GrandpaGB

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 45 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Socialism not Communism #267252
    GrandpaGB
    Participant

    Your problem is you’re back to front. You start with theory as a conclusion and then try to make the pieces fit. What you don’t explain is the practicalities. Who is the distributor, who solves disagreements, how do you make people want to work, how do you persuade people to give up what they already own? What’s in it for them? How are you going to reconcile the other groups who also think they’re right? You can’t explain anything above theory, you just believe.

    It’s not me that’s the odd one out, it’s the tens of millions that aren’t voting for a theory that makes you the odd one’s out. You have a membership of around 300. It’s simply an embarrassing fact to say The Monster Raving Loony Party has more believers than you do.

    I prefer a rather more neutral warts and all view of what the SPGB is and it’s history.

    in reply to: Socialism not Communism #267248
    GrandpaGB
    Participant

    “Dictatorship is based directly upon force and unrestricted by any laws. The revolutionary dictatorship of the proletariat is rule won and maintained by the use of violence by the proletariat against the bourgeoisie.” (Collected Works, Vol. 28, p.236). I think that sums it up?

    1. “It’s not up to us to “persuade” the working class to embrace socialism.” Then why do you stand people for elections? Why do you have a newspaper? What is that if not trying to persuade people?

    2. Wealth is extremely concentrated, not just in Britain but everywhere in the world. That’s a by-product of capitalism. Remove it and another lot will become the capitalists, but this time they’ll call themselves the People’s Distribution Committee, or something similar. It’s human nature.

    3. The argument that the majority of haves will give up what they have to the have nots is the core of why your society will never happen. What you have do is persuade the haves to share everything they’ve got, which the have nots will be very happy about and that isn’t going to happen.

    I’m not slagging off the SPGB. I’m explaining why it’s pie in the sky. The SPGB doesn’t have a personality cult as so many do, but it does have an ‘only we are right’ attitude, lacking practicalities and resembling a doomsday sect type of organisation waiting for something that will never happen.

    in reply to: China and Statism #267243
    GrandpaGB
    Participant

    The main issue is not statism, the main issue is whether something works or not. When I say no one is criticising what came after Mao, I mean no one is criticising the wealth of China because of regulated capitalism, or that it has lifted hundreds of millions out of poverty. There is no more Maoism.

    Mao’s ultimate aim was also a classless, stateless, and moneyless society, that’s always the bait that draws the gullible in and that it always turns into a dictatorship and never happens shouldn’t come as a surprise. Before anything can work the world needs to get rid of the Mao’s, Stalin’s and Pol Pot’s and there’s plenty of them. The people will stop them? That’s not worked very well, has it.

    Your system wouldn’t work because it would quickly dissolve into anarchy. A leaderless mob of millions each grabbing what they want and the impossibility of distribution means it would fail. There’s also the main problem that no one would vote for it.

    in reply to: Socialism not Communism #267213
    GrandpaGB
    Participant

    Just looking at the news and how quickly the ‘Free Palestine’ protests fizzled out and the cost of living and anti cut-back ones arrived. A bit like mentally ill Greta and Stop the Oil lot, it comes in waves.

    Germany gets its turn this weekend with France’s ‘Yellow Vests.’ Come on, you love a bit of anarchy, don’t you. 🙂 Your lot will be there waving red and black flags with their green hair, hoodies and nose rings. Having said that, some of it I agree with; stop the war-mongers financing the Ukraine conflict and down with the EU liberal fascist elites, but I think there will be a distinct lack of those shouting everything must be free.

    When you watch the protests, the dozens of agenda’s on show, the violence, the looting, the burning … Those are the people who would be running your society, the only thing missing is Robespierre.

    in reply to: Socialism not Communism #267212
    GrandpaGB
    Participant

    I’m quite aware you people are part of a cult, no different from the opposite of Farage who ropes in the gullible. But Farage said and the SPGB said … So it must be true?

    Marx said there must initially be a “Dictatorship of the proletariat.” Sound reasoning in an age of absolute poverty where the have nots outnumbered the haves. Fast forward to the 21st century and how do you persuade the majority of haves to give up what they own to the minority have nots without another dictatorship?

    After reading a couple, I don’t read the SPGB writings any more, I already know they’re going to spin history from a Marxist perspective and I can read what they say here as you’re repeating them. The world according to the SPGB? I’m not about to spend the next few weeks writing a series of five thousand word essays on the points you, or rather the SPGB, are making. I ask questions, simple ones that you can’t answer and that tells me there’s not much independent thought going on here and that you need the SPGB as much as they need you.

    in reply to: China and Statism #267211
    GrandpaGB
    Participant

    There will always be criticism of anything and Mao quite rightly comes in for his share. No one is criticising what came after Mao.

    If you cite content from ‘China Observer’ you should also mention who’s behind it and that it’s an anti-communist propaganda channel. The same goes for today’s Russia where everyone is said to be living on bread and water.

    It’s not what you earn, it’s what you can buy with it. Ten years ago a cafe type lunch cost about 30 Yuan, today that’s about £3.36. If you’re going to pay nearly the same in London for a tea bag and some hot water you’re going to need high wages.

    Before the 20th century, China was ruled by Emperors and Dynasties for thousands of years. No chance of anti-capitalism there. In fact the famous ‘Silk Road’ trading route was started around 130BC, when we were still in the Iron age. Today it’s called the ‘Belt and Road’ trading route and stretches as far as Africa and into Europe. Not sure why I added that except to make you wonder why they didn’t abandon capitalism, but introduced regulated capitalism instead and seem to be doing very well out of it.

    in reply to: Socialism not Communism #267170
    GrandpaGB
    Participant

    We’ve already answered. What about you attending to our points made?

    No you haven’t. You’ve given me theory of what should be from what someone else told you, not your how it would be implemented, because that’s where all this nonsense falls flat. How do you argue against beliefs? If you believe so shall it be, but don’t hold your breath. If you can’t answer the questions just say so instead of waffling.

    in reply to: China and Statism #267169
    GrandpaGB
    Participant

    You’re not pointing out anything the SPGB didn’t tell you. I lived there, I didn’t get what I wrote from someone else.

    “Widely regarded as the “architect of modern China,” he [Deng Xiaoping] transformed the nation from a rigid, isolated communist economy into a global economic powerhouse.” – Wiki.

    Did he, or didn’t he? Stop wasting your time constantly referring to what the SPGB said. I don’t read them as I already know what they’re going to say.

    in reply to: Socialism not Communism #267165
    GrandpaGB
    Participant

    I don’t need someone else to tell me what Cultural Marxism is. Gramsci was never part of the Frankfurt school. He discovered the answer to Lenin’s question of why the workers in the west weren’t rising up and overthrowing the system (Prison notebooks). His answer was use the minorities instead as a revolutionary cadre and it’s what you can see in the street protests today. It’s why the term cultural as opposed to classical.

    I suppose the point is don’t blindly believe what someone else says because that’s just their opinion. Don’t believe me either, you have the Internet at your fingertips.

    But back to the above questions? Do I hear a deafening silence? You won’t find the answers to those in the SPGB.

    in reply to: China and Statism #267164
    GrandpaGB
    Participant

    Grandpa has stated “In any group of people a leader will emerge, it’s human nature”

    This is a very absolutist statement. There is no equivocation, “any group of people” However, as just as one example, the SPGB has been in existence since 1904, in that period of 126 years there have been several thousands of people who have been members of the SPGB and their companion Parties. They definitely meet Grandpa’s criteria of being part of any group of people. Yet in all that time, with all of those people no leader has emerged. So it is unarguable that Grandpa’s statement is incorrect. I could give many, many other examples of groups where leaders don’t emerge.

    This may seem a trivial point, but it is extremely indicative of Grandpa’s style of constructing argument. Take an opinion, attempt to dress it up with a fact, and then, despite all of the evidence that proves the opinion is false, use it as a foundation for more opinions dressed up as facts.

    I would describe Grandpa style as being sophistry, but I think the original sophists would turn in their collective graves if such a poor example as Grandpa was included in their practice.

    I don’t blindly tie myself into any group or ideology because none of them are perfect. You hit the nail on the head when you say that since 1904 thousands have been members of the SPGB and like minded splinter groups. What percentage is that of tens of millions? Never mind about Grandpa, not exactly been a success has it. What you’re giving me is the theory of a man who was writing nearly a century and a half ago in an age of absolute poverty and suggesting it would work in a modern era.

    in reply to: Socialism not Communism #267145
    GrandpaGB
    Participant

    OK, basic question time.

    1. If nobody is voting for your ideas, how do you propose to bring about this revolutionary change?

    2. Can I and the other eight billion really have everything we want? Or is there a get out clause that says subject to availability, terms and conditions apply?

    3. Currently, people work to earn money. If everything is free why would anyone want to work?

    4. Who gets the top jobs to organise, manage and distribute in the biggest bureaucracy the world has ever seen? Call it a government, or a people’s collective, they’re both the same thing.

    5. How do you convince those with individual wealth, even if it’s only a little, to give it up voluntarily and not by force?

    6. What will replace human self-interest and the desire for personal reward? Without them, where is the incentive to progress, or put effort into anything.

    Pick one, Short answers based on reality and not beginning with, Marx said …

    in reply to: Socialism not Communism #267144
    GrandpaGB
    Participant

    ” I’m sure if I put you all into one room you’d spend forever arguing amongst yourselves.”

    So, the very opposite, then, of the mindless cult of followers you suppose us to be!

    No, not at all. You’d all agree on the objective, you’d fight amongst yourselves on how it would be achieved, because remember you have no leader so it’s a free for all.

    in reply to: Socialism not Communism #267138
    GrandpaGB
    Participant

    But Grandpa is obviously stuck in a groove he’ll never get out of. So is it worth persisting?

    I hope so, Howard. At least it provides an opportunity to deal with the kind of knee-jerk opposition to the concept of a socialist society that is unfortunately very widespread…

    When you’ve persuaded me you only have a few million more to convince. Come on you love it. Gets all that pent up anger out and gives you a chance to get a bit of Marxist theory out.

    in reply to: Socialism not Communism #267137
    GrandpaGB
    Participant

    Fantastic post, Robin. But Grandpa is obviously stuck in a groove he’ll never get out of. So is it worth persisting? Hard to know exactly what his purpose was in initiating this discussion. In his very first post he said ‘I don’t know whether I’ll fit in here’ and then, in the same message, accused us of harbouring ‘some utopian communist fantasy where 8 billion people live in a wageless society, share everything and live happily ever after’. How likely are you to ‘fit in’ with something you immediately mock? That’s why, at a certain point, I suggested he might be a troll. But perhaps he just wanted a bit of fun. And maybe he’s had that by now.

    That was the point of my asking will I fit in here. Is dissent among the eight billion frowned on? You know, the world in complete agreement thing, all holding hands …? Socialism, communism, anarchism … I’m sure if I put you all into one room you’d spend forever arguing amongst yourselves. You know it’s never going to happen so why act surprised?

    You can persuade me by saying I get my house in the countryside and a Rolls Royce though. 🙂

    in reply to: China and Statism #267125
    GrandpaGB
    Participant

    Yes, I do read your posts. I smile at the terminology of words such as ‘reactionary, peasants’ and ‘bourgeoisie’, it’s 2026 people, not 1894. I think the last time someone called me ‘comrade’ was back in the 70s. You’re trying to rewrite history and adapt it to the modern era. It’s why it sounds so weird, not just to me, but to the millions of workers you aren’t convincing either. I don’t lecture, I just focus on reality.

    Some of my recent favourites:

    “Mao wasn’t a communist.” That one had me in stitches.

    “You talk to any of those so-called anti-communist exiles from the Cold War period, and they do not have a clue of what socialism really is …” You mean people like Bukovsky who spent years in a Gulag for criticising a country that abandoned capitalism?

    “Socialism/communism, as we have said several times in this forum, would be a society without a state and without a leader, and without government.” A bit like Somalia in the 90s? The Spanish anarchists already tried that. In any group of people a leader will emerge, it’s human nature and usually of the type

    You’re telling me what Marxism should look like in theory. I’m telling you what happens when countries abandon capitalism. So who should I believe? Classical Marxism? Leninist and state socialism? Critical Marxists, Anarchism, Libertarian and autonomous Marxism? Everyone of them says they’re right.

    You’re flogging a dead horse. The workers aren’t interested. They’re interested in how much they’ll get in their wage packets next week, not dreaming of some fantasy of moneyless societies and no government. How many will be listening to the budget and hoping they get something out of it?

    Yes, I laughed as well watching them sitting there wisely nodding their heads and pretending half of them aren’t dipping their fingers in the till, but can you imagine what a leaderless country would look like with an executive committee or whatever they’d call themselves? Explain the difference between a leader and manager.

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 45 total)