you seem the most switched on here amongst your lost in space comrades, but even in that reply you were advocating communism. The line that made me smile the most was, “That was actually Marx’s vision too …” No h, you haven’t discovered anything, you’re regurgitating Marxism and pretending you’ve come up with something new.
You must know that what you’re proposing will never be voted in and it’s just something to add to your Father Christmas wish list? Probably not much hope either for those who think Mao wasn’t a communist and poverty was the same in 2010 as it was in the Great Depression of the 1930s. The only thing you’re lacking in your political set-up is a Minister of Utter Bollocks.
GrandpaGB
ParticipantJust a quick question Grandpa.
In another thread you say that:
“What large industries we had left Thatcher destroyed in the 80s”
By saying “we” I assume you were part of the ownership of those industries.
Which part of the “large industries” did you own?
We as in the royal we. Thatcher was speaking on behalf of the majority who voted for the Conservatives.
-
AuthorPosts
