Bijou Drains
Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
But…. why did well known republican supporter, Jack Ruby, who was well connected to many mafiosa figures and in considerable debt to the mafia and others, seek out and kill Lee Harvey Oswald?
That’s interesting ALB. I’ve just completed a few manuscripts for publication:
“Gluten Free Marxism”,
“The Karl Marx 7 Day Diet”
“Karl Marx the Rock and Roll Days”
and
“Fredrich Engels Ate my Hamster”
looks like I could be on to a nice little earnerPerhaps it would be best to start a separate topic on this rather than further complicate the thread?
I have comments to make but don’t want to cause confusionDespite the disagreements, L Bird, I’m glad to hear you’re alive and kicking and haven’t succumbed to the virus.
I would have said affectionately “shine on you crazy diamond” but I didn’t, just in case you thought it was insulting (which it wouldn’t have been)My view as a football fan is pretty close to that put forward by Bobby Robson:
“ What is a club in any case? Not the buildings or the directors or the people who are paid to represent it. It’s not the television contracts, get-out clauses, marketing departments or executive boxes. It’s the noise, the passion, the feeling of belonging, the pride in your city. It’s a small boy clambering up stadium steps for the very first time, gripping his father’s hand, gawping at that hallowed stretch of turf beneath him and, without being able to do a thing about it, falling in love.”My first trip to St James was just like that. It’s hard to believe that a friendly match in 1967 would engender such feelings, but it was very like that. Ironically my football living father, who took me to that match was a Sunderland supporter!
To précis the previous replies, if a minority attempt to disrupt the majority and the overthrow of capitalism through violent means, we would organise a forceful response based on delegated, capable group of those willing and able to take on that role. As I have said before, real Socialists are not sheep, we do not need a leader to organise our selves and take necessary action.
In terms of who would take part in the “capable group” I strongly suspect that you won’t be part of that group so you can change your soiled undergarment, go back to the frat house and return to watching re runs of “friends”.
Another example of the Chinese State’s great concern for the toiling masses is shown by CNTC.
The Chinese tobacco industry is a powerful state-owned enterprise. The commercial arm called the China National Tobacco Corporation (CNTC) is managed by the government arm, the State Tobacco Monopoly Administration. CNTC is the largest tobacco company in the world, producing 40 per cent of the global cigarette supply. The company has a monopoly in China to supply more than 300 million Chinese smokers and makes vast profits for the Chinese state.
Rather attempt to develop programmes to stop smoking, CNTC has a long history of sponsorship of schools and educational programmes, the programmes used are advertised with slogans “genius is from hard work, tobacco helps you excel”.
The profit motive at work again.
Over the years I have met many of these pseudo revolutionaries like TS, full of blood curdling slogans about violent revolutionary actions, but when it all kicks off they are nowhere to be be seen. One whiff of any real trouble TS and their ilk fill their pants and are off hiding under the bed.
Like the pretend revolutionaries of the left who bleated on about offering full support to the Provisional IRA, Happy enough to sing rebels songs in the pub on a Friday night, but somehow they never manage to show their solidarity by getting themselves over to the Falls Road or the Creggan and get themselves an armalite.
Same with the miners strike, full of support to the miners, didn’t see many of them at the Battle of Orgreave!
The most radical action that TS has ever undertaken was quoting Monty Python sketches to his mates in his frat house.
The SPGB has never argued that spontaneous risings will bring about Socialism, quite the opposite. We disagree with your need for leaders (by the way is your Marvel alter ego “Sheep boy). Unlike you we have the same view as Engels
“ The time of surprise attacks, of revolutions carried through by small conscious minorities at the head of masses lacking consciousness is past. Where it is a question of a complete transformation of the social organisation, the masses themselves must be in on it, must themselves have grasped what is at stake, what they are fighting for, body and soul.’”“Lenin and Stalin made unbelievably spectacularly bad
judgements about at least the following people…”Like I’ve said, I’m not much interested in the trials. But saying Lenin and Stalin should have known the listed names were traitors is ridiculous. Sukarno should have known Suharto was a traitor, Caesar that Brutus was a traitor, etc? You think traitors don’t exist?
When you lead your revolution (Lol) I’m sure there won’t be a single traitor. You will never misjudge anothers’ character because you are a Marxist superhero, armed, no doubt, with a lasso of truth and x-ray vision that can see into a man’s very soul. Am I right? Come on, I’m right, right?
Is the sound I can hear accross the wide Atlantic, the noise of a desperate Maoist apologist, clutching straws?
For your information, we don’t have any need or use for leaders, we are a fully democratic organisation made up of class conscious revolutionary Socialists. We don’t need to lead or be led. Leaders are for sheep.
I think your understanding of politics relies more on Marvel Comics than the works of Marx and Engels.
TS, If you were correct about the Moscow show trials (which I do not think for one moment that you are) by your admission all of these high level Bolsheviks were appointed to high position and were highly endorsed at one point or another by either Lenin and or Stalin.
Again if you are correct, this would mean that according to you, your two heroes, Lenin and Stalin made unbelievably spectacularly bad judgements about at least the following people:
Nikolai Bukharin (1888 – 1938)
Grigori Zinoviev (1883 – 1936)
Lev Kamenev (1883 – 1936)
Béla Kun (1886 – 1938)
Alexei Rykov (1881 – 1938)
Karl Radek (1885 – 1939)
Mikhail Tomsky (1880 – 1936)
Martemyan Ryutin (1890 – 1937)
Ivan Smirnov (1881–1936)
Ivar Smilga (1892 – 1938)
Arkady Rosengolts (1889 – 1938) —
Yevgeni Preobrazhensky (1886 – 1937)
Aleksandr Smirnov (1877 – 1938)
Nikolay Krestinsky (1883 – 1938)
Alexander Shliapnikov (1885 – 1937)
Andrei Bubnov (1883 – 1938)
Varvara Yakovleva (1884 – 1941)
Alexander Shotman (1880 – 1937)
Alexander Beloborodov (1891 – 1938)
Lev Karakhan (1889-1937)In fact of the 139 members and candidates of the Central Committee who were elected at the 17th Congress, 98 persons, i.e., 70 per cent, were arrested and shot (mostly in 1937-1938). Out of 1,966 delegates with either voting or advisory rights, 1,108 persons were arrested on charges of anti-revolutionary crimes.
You don’t need to take my word for the names and numbers of “traitors”, this information does not come from me, but rather from the minutes of The 18th Congress of the Russian Communist Party which was held during 10–21 March 1939 in Moscow and The Nineteenth Congress of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union which was held from 5 to 14 October 1952. You are welcome to check my figures they are figures agreed on by Stalin and signed off by the Central Committe of the Russian Communist Party.
If you are correct, then your evidence would show Lenin and Stalin must be the worst political leaders and worse judges of character ever born.
AJ “so it will be easy for you to copy and paste the relevant facts that are irrefutable.”
TS – And why would I get into arguments about a criminal trial with you, Alan? You are a dishonest interlocutor.
TS is sidestepping questions, yet again.
Your fooling nobody (with the possible exception of yourself), it is clear you cannot produce the evidence you claim to have, in the same way you cannot explain why anyone should trust the Chinese “communist” Party’s claim that they will have achieved “full communism” by 2120, given their backtracking on their claims about “underdeveloped socialism”.
It appears, my friend that you are full of it.
