China and Statism
November 2026 › Forums › General discussion › China and Statism
- This topic has 91 replies, 8 voices, and was last updated 1 week, 1 day ago by
Movimiento Socialista Mundial.
-
AuthorPosts
-
October 29, 2026 at 1:41 pm #267009
GrandpaGB
ParticipantChina is politically communist with a regulated capitalist economy. Regulated means that the individual capital to create more wealth is allowed, but the excess and exploitation found in western capitalism is controlled. Governments do not create wealth, they distribute the wealth of others, albeit often unfairly, but government didn’t invent the combustion engine, penicillin or the light bulb.
When Communism Met Capitalism
Following Mao’s death in 1976, two years later Deng Xiaoping overturned just about every policy Mao had implemented and abandoned the class struggle. He created a “Socialist Market Economy” which wasn’t a free market as we know it, but state regulated capitalism often referred to as statism. Gorbachev’s economic reforms (perestroika) during the last days of the USSR also tried to implement limited private enterprise and private market initiatives, but too little too late.
In just over thirty years after Mao’s death, China surpassed the U.S. to become the world’s leading exporter in 2009 (BBC), with a GDP of 11.1% (Reuters). In that thirty three year period China lifted an estimated 500 to 600 million people out of poverty (World Bank Group) and despite western restrictions on Chinese firms, in 2025 it’s GDP was 5.1%. Britain’s GDP was 1.4%.
China didn’t abandon capitalism, it embraced it and made it work for the country and not just the individual. The price paid is living in a police state. China makes no attempt to boast of democracy and freedom of the individual, it’s collectivised and patriotic to a level unheard of in Britain since WW2.
Living in China
China subsidises essentials such as basic foods, transport, utilities, accommodation … so that even those at the bottom aren’t left out. As people progress with promotions or wage rises they want to buy more such as a computer, foreign foods or a car. These are classed as non-essential items and are heavily taxed. This tax helps subsidise the essential basics for everyone.
Conversely, in the west people are subjected to market forces. As prices rise it produces more poverty as people are priced out of the consumer market. This is what you’re seeing now in the soaring cost of living and is the visible and ugly side of laissez faire capitalism.
The point being made is that China has proved that regulated capitalism works and the USSR proved that a society without capitalism didn’t work. China’s success shows that capitalism is a reliable tool for generating wealth, but provided the state remains its master rather than its servant.
October 29, 2026 at 2:00 pm #267012Thomas_More
ParticipantStandard textbook mythology.
October 29, 2026 at 2:23 pm #267014GrandpaGB
ParticipantStandard textbook mythology.
Hardly out of a textbook, I was there. Which part of it don’t you agree with?
October 29, 2026 at 2:57 pm #267015LBird
ParticipantGrandpaGB, I’d be interested to read your comments about this thread:
October 29, 2026 at 3:00 pm #267016Bijou Drains
ParticipantAnd as Chinese capitalism develops from feudalism, through state capitalism and its current system of capitalism with the hegemony of the political classes, the emerging private capitalist class will start to become dissatisfied with moving to answer to the CP praetorian guard.
They will also recognise, as did Adam Smith, Riccardo and others, that effectively tax is a levy on capital. There will be increasing pressure on the CP to step back, reduce taxes to increase profitability.
Chinese manufacturers do not set prices in a vacuum. As other manufacturers become more competitive, the profit margins for Chinese capital will become smaller and sections of the capitalist class will argue for greater democracy (a settled democracy without the cost of a police state, is far cheaper for the state machine).
The Chinese “Communist” party will have completed the historic role (which they probably weren’t aware of) of laying the foundations of the transition from feudalism and warlordism into capitalism. Just as the Parliamentarians did in England, the revolutionaries of France did during the revolutionary period, the Bolsheviks did in Russia, the republicans in Sinn Fein did in Ireland and which the Workers Party of Vietnam are also working towards.
The Parliamentarianists use the ideology of Protestantism, the French Revolutionaries used the ideology of the enlightenment, Sinn Fein used the mythology of the Gaelic revival and Lenin, Mao and Le Duan used the ideology of Communism as window dressing for their movements. Regardless of their alleged ideologies, economic and social development forced them to follow the same path.
-
This reply was modified 2 weeks, 6 days ago by
Bijou Drains.
October 29, 2026 at 3:22 pm #267018Thomas_More
ParticipantLots of people are there. I’ve met Chinese who have never heard of the Ch’ing dynasty.
One doesn’t jump social systems like one jumps on a hop scotch ground.
Social systems evolve, each within its predecessor. The huge former empires of China and Russia, in both of which the national bourgeoisie was small and weak, and which were under the necessity of modernising rapidly in order to compete on world markets with the established capitalist nation-states, could only do so if the state itself took on the task of building capitalism: as per Lenin’s model.
Even during the Sino-Japanese War, capitalists were moving their workshops and factories into the Red areas, as more conducive to their businesses than the Chiang regime.
By the late 1970s the Maoist cocoon had produced a fully-fledged capitalism, just as the Bolshevik state capitalist cocoon had done in Russia.
The same processes had been followed by Mao in China and Stalin in Russia (but much more rapidly) as were carried out in Tudor England: the mass expropriation of the peasantry and other landholders (in Russia and China forced into so-called “communes” run by the state, rather than thrown onto the streets as in England), so, being forcefully deprived of the means of production for themselves, rather than on behalf of the state machine, they would have to work for the latter. China’s and Russia’s “Communist” party high officials thus became the capitalist class of those states, eventually ditching the Bolshevik model which had served its purpose.
The revolutions in Russia and China were capitalist revolutions, even though not initiated by the bourgeoisie itself.(Neither was Japan’s revolution initiated by its bourgeoisie (which was the lowest and most despised class in the country) but by the Satsuma and Chōshu samurai class.)
October 29, 2026 at 3:33 pm #267019Thomas_More
ParticipantBijou, have to stop you on ” And as Chinese capitalism develops from feudalism.”
Chinese feudalism had been absorbed in the Chin dynasty into a landlord meritocracy. This was a form of what Marx called “the Asiatic mode of production”, which he was examining when he died so couldn’t finish.
Mao wrongly saddled China with the European scenario, in which capitalism did emerge from feudalism, and this has become the myth preached by the Chinese “Communist” Party. But feudalism hadn’t existed in China since the third century BCE.
(You will need to press translate. I wrote this article in Occitan).-
This reply was modified 2 weeks, 6 days ago by
Thomas_More.
October 29, 2026 at 4:31 pm #267022GrandpaGB
ParticipantGrandpaGB, I’d be interested to read your comments about this thread:
Which post, there are many of them.
People are arguing their ideological positions of markets and using Marxism to try to explain Maoism. Once we ruled the roost, then the U.S. took over and now China is rising. All dominant countries have a shelf life, all rise and fall, but what China has shown is that controlled capitalism can work. Let Marx explain that one away.
October 29, 2026 at 4:51 pm #267024Thomas_More
ParticipantThere’s that “we” again. So I take it you will be handing yourself over to the authorities in Beijing and demanding they punish you with death for starting the Opium Wars, helping the Manchu throne to crush the T’aip’ings, and deliberately diverting arms supplies meant for Canton to the warlord of Kwangtung?
The children in Liverpool’s cotton mills will have been gratified to hear they ruled the roost.
-
This reply was modified 2 weeks, 6 days ago by
Thomas_More.
-
This reply was modified 2 weeks, 6 days ago by
Thomas_More.
October 29, 2026 at 5:47 pm #267031Bijou Drains
ParticipantGood to hear from you L Bird
Haven’t heard from you for a while, I hope life is treating you as well as it can.
October 29, 2026 at 5:57 pm #267033GrandpaGB
ParticipantThere’s that “we” again. So I take it you will be handing yourself over to the authorities in Beijing and demanding they punish you with death for starting the Opium Wars, helping the Manchu throne to crush the T’aip’ings, and deliberately diverting arms supplies meant for Canton to the warlord of Kwangtung?
The children in Liverpool’s cotton mills will have been gratified to hear they ruled the roost.
On a British website I take it we’re British? The ‘we’ meaning Britain. You have to read the ‘we’ in context with what’s being said, so no not me as an individual or the factory workers, but the government of the country which represented us. There’s another one for you, ‘us’. And no, I wasn’t responsible for the opium wars and I’m not interested in semantics. So anyway, which part of the op didn’t you agree with?
October 29, 2026 at 6:35 pm #267036Thomas_More
Participant” the government of the country which represented us. ”
Governments do not represent the working class, even though the working class are duped into electing them. Governments represent the capitalist interests of the nation-state. So when one uses “we” one is identifying with the exploiting class. Unless you are a capitalist? I don’t mean someone who just supports capitalism, but someone who lives on rent, interest and profit, surplus value, on the shoulders of the workers.
-
This reply was modified 2 weeks, 6 days ago by
Thomas_More.
October 29, 2026 at 8:32 pm #267047GrandpaGB
Participant” the government of the country which represented us. ”
Governments do not represent the working class, even though the working class are duped into electing them. Governments represent the capitalist interests of the nation-state. So when one uses “we” one is identifying with the exploiting class. Unless you are a capitalist? I don’t mean someone who just supports capitalism, but someone who lives on rent, interest and profit, surplus value, on the shoulders of the workers.
I’m afraid the government do represent us. Whoever it is they’re the one people voted for. If the SPGB was voted in wouldn’t some committee represent us? No, I never owned a business, or ever had someone work for me. I’ve worked for what I’ve got and I’m not about to give it away for some fairy tale of sharing it with the world. Count in the rest of the workers in Britain who also feel the same way.
October 29, 2026 at 8:34 pm #267048GrandpaGB
ParticipantBut back to China …
Results matter. Capitalism is blamed for our ills, but then look at China and there are no explanations for how they successfully used capitalism to make their economy boom and remove hundreds of millions from poverty with not a Marxist in sight.
Shall we stop for a moment and remember the tens of millions who went into mass graves as a result of those following Marx’s teachings?
Perhaps we should move away from centuries old ideologies and focus more on what works? Call the Chinese way the real post-capitalism to replace our ailing laissez faire capitalism and be thankful for our welfare society?
Surely, the lesson is that economic systems should be judged by the prosperity they deliver, rather than by the ideological purity of the theories behind them.
October 29, 2026 at 10:21 pm #267051Bijou Drains
ParticipantI think, Grandpa, you mistake Mao’s and similarly Stalin’s collectivisation with anything Marx wrote.
In fact primative accumulation was Marx’s term for the historical process of divorcing direct producers—such as peasants and artisans—from their means of production and livelihood.
Which was exactly what Mao and Stalin undertook, under the cloak of “Marxism”
Effectively, primitive accumulation is the basis of the transition from precapitalist modes of production (like feudalism and subsistence farming) into the capitalist mode of production.
Marx rejected classical economists (like Adam Smith) who claimed capitalism started through peaceful individual thrift and hard work.
Instead, Marx argued it was born through violent conquest, enslavement, robbery, and state coercion.
It’s hard to believe that Marx would be so damning of the process of accumulation in the British Isles (if you have any integrity you would read the opening 1/3 of Volume One of Das Kapital, before you make foolishly say that Mao was somehow following Marx’s blueprint.
By being forcibly driven off the land (such as through the English enclosure movements, the Highland Clearances, etc.), people were “freed” in two ways: freed from feudal ties and freed from any ownership of land or tools. With no way to self-subsist, they had to sell their labour power as a wage-labourers.
This was exactly the same process that happened in the UK, Russia, China, the far east, etc.
All of this was accompanied by Bloody Legislation, in the UK Governments passed harsh laws (whipping, branding, and forced labor) in the 15th and 16th centuries to discipline the newly created landless class into accepting wage labour. In China and Russia the process was even more brutal.
The same argument you are using, “look how prosperous we are” was used in the UK even up to the 1950 – 60s (MacMillan’s “affluent society”)
As Marx wrote, capital comes into the world “dripping from head to toe, from every pore, with blood and dirt”
It’s the same in China, as in the UK, Russia.
And if you think the USA, is any different try reading books such as Bury my Heart at Wounded Knee
-
This reply was modified 2 weeks, 6 days ago by
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
