Introducing Grandpa

November 2026 › Forums › General discussion › Introducing Grandpa

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 33 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #266867
    GrandpaGB
    Participant

    I’m Grandpa, a retired teacher who worked for many years in China and SE Asia. I don’t know whether I’ll fit in here, but let’s give it a go.

    I’m an ‘Old Skool’ socialist in that I believe essential public services such as public transport, the utilities and the NHS should be run by an elected government and not some Del Boy characters looking for rich pickings at the expense of everyone else.

    I believe in the Beveridge Report of 1942, which outlined plans to address the ‘five giants’ of want, disease, ignorance, squalor and idleness and formed the basis for the introduction of the Welfare State between 1945 and 1951.

    And why not? That we can all read and write, have access to free medical care and no one is starving to death on the streets is a welfare system that Marx would have cut off his right hand for.

    I believe in dealing with the real world, not some utopian communist fantasy where eight billion people live in a wageless society, share everything and live happily ever after. It’s never going to happen. I’d rather stick with old-fashioned socialism that works in practice and which millions around the world can only dream of.

    • This topic was modified 3 weeks ago by Young Master Smeet. Reason: Not off topic, socialism generally is the topic
    #266869

    We’re against ‘rich pickings’ for the tiny minority as well. But we also consider that whoever runs the public services, the overall system of production for profit will continue. As long, that is, as the workers of the world (i.e. the vast majority) don’t get together to bring in a completely new system of society – moneyless, wageless, stateless and based on from each according to ability to each according to need. That was actually Marx’s vision too and I wonder whether he would really have been surprised that capitalism would be able to deliver a lot more than it was doing in his day? The important thing, however, is that it’s still capitalism, a system that still prevents us from realising the abundance that the modern world could readily deliver under that different kind of system. As for whether our (and Marx’s) view of socialism is a utopia, well forever it will be until the Grandpas of this world decide to be part of making it a reality. Things do change over history after all. Remember Ursula Le Guin’s words: ‘We live in capitalism, its power seems inescapable. But so did the Divine Right of Kings.’

    #266886
    GrandpaGB
    Participant

    “From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs” and “Workers of the world, unite; you have nothing to lose but your chains” isn’t socialism, it’s communism, which has a proven track record of failure. So has the idea of a borderless society, which has turned into a disaster for Europe.

    And who is to manage this “moneyless, wageless, stateless” society? That’s why it wouldn’t work because whoever it is, self-interest dictates they will feather their own nest before they feather yours and you’re back to an elite rule.

    What did capitalism and the Del Boy elites of today replace? Feudalism and its lords and nobility. Go back even further and we get the Roman slave-based economy run on capitalism before it was even invented by the Emperor, the Senate, and landowners.

    The last person who tried what you’re suggesting was Cambodia’s Pol Pot who in the late 1970s decided to force a return to Year Zero and socially engineer a society built on what you’re suggesting. That failed and left a quarter of the population dead.

    I understand where you’re coming from, but the objective should be to curb the power of the capitalist elites; those who exploit others for their own personal greed. The vast majority of people won’t give up the right to own individual wealth, or property rights, or democracy. You will never get rid of capitalism; the nearest you’ll get is to keep the greedy away from the welfare system and re-nationalise the essential services.

    Marx got it wrong by the way. It wasn’t about class, it was culture and why you rarely see the workers out in the streets protesting any more. They were replaced by Gramsci’s Cultural Marxism and the minorities as the new revolutionaries.

    #266910

    Amazing. Where do I start? Somewhere far back, I think, with someone who doesn’t seem to have got very far with thinking things through. (Sorry, I don’t mean to be rude, so please forgive me if I am being)

    First. Marx used ‘socialism’ and ‘communism’ synonymously and so do we. They’re both a society based on what you say: ‘From each according to ability, to each according to needs’.

    Second. That kind of society doesn’t have ‘a proven track record of failure’, because it’s never been tried.

    Third. Europe is definitely not a ‘borderless society’ in the way that we conceive of that. It may have a common currency but it’s got loads of borders and anyway you seemed to be saying in your last message that things were pretty good as they were (so presumably despite the imagined lack of borders) and that it was just a few tweaks that were needed.

    Fourth. ‘Self-interest’ is a form of behaviour characteristic of capitalism because its dog-eat-dog nature pushes people towards it. All the evidence is that the kinds of society that have existed for at least 95% of the 300,000 years that homo sapiens has been around (mainly hunter-gatherers) were egalitarian and characterised by cooperation and sharing. The same of course applied to so many everyday interactions between people even in today’s society, and even when they’ve nothing material to gain – and this despite the pressures of capitalism.

    Fifth. To describe the Pol Pot’s regime as anything in any way resembling the kind of society we advocate (please have a look at the stuff on our website) is just off the wall. To say that they tried to ‘socially engineer a society built on what you’re suggesting’ is profoundly absurd. We’re not suggesting ‘social engineering’ in any shape or form, we’re suggesting voluntary cooperation on a democratic basis. Again have a look at our website.

    Sixth. We don’t need to ‘curb the power of the capitalist elites’. We need to remove that power – democratically by a large majority of people voting for something else. Nationalisation might be of some assistance to some people in some cases, but in the end – as history as shown – the best reforms like that can do is to tinker at the edges of the problems that capitalism inevitably throws up – poverty, insecurity, war, for example. You assert that we’ll never get rid of capitalism, but how can you know that? I’ll refer you again to Ursula Le Guin’s words and the fact that change happens when the circumstances dictate and require it.

    Seventh. You’re not the first to say that ‘Marx got it wrong’ (even if he actually he did get some of it wrong), but you’re surely not placing yourself on the level of one of the most profound thinkers of the last 200 years. Society is still about class and workers not coming out on the streets to protest (even if some of them are doing that at the moment in ‘borderless Europe’) has nothing to do with it, since, as I say, the socialist revolution will not be that kind of thing. It will be about the vast majority asserting their will through democratic means.

    Eighth. As for Gramsci and so-called ‘cultural Marxism’, well don’t get me started. I’ve spent a significant part of my life studying Gramsci and, despite his defects, at bottom he wasn’t denying the class struggle but simply saying that workers of all kinds and from all social milieux need to get together to enact change.

    #266922
    GrandpaGB
    Participant

    The Failure of Communism
    Why amazing? Don’t worry, I’ve heard all the excuses about why communism didn’t work, but it will next time. I do think things through, but I stopped believing socially engineered utopias of whatever political persuasion could succeed a long time ago. From the USSR, to Pol Pot and onto today’s Kim Jong-Un, it wasn’t through a lack of trying and yes, maybe from original good intentions but they all turned into bloodthirsty dictatorships and failed.

    Open borders
    The EU does have open borders as a result of the Schengen Treaty. You can travel from Spain in the south to Sweden in the north, over two thousand miles away and through two or three countries and not be stopped at any border. I don’t believe I said things were good, what I said was, “So has the idea of a borderless society, which has turned into a disaster for Europe.”

    Self-Interest
    “Self-interest” has been around for as long as humans have existed. The pre-historic man didn’t give the cloak he’d made from wolf skins to his neighbour in the next cave, he bartered it for a hunting spear, or two if he could get them. Although egalitarianism existed in primitive societies as a means of survival, there has never been a society based totally on equality and altruism.

    Pol Pot and a self-sufficient, classless, communist society
    I’m sure Pol Pot never envisaged what his society would become. What’s the saying? “The road to hell is paved with good intentions?” He’s the nearest to what you’re advocating, a self-sufficient, classless, communist society.

    I remember visiting the Genocidal Center near Phnom Penh and before that ‘ The Road of Bones’ on what is now the R504 Kolymar Highway near Yakutsk and entering a couple of the old remaining camps. Later on a visit, having to bow before statues of the Kim dynasty in Pyongyang (what a dump that was). All are must see destinations for anyone dreaming about creating a communist utopia and pretending it’s socialism.

    Capitalism
    You are never going to vote capitalism out. In the 2024 general election the SPGB contested two constituencies and won 193 votes between them. In New Forest East, The Mad Hatter from The Monster Raving Loony Party got 529 votes! Many people dislike laissez faire capitalism, myself included, but the vast majority won’t vote for communism because that’s what you’re advocating whilst trying to pretend it’s something else.
    2024. Labour: 404 seats. Conservative: 118. Reform: 8. SPGB: 0.

    Marx
    Marx describes capitalism brilliantly. Even today it’s impossible to do a degree in the political sciences without Marx. Where he errs is when he begins to offer alternatives. Remember that Marx was writing in a time of European absolute monarchs and absolute poverty. ‘Bread for the workers’ sounds as outdated today as the Americans still cheering for revolutionary militias.

    The workers are not coming out into the streets of Europe. What started as a protest against the cost of living and cut-backs was quickly taken over by communists, anarchists and Islamists. The irony is that social-liberal Macron, cheerleader for the EU and formerly a member of the Socialist Party is now behind far-right Le Pen in the presidential race.

    Gramsci
    You’ll have read Gramsci’s ‘Prison Notebooks’ then. He’s the one who answered Lenin’s question of why the western proletariat weren’t rising up all over Europe. This was before Stalin came to power and communism was still widely regarded as an alternative. Gramsci was the one who discovered it was culture, including patriotism and not class which provided the cohesion that held society’s together. If the workers weren’t interested he proposed the minorities replace them and from Blair onwards that’s what you see today. Gone are the workers protests of the 60s and 70s.

    Cultural Marxism
    Every society is built on culture as its foundation. This includes language, religion, identity, values, traditions … Dilute or remove these and the foundations on which that society was built collapses.

    It’s not only capitalism which is destroying society it’s the anarchy of Cultural Marxism which is changing the social structure. Who would have thought a creep like Farage would ever be a realistic contender for PM, or Tommy Robinson would bring an estimated one million plus out into the streets in his ‘Unite the Kingdom’ march? There’s the backlash to smashing capitalism and the response to Cultural Marxism.

    #266925

    Rarely (if ever) have I come across anyone so mixed up while at the same time thinking he knows everything about everything (he’s even become an anthropologist now). And you just bat away pretty offensively all attempts to propose anything even marginally different from what’s already floating in your mind. I’ve had many discussions with people vehemently opposed to our arguments but never in the course of these have I heard us compared to Pol Pot. You need to focus your mind a little instead of swimming in platitudes.

    You said at the beginning: ‘I don’t know whether I’ll fit in here’, when it was clear from your very first post that you knew very well you wouldn’t and that your main purpose was to taunt. So please do it elsewhere.

    #266926
    ste finch
    Participant

    Howard, pity you had to waste time with this chap. He obviously hasn’t got a clue about the SPGB’s position.

    #266927
    GrandpaGB
    Participant

    I used to teach social and political science and I seem to have hit a raw nerve. Perhaps I’m not the usual wet behind the ears member you thought I would be if you want to debate politics? You haven’t got an argument, you stated your points and are now stamping your foot when challenged and saying it’s taunting.

    What you’re promoting is not socialism, they’re ideas so bizarre that when your classless, self-sufficient, anti-capitalist society was tried in Cambodia it resulted in genocide! That’s fact; you and Pol Pot would have got on like a house on fire.
    If Marx were alive today I wonder what he’d say about the maniacs in the 20th century who followed his theories?

    In my first post I outlined who I was and the kind of socialism I believed in. You’re the one who piled in with a “moneyless, wageless, stateless and based on from each according to ability to each according to need …” communist society.

    Having done a little digging, I’m sure you’re also aware that since the SPGB started to get involved through the ballot box in 1945, they’ve never won a single seat in parliament, or a by-election. Or that in the recent Clacton by-election, Count Binface, a man with a bin on his head, won more popular votes in one by-election than the SPGB has in its history?

    Perhaps it’s not just me you’re not convincing? If you have an ideological position and a world view you should be able to defend it, but in your case obviously not.

    #266928

    ‘Howard, pity you had to waste time with this chap. He obviously hasn’t got a clue about the SPGB’s position.’

    No, and in his confusion he seems determined not to find out either. Is he just a troll or is he someone who, in his retirement, is looking for something to fill his time?

    #266929
    GrandpaGB
    Participant

    Howard, pity you had to waste time with this chap. He obviously hasn’t got a clue about the SPGB’s position.

    I’m now aware of SPGB’s position, but it’s not enough to state it, explain it. Tell me where it’s been tried and succeeded, how it would be implemented because it won’t be through the ballot box, how will it be managed and by whom? I can only compare what I’ve heard so far to the MAGA crazies in America who just repeat their beliefs like a mantra.

    #266931
    GrandpaGB
    Participant

    No, and in his confusion he seems determined not to find out either. Is he just a troll or is he someone who, in his retirement, is looking for something to do?

    I’ve already found out, you’ve told me. Good heavens, don’t you ever get mixed up in real politics, you won’t stand a chance. So if you don’t like being challenged move on to your echo chamber, but I’m probably the biggest excitement you’ve had here for years. 🙂

    #266934

    If you have a good look at this site, you’ll see it’s far from being an echo chamber. But it IS a place of meaningful – and even exciting – discussion.

    #266938

    Grandpa,

    you’re arguing against positions we don’t hold.

    1: We argue that socialism can only come about when the overwhelming majority of people *understand* and *want* it, and this can *only* be done democratically. This also answers your question of ‘who would manage’ socialism, it would be everyone, democratically and freely, without coercion. Hence why comparisons with groups where someone has seized power as a minority are invalid.
    2: You might find our pamphlet “Beveridge re-organises poverty” interesting (https://www.worldsocialism.org/spgb/pamphlet/beveridge-re-organises-poverty/).
    3: Our object is very simple: “The establishment of a system of society based upon the common ownership and democratic control of the means and instruments for producing and distributing wealth by and in the interest of the whole community.” Now, that community is 8 billion strong, but it can be done.

    #266940
    robbo203
    Participant

    GrandpaGB

    I would echo the sentiments that others have expressed here. Sorry, but you haven’t got a clue (yet) what the SPGB is about. Since you’ve visited this site, it’s worth being a little more open-minded and receptive to what this organisation is saying.

    I won’t repeat what others have already said, but I’ll make two simple points in response to some of what you have said.

    Firstly, this thing about so-called “communist” Cambodia under Pol Pot, you should know very well that the SPGB does not consider this regime remotely “communist”. Shallow commentary points to the alleged absence of money under the Khmer Rouge as proof of its “communist” character.

    Even if it were true that the regime was a moneyless one, the mere absence of money does not equate with communism (and by communism I mean the Marxist definition of communism as a synonym for socialism and not how the Washington Consensus defines “communism” – it seems you are going along with the latter definition and disregard the former).

    For us the mere absence of money does NOT signify Marxian communism. The Inca Empire was a large-scale aristocratic-based society that operated without money. By your dodgy logic, it could be construed as a “communist” social formation. Needless to say, this would be risible.

    Apart from that, the claim that Cambodia abolished money is highly questionable. See, for example, this

    Was Money Abolished in Cambodia?

    But Marxian communism, as (opposed to your preferred Washington version) stands for an awful lot more than the mere absence of money. Communism means a moneyless, wageless, classless and stateless alternative to all forms of capitalism.

    The Soviet Union was very clearly a capitalist social formation since it was based on those twin core features that define capitalism — generalised wage labour and commodity production. The Soviet Union was a state capitalist social formation, in other words.

    Whether the Khmer regime can be called state capitalist is debatable, but it most certainly was NOT a post-capitalist communist society. It was a class-based statist society in which individuals’ relationship to the means of production was grotesquely unequal.

    Further, Marxists hold that a communist society cannot be achieved unless and until the majority want it and understand it. It cannot be imposed from above by some Leninist vanguard. It is pretty obvious that the Cambodian population prior to the Khmer Rouge taking over was in no way communist-minded. So Marxian communism was out of the question.

    If anything, the situation in Cambodia could be described as a lapse into a pre-capitalist state of affairs, not a post-capitalist society.

    The other point I wanted to pick up on was your jibe about the lack of support for the SPGB. Of course, we acknowledge that only a relatively tiny fraction of the population supports what we advocate. It’s not a comfortable position to be in, but it won’t deter us from advocating what we believe is right.

    However, I get the impression from what you are saying that you look upon the SPGB as if it were in an equivalent position to what a reformist political party — like the Labour Party or the Greens, perhaps — and that you imagine our political significance might be enhanced even if only we went about offering a more attractive programme to the electorate.

    This is a complete misunderstanding of where the SPGB is coming from. We are not “offering” anything. We are not making any kind of “promises” to the electorate whatsoever. We have zero interest in “getting into power” based on a programme of reforms that would make us more electable in the electorate’s eyes.

    We are ordinary workers who have concluded that we need a radically different kind of society from the one we live in, which has long passed its sell-by date and now threatens humanity with multiple crises that could even lead to our species becoming extinct in the worst case.

    Yes, the SPGB has made little headway thus far—we can’t argue with that—but this failure is also a failure of our class as a whole to overthrow the yoke of a capitalist, class-based society.

    The question is whether you want to keep the status quo or work with us to overthrow this system by spreading the idea of a genuine alternative. It’s that simple

    #266945
    GrandpaGB
    Participant

    What the SPGB says it is and what it actually is are two different things. Of course it’s going to distance itself from failures. My point was that what Pol Pot wanted and what you’re suggesting are the same thing. Followed by a link to your own site? Which is like saying Trump is the most intelligent man on earth with a link to him saying it.

    Secondly, I don’t use the multitude of subjective beliefs as to what communism is, or isn’t. I’ve lived and been to various communist countries and I know exactly what communism is.

    All Marxists do not hold that communism can only be achieved through a consensus. That’s an SPGB position.

    My comment that the SPGB lacked any kind of public support wasn’t a jibe, it was fact. It was to say you’ve moved so far away from socialism that you’re now a fringe group along the lines of The Flat Earth Society. If you’re not interested in getting into power, why do you put up candidates in elections?

    My position is the one I outlined in my first post. We have a welfare system and our aim should be to keep the private sector away from it. Surely, you must realise that a cashless, wageless and stateless world of eight billion running it is never going to happen? In which case, why keep flogging a dead horse? Yes, I’m against laissez faire capitalism and if it was up to me I’d put the capitalist Del Boys in an Amazon warehouse for a 12 hour shift on a minimum wage and see how they like it. But that’s never going to happen either.

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 33 total)
  • The topic ‘Introducing Grandpa’ is closed to new replies.