Socialism not Communism

November 2026 › Forums › General discussion › Socialism not Communism

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 80 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #266963
    GrandpaGB
    Participant

    Socialism is often associated with public ownership and essential services such as healthcare, transport and utilities. But the SPGB means something quite different: common ownership of the means of production, the abolition of the wages system, and a moneyless society where goods and services are freely available according to need. One of those semantic comments of, we’re not communists, we just agree with Marx.

    The SPGB doesn’t regard nationalisation or public ownership as socialism at all. In their view those are just forms of state capitalism; the wages system, markets and a privileged class still remain. For them, socialism and communism are the same thing: a worldwide system of common ownership and democratic control with free access.

    That leaves some basic questions.

    Can It Work in Practice?

    The SPGB proposes common ownership and democratic control on a global scale. But how would that work in practice? Common ownership of the means and modes of production is communism, not socialism.

    Without money, wages or markets, how would we decide what to produce, how much to produce and where resources should go? Who would coordinate everything, and how would we stop those people from becoming a bureaucracy with interests of its own?

    Democratic control? How would that work beyond voting for political representatives? Would all eight billion of the worlds population have a say in decisions about production, or would we end up relying on administrators to make those decisions for us?

    Removing Capitalism

    In abolishing capitalism, who in Marxist terms would then control the means of production? In other words, who would control the ownership of wealth-generating assets and the means by which wealth is produced? The state, the government, a people’s collective? That’s communism.

    In the Land of the Free

    Then there’s free access. Would people really contribute according to their abilities and take only what they need? Who is going to decide what each individual needs, or do eight billion people each decide for themselves? What happens when resources are scarce, people disagree about priorities, or some people simply don’t want to contribute? Does everyone really get what they each think they need, or do we sink to the lowest common denominator in the interests of equality?

    Advocating a society based on common ownership and free access is one thing. Explaining how it would actually function is another. Aren’t these beliefs just theory in opposition to laissez faire capitalism? How many here are working, own property, or have savings and are willing to share what they have with others? Or is it more a one way street and they have very little but want a share in what others have got? That’s not socialism either, again, it’s communism.

    Socialism Not Communism

    Given the SPGB’s minuscule electoral support, what’s the prospect of achieving such a society through democratic means? It’s zero isn’t it, so why not fight to keep the socialism of our welfare state out of private hands instead of dreaming of a mythical society where everyone agrees to be equal, greed magically disappears and eight billion people think they’re going to get what they want.

    #266966
    ste finch
    Participant

    Looks like someone has been playing with AI!
    If this person wants to debate, we are happy to do so, but on the basis of our party’s case not some imagined or isolated points.
    Just one more thing – yes we use socialism and communism interchangeably – get over it!

    #266967
    Thomas_More
    Participant

    I say we ignore him from now on. Don’t waste energy.

    #266968
    GrandpaGB
    Participant

    I don’t do AI, I don’t need to. I just write about what I know from the top of my head. This is a forum 500 word throwaway post. I wouldn’t waste more than 30 minutes on a post.

    Perhaps you’re not used to anything over a paragraph long? Or perhaps you’re just unhappy with what’s written, or maybe can’t understand it? No point attacking the poster. If you don’t understand something ask and if it’s a genuine question I’ll try to explain.

    #266969
    GrandpaGB
    Participant

    I say we ignore him from now on. Don’t waste energy.

    For someone who doesn’t like what I say you seem to a frequent visitor. Off you go then. 🙂

    #266970
    Bijou Drains
    Participant

    I’ve got to agree with you Grandpa, it doesn’t look to me like you are using AI. I come across a lot of AI through work and although your contribution has a look of it, you’re grammar has some pretty obvious flaws.

    AI usually has good (although more US based) grammar.

    More that happy to discuss your “points”, although I’m up to my eyes with work at the moment and have a few posts about Freud to add before I get a chance to send some stuff across.

    I might be wrong, but you seem to be hinting at the Von Mises Economic Calculation argument. Could you clarify if that is part of your argument? It might aid discussion.

    #266971
    Bijou Drains
    Participant

    Just a quick question Grandpa.

    In another thread you say that:

    “What large industries we had left Thatcher destroyed in the 80s”

    By saying “we” I assume you were part of the ownership of those industries.

    Which part of the “large industries” did you own?

    #266974

    Just a quick question, Grandpa.

    In another thread, you say that:

    “What large industries we had left Thatcher destroyed in the 80s”

    By saying “we,” I assume you were part of the ownership of those industries.

    Which part of the “large industries” did you own?

    —————————————————————–

    Some wage slaves call themselves capitalists because they support and defend capitalism, the are pro-capitalists, and the only thing that they own is their labour force, and they are living from paycheck to paycheck; if they miss one, they will go into bankruptcy. Some pro-capitalists are living in their parents’ basement because they cannot afford the rent for a room.

    #266978

    Just a note, we use the words socialism and communism interchangeably, as society based on the common ownership and democratic control of the means of producing and distributing wealth. In the 19th century, they both meant the same thing. When the Bolsheviks launched their coup, and began organising “communist” parties, the Socialist Party speakers avoided the term, to avoid confusion with Leninists. But what we advocate could equally be called communism.

    It will be run democratically, since the majority of people will have a clear idea of what common ownership means they will organise accordingly, and with a desire for freedom that means that counter domination strategies will be deployed to ensure that elected bodies and delegated functions don’t become a means of recreating the state.

    Finally, we don’t want a welfare state: we’d rather argue for what we want and not get it than argue for something we don’t want and get that.

    #266979
    robbo203
    Participant

    “Then there’s free access. Would people really contribute according to their abilities and take only what they need? Who is going to decide what each individual needs, or do eight billion people each decide for themselves? What happens when resources are scarce, people disagree about priorities, or some people simply don’t want to contribute? Does everyone really get what they each think they need, or do we sink to the lowest common denominator in the interests of equality?

    Advocating a society based on common ownership and free access is one thing. Explaining how it would actually function is another.”

    These are the kinds of stock arguments socialists often encounter from people unfamiliar with the case for free-access socialism/communism. They rest on all sorts of highly dubious assumptions.

    Human beings are depicted as inherently “greedy”, implying that a socialist society is unattainable because it somehow requires us to abandon this ingrained trait we have and become virtuous angels driven by purely altruistic motives. I have encountered this same stock argument time and time again….

    If only it were true that workers were more strongly motivated by self-interest and class interests than they currently are! It seems to be a case of inordinate altruism on their part that they allow a system of capitalist exploitation to continue at their expense.

    The point that needs to be made is that any and every form of human society depends on a mixture of both egoistic and altruistic motives. That includes socialism as well.

    It is not just altruistic values that would allow a socialist society to function but also egoistic values – or, if you prefer, “enlightened self-interest”.

    It is in the interest of workers to establish a socialist society and, therefore, by extension, to ensure that it works. Grandpa seems to think workers are inherently greedy and therefore free-access socialism will break down at the first opportunity. This shows a complete lack of sociological imagination on his part – a tendency to project the consumerist values of capitalism onto a socialist society.

    I don’t drink more water than I need from a public water fountain, just because it’s free and plentiful. In capitalism, status equates with material wealth, and so you can understand why it is today that someone like the Sultan of Brunei is said to possess a collection of 7000 cars. What’s the point of such stupidity in a free-access society?

    Such a society will not be a perfect society — there is no such thing as a “perfect society” — but it will be a damn sight better than what we’ve got today.

    There will be trade-offs. While we certainly have the means to meet all our basic needs, we may well have to rein in some of our more extravagant wants, assuming we even continue to want them. Having our basic needs met takes the edge off wanting more.

    In the more affluent Western countries, most workers’ basic needs are more or less met today. The problem is not so much quantitative as qualitative — the growing sense of insecurity, for example. This is what we should focus on more. The quality of life. This is where free access socialism scores heavily over contemporary capitalism.

    There are other aspects of the so-called human nature argument against socialism that are likewise untenable. For example, the claim that we are intrinsically lazy and that no one will work if they can just help themselves to whatever they want is just so laughably inept when you look at the argument up close.

    Even today, most work is done completely outside the money sector. Furthermore, would a working class that has knowingly and intentionally established a socialist society go about undoing the very thing that it had striven so hard to establish? I don’t think so. Needless to say, the movement to establish such a society will bring about a sea change in values and outlook.

    The point I finally want to make is that, given that these kinds of objections that people like Grandpa make are quite commonplace, might there not be a case for the SPGB to publish a pamphlet explicitly focused on the human nature argument? I know we have pamphlets in stock, like “Are We Prisoners of Our Genes?”, but they don’t address the arguments in the direct, explicit way required.

    A new pamphlet dealing explicitly with the human nature argument and its two main subcategories — the “lazy person argument” and the “greedy person argument” — would be a welcome addition to the stock of literature

    #266980
    GrandpaGB
    Participant

    I’ve got to agree with you Grandpa, it doesn’t look to me like you are using AI. I come across a lot of AI through work and although your contribution has a look of it, you’re grammar has some pretty obvious flaws.

    AI usually has good (although more US based) grammar.

    More that happy to discuss your “points”, although I’m up to my eyes with work at the moment and have a few posts about Freud to add before I get a chance to send some stuff across.

    I might be wrong, but you seem to be hinting at the Von Mises Economic Calculation argument. Could you clarify if that is part of your argument? It might aid discussion.

    If I was writing an article to be published it would be grammar perfect, off the top of my head posts don’t get the same level of attention.

    To be honest I’d never heard of the Von Mises Economic Calculation argument. I try to stay away from centuries old political and economic arguments because they were meant for another era and usually sound odd in a modern 21st century society.

    I’d consider myself a realist and a pragmatist as opposed to someone caught up in a blind faith belief system. I thank my lucky stars that I was born into a welfare system which the old socialists like Bevan and Attlee fought so hard for, but admit I too would have been a communist in the 1930s. I take note of Huxley’s “Brave New World “where everything is free and I think, be careful what you wish for.

    #266981
    GrandpaGB
    Participant

    Just a quick question Grandpa.

    In another thread you say that:

    “What large industries we had left Thatcher destroyed in the 80s”

    By saying “we” I assume you were part of the ownership of those industries.

    Which part of the “large industries” did you own?

    We as in the royal we. Thatcher was speaking on behalf of the majority who voted for the Conservatives.

    #266983
    Bijou Drains
    Participant

    So when you say “we” you don’t mean we, you actually mean “they”.

    If, for example, owned British Rail, why did we have to pay to use it?

    If it was ours why did the government have to pay on going payments to the previous owners of the railway companies, ship building companies, coal owners, etc.

    The fact is, the mine owners, for instance, continued to take their share of the surplus value produced by miners, without having any of the complications of having to run the system themselves.

    Most of the coal owners in the area I live in were rubbing their hands in glee at the prospect of nationalisation, back in the 1940s

    #266984
    Bijou Drains
    Participant

    Grandpa “Thatcher was speaking on behalf of the majority who voted for the Conservatives.”

    This actually demonstrates the paucity of your research and your ability to use words inaccurately.

    Thatcher got 43.9% of the votes in 1979, 42.4% in 1983 and 42.2% in 1987.

    That is not a majority, it’s a plurality.

    If, as you say, been teaching Wnglish to non English speakers, it sounds to me like you’ve been stealing a living for a lot of years.

    #266985

    Mod note:
    @Bijou: that’s dangerously close to a personal attack, pull back please.

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 80 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.