GrandpaGB
Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
GrandpaGB
ParticipantI’ve got to agree with you Grandpa, it doesn’t look to me like you are using AI. I come across a lot of AI through work and although your contribution has a look of it, you’re grammar has some pretty obvious flaws.
AI usually has good (although more US based) grammar.
More that happy to discuss your “points”, although I’m up to my eyes with work at the moment and have a few posts about Freud to add before I get a chance to send some stuff across.
I might be wrong, but you seem to be hinting at the Von Mises Economic Calculation argument. Could you clarify if that is part of your argument? It might aid discussion.
If I was writing an article to be published it would be grammar perfect, off the top of my head posts don’t get the same level of attention.
To be honest I’d never heard of the Von Mises Economic Calculation argument. I try to stay away from centuries old political and economic arguments because they were meant for another era and usually sound odd in a modern 21st century society.
I’d consider myself a realist and a pragmatist as opposed to someone caught up in a blind faith belief system. I thank my lucky stars that I was born into a welfare system which the old socialists like Bevan and Attlee fought so hard for, but admit I too would have been a communist in the 1930s. I take note of Huxley’s “Brave New World “where everything is free and I think, be careful what you wish for.
GrandpaGB
ParticipantI say we ignore him from now on. Don’t waste energy.
For someone who doesn’t like what I say you seem to a frequent visitor. Off you go then. 🙂
GrandpaGB
ParticipantI don’t do AI, I don’t need to. I just write about what I know from the top of my head. This is a forum 500 word throwaway post. I wouldn’t waste more than 30 minutes on a post.
Perhaps you’re not used to anything over a paragraph long? Or perhaps you’re just unhappy with what’s written, or maybe can’t understand it? No point attacking the poster. If you don’t understand something ask and if it’s a genuine question I’ll try to explain.
GrandpaGB
ParticipantI remember watching a documentary in which a former accomplice of Pol Pot burst into giggles when his interviewer referred to the Khmer Rouge as communists.
If Grandpa despises us as a tiny “utopian” group with no relevance, what is he doing here? Nothing better to do?
Currently, Grandpa is laughing at you. No seriously, doing a Q&A session.
Mao was a nationalist? The Maoist with the little red book and red flag? The Khmer Rouge (translated Red Cambodians) weren’t communists?… What planet are you people living on and you present yourselves as members of a credible political alternative? I don’t despise you, I’m just amazed that in the 21st century people with an education can have so little knowledge. I’m still waiting for one of you to pop-up and tell me Farage is a liberal democrat!
Perhaps many of you are Gen Z? That would explain the rebel without a cause and railing against the world attitude, as well as being gullible and open to influence by others as you gather together in little peer groups on the Internet.
If you were even faintly familiar with politics you wouldn’t come out with statements such as we’re not communists we just believe in Marx. Do you realise how stupid that sounds? Or, we believe in a cashless, equality based and stateless society, but we’re not Marxists.
You’re communists, why not just admit it? Is it because every time it’s been tried it’s failed and so you pretend communist societies aren’t communist but are something else? Anyway, instead of commenting against this very low level of knowledge, perhaps I should put up a quick post myself?
GrandpaGB
Participant” Yes, it was definitely a coup as it’s the only way these characters can get into power. You can add Castro, Mao and Lenin to that.”
In fact you are wrong about Castro and Mao. They were of course nationalists, not communists, and were carried to power by majority peasant support, not by coups.
Lenin and Trotsky did stage a coup.
In fact also, your ridiculous notion of socialism and communism being different things is pure Lenin.Castro and Mao were nationalists? Really? You mean like Mussolini, Franco and Hitler? The same Castro that allied itself with the USSR during the Cuban crisis, or the Mao that aided communist North Korea in the Korean war?
If you haven’t got the knowledge, use google. It’s generally useless at explanations, but good for facts.GrandpaGB
Participantgrand, well, we’d argue that the long postwar boom did more to raise wages and living conditions than the cheeseparing of the welfare state did: that plus the cheapening of the means of living that came about through worldwide productivity growth. When Labour last left power, inequality in the UK was pretty much the same as it had been in the 1930s: poverty wears a different face, but it is still very much there.
The postwar boom had nothing to do with the creation of the welfare state which was already up and running, but yes, wages rose and living conditions greatly improved by the 60s. Largely due to the welfare state. It’s why we use relative poverty figures now and not those of absolute poverty.
As our industrial era began to decline, other countries starting theirs made the west uncompetitive. What large industries we had left Thatcher destroyed in the 80s.
Depends what you mean by ‘inequality.’ Are you suggesting that poverty was worse at the end of the last Labour government in 2010 than it was in the 1930s Great Depression?
GrandpaGB
Participant“What the SPGB says it is and what it actually is are two different things. Of course it’s going to distance itself from failures.”
But, do you accept that those failures are of a completely different plan: a minority seizing power and forcing the population at gunpoint to enact their programme? We do not advocate that, and so absolutely do not consider those instances to be failure of what we advocate. Without the conscious and voluntary co-operation of the vast majority, you cannot build a democratic society of common ownership (indeed, Russia, China, Cambodia, etc. are proof of what we are saying, not a refutation).
As our Beveridge pamphlet shows, the welfare state is about rationalising insurance and saving the costs to the capitalist, it’s not a net benefit to the workers.
Yes, it was definitely a coup as it’s the only way these characters can get into power. You can add Castro, Mao and Lenin to that.
You don’t advocate the use of an armed overthrow, but you’ll never get in by the ballot box either. Stalemate.
The welfare State introduced a social security and healthcare system. It’s the reason you have a roof over your head, you’re not in absolute poverty, you get free healthcare at the point of deliver, a pension when you’re older and guaranteed an education under the 1944 Act.
You want to know what came before the Welfare State? Read Orwell’s ‘Down and Out in Paris and London’ or ‘The Road to Wigan Pier.’ That will open your eyes to what naked capitalism was really like and not today’s bleating of, he’s got more than me.
GrandpaGB
ParticipantGranpa wrote:
” Every society is built on culture as its foundation. This includes language, religion, identity, values, traditions … Dilute or remove these and the foundations on which that society was built collapses.”
Culture is not the foundation of a society but the expression, the superstructure, produced by the economic base. “The morality of a given society is the morality of its ruling class” – those who own and control the means of production. Identity, values etc., whether supportive of, or in opposition to, the prevalent social structure are all superstructure.
Oh stop it Thomas. That’d the biggest load of intellectual gobbledegook on this thread so far and a very near paraphrase of Marx.
GrandpaGB
ParticipantIf you have a good look at this site, you’ll see it’s far from being an echo chamber. But it IS a place of meaningful – and even exciting – discussion.
Let’s address the poster attacks first. In any discussion they’re the go to option when someone is losing an argument. No room for dissent in your democratic world where everyone has a say then? All must follow the party line?
Second, I’m not some nasty troll who’s suddenly appeared and is daring to criticise. I’m actually a big pussy cat, it’s just that I taught English and politics for a living in a communist country and visited others and I know communism disguised with socialism when I see it.
China
I looked through the Chinese thread because that’s an interest. The usual links to western sources from people who have never been there. Very little mention that the Chinese government has lifted hundreds of millions out of poverty, while western capitalism has put tens of millions in it. We could do with a bit of that statism in the west!The first post had a link to an article, “How China forgot Karl Marx.” China was never Marxist, it was Maoist and the difference is that Marx wrote about industrialised countries and the effects on the working classes and Mao about agrarian societies, so more about peasants and land reform.
Ukraine
Ukraine is also an interest. How on earth do you turn the Ukraine conflict into a class struggle against capitalism?! With the usual lemming like links to western media.RT News is banned in the west because they don’t want you to know the other side of the story. I use the free VPN in the Firefox browser. Or how about watching some filmed documentaries and learn what’s going on in the world first before you start talking politics; instead of being stuck in an echo chamber of fantasies about eight billion people sharing what they have and singing Kumbaya.
I’m convinced that if I wrote a short piece that Alice in Wonderland was actually a tale about being exploited by The Mad Hatter and The Cheshire Cat who were really capitalists, it would fit right in with the content here.
GrandpaGB
ParticipantWhat the SPGB says it is and what it actually is are two different things. Of course it’s going to distance itself from failures. My point was that what Pol Pot wanted and what you’re suggesting are the same thing. Followed by a link to your own site? Which is like saying Trump is the most intelligent man on earth with a link to him saying it.
Secondly, I don’t use the multitude of subjective beliefs as to what communism is, or isn’t. I’ve lived and been to various communist countries and I know exactly what communism is.
All Marxists do not hold that communism can only be achieved through a consensus. That’s an SPGB position.
My comment that the SPGB lacked any kind of public support wasn’t a jibe, it was fact. It was to say you’ve moved so far away from socialism that you’re now a fringe group along the lines of The Flat Earth Society. If you’re not interested in getting into power, why do you put up candidates in elections?
My position is the one I outlined in my first post. We have a welfare system and our aim should be to keep the private sector away from it. Surely, you must realise that a cashless, wageless and stateless world of eight billion running it is never going to happen? In which case, why keep flogging a dead horse? Yes, I’m against laissez faire capitalism and if it was up to me I’d put the capitalist Del Boys in an Amazon warehouse for a 12 hour shift on a minimum wage and see how they like it. But that’s never going to happen either.
GrandpaGB
ParticipantNo, and in his confusion he seems determined not to find out either. Is he just a troll or is he someone who, in his retirement, is looking for something to do?
I’ve already found out, you’ve told me. Good heavens, don’t you ever get mixed up in real politics, you won’t stand a chance. So if you don’t like being challenged move on to your echo chamber, but I’m probably the biggest excitement you’ve had here for years. 🙂
GrandpaGB
ParticipantHoward, pity you had to waste time with this chap. He obviously hasn’t got a clue about the SPGB’s position.
I’m now aware of SPGB’s position, but it’s not enough to state it, explain it. Tell me where it’s been tried and succeeded, how it would be implemented because it won’t be through the ballot box, how will it be managed and by whom? I can only compare what I’ve heard so far to the MAGA crazies in America who just repeat their beliefs like a mantra.
GrandpaGB
ParticipantI used to teach social and political science and I seem to have hit a raw nerve. Perhaps I’m not the usual wet behind the ears member you thought I would be if you want to debate politics? You haven’t got an argument, you stated your points and are now stamping your foot when challenged and saying it’s taunting.
What you’re promoting is not socialism, they’re ideas so bizarre that when your classless, self-sufficient, anti-capitalist society was tried in Cambodia it resulted in genocide! That’s fact; you and Pol Pot would have got on like a house on fire.
If Marx were alive today I wonder what he’d say about the maniacs in the 20th century who followed his theories?In my first post I outlined who I was and the kind of socialism I believed in. You’re the one who piled in with a “moneyless, wageless, stateless and based on from each according to ability to each according to need …” communist society.
Having done a little digging, I’m sure you’re also aware that since the SPGB started to get involved through the ballot box in 1945, they’ve never won a single seat in parliament, or a by-election. Or that in the recent Clacton by-election, Count Binface, a man with a bin on his head, won more popular votes in one by-election than the SPGB has in its history?
Perhaps it’s not just me you’re not convincing? If you have an ideological position and a world view you should be able to defend it, but in your case obviously not.
GrandpaGB
ParticipantThe Failure of Communism
Why amazing? Don’t worry, I’ve heard all the excuses about why communism didn’t work, but it will next time. I do think things through, but I stopped believing socially engineered utopias of whatever political persuasion could succeed a long time ago. From the USSR, to Pol Pot and onto today’s Kim Jong-Un, it wasn’t through a lack of trying and yes, maybe from original good intentions but they all turned into bloodthirsty dictatorships and failed.Open borders
The EU does have open borders as a result of the Schengen Treaty. You can travel from Spain in the south to Sweden in the north, over two thousand miles away and through two or three countries and not be stopped at any border. I don’t believe I said things were good, what I said was, “So has the idea of a borderless society, which has turned into a disaster for Europe.”Self-Interest
“Self-interest” has been around for as long as humans have existed. The pre-historic man didn’t give the cloak he’d made from wolf skins to his neighbour in the next cave, he bartered it for a hunting spear, or two if he could get them. Although egalitarianism existed in primitive societies as a means of survival, there has never been a society based totally on equality and altruism.Pol Pot and a self-sufficient, classless, communist society
I’m sure Pol Pot never envisaged what his society would become. What’s the saying? “The road to hell is paved with good intentions?” He’s the nearest to what you’re advocating, a self-sufficient, classless, communist society.I remember visiting the Genocidal Center near Phnom Penh and before that ‘ The Road of Bones’ on what is now the R504 Kolymar Highway near Yakutsk and entering a couple of the old remaining camps. Later on a visit, having to bow before statues of the Kim dynasty in Pyongyang (what a dump that was). All are must see destinations for anyone dreaming about creating a communist utopia and pretending it’s socialism.
Capitalism
You are never going to vote capitalism out. In the 2024 general election the SPGB contested two constituencies and won 193 votes between them. In New Forest East, The Mad Hatter from The Monster Raving Loony Party got 529 votes! Many people dislike laissez faire capitalism, myself included, but the vast majority won’t vote for communism because that’s what you’re advocating whilst trying to pretend it’s something else.
2024. Labour: 404 seats. Conservative: 118. Reform: 8. SPGB: 0.Marx
Marx describes capitalism brilliantly. Even today it’s impossible to do a degree in the political sciences without Marx. Where he errs is when he begins to offer alternatives. Remember that Marx was writing in a time of European absolute monarchs and absolute poverty. ‘Bread for the workers’ sounds as outdated today as the Americans still cheering for revolutionary militias.The workers are not coming out into the streets of Europe. What started as a protest against the cost of living and cut-backs was quickly taken over by communists, anarchists and Islamists. The irony is that social-liberal Macron, cheerleader for the EU and formerly a member of the Socialist Party is now behind far-right Le Pen in the presidential race.
Gramsci
You’ll have read Gramsci’s ‘Prison Notebooks’ then. He’s the one who answered Lenin’s question of why the western proletariat weren’t rising up all over Europe. This was before Stalin came to power and communism was still widely regarded as an alternative. Gramsci was the one who discovered it was culture, including patriotism and not class which provided the cohesion that held society’s together. If the workers weren’t interested he proposed the minorities replace them and from Blair onwards that’s what you see today. Gone are the workers protests of the 60s and 70s.Cultural Marxism
Every society is built on culture as its foundation. This includes language, religion, identity, values, traditions … Dilute or remove these and the foundations on which that society was built collapses.It’s not only capitalism which is destroying society it’s the anarchy of Cultural Marxism which is changing the social structure. Who would have thought a creep like Farage would ever be a realistic contender for PM, or Tommy Robinson would bring an estimated one million plus out into the streets in his ‘Unite the Kingdom’ march? There’s the backlash to smashing capitalism and the response to Cultural Marxism.
GrandpaGB
Participant“From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs” and “Workers of the world, unite; you have nothing to lose but your chains” isn’t socialism, it’s communism, which has a proven track record of failure. So has the idea of a borderless society, which has turned into a disaster for Europe.
And who is to manage this “moneyless, wageless, stateless” society? That’s why it wouldn’t work because whoever it is, self-interest dictates they will feather their own nest before they feather yours and you’re back to an elite rule.
What did capitalism and the Del Boy elites of today replace? Feudalism and its lords and nobility. Go back even further and we get the Roman slave-based economy run on capitalism before it was even invented by the Emperor, the Senate, and landowners.
The last person who tried what you’re suggesting was Cambodia’s Pol Pot who in the late 1970s decided to force a return to Year Zero and socially engineer a society built on what you’re suggesting. That failed and left a quarter of the population dead.
I understand where you’re coming from, but the objective should be to curb the power of the capitalist elites; those who exploit others for their own personal greed. The vast majority of people won’t give up the right to own individual wealth, or property rights, or democracy. You will never get rid of capitalism; the nearest you’ll get is to keep the greedy away from the welfare system and re-nationalise the essential services.
Marx got it wrong by the way. It wasn’t about class, it was culture and why you rarely see the workers out in the streets protesting any more. They were replaced by Gramsci’s Cultural Marxism and the minorities as the new revolutionaries.
-
AuthorPosts
