Young Master Smeet

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 3,097 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: No Surprise 😹 #261359

    Mod note: Please avoid posting bare links, it’s good manners to at least describe what you are linking to and why readers of this forum may find it relevant.

    in reply to: Irish presidential election (What’s the point?) #261112

    So Connolly won by a landslide, on a slightly increased turnout.

    103K people voted for a candidate who withdrew from the contest.
    213K joined a spoilt ballot contest, organise by the far right, ostensibly because the system was ‘rigged’ because their candidate was unable to get nominated by parliamentarians or councils (apparently it is unusual for Fine Gael to whip its councillors to not support an independent, but it is hardly unfair nor unreasonable to expect them to not back an opponent to their party’s candidate – as matter of fact, with the ranking voting system Ireland uses, it wouldn’t matter if there were further candidates, except for media exposure, Steen could not have won). The various left parties, including Sinn Fein

    This is useful to us, because it shows how a spoilt ballot campaign can punch through, in this case, reaching 16% in some quarters.

    in reply to: Economic reform in China #260439

    Well, all markets are designed markets, and all markets (despite the propaganda) are creatures of the state and law, so in essence, China isn’t doing anything that Western states haven’t already done, as I understand it, Xi’s big thing is the central role of the party:

    See, https://monitoring.bbc.co.uk/product/c1dmwn4r
    (about a third of the points concern the Party).

    (I knew he is a Red Prince, but didn’t realise how significant his father was: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xi_Zhongxun)

    in reply to: Food for all #260071

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c98jjgqyd6po

    This is also relevant:

    “The process starts with yeast that has been genetically modified to produce casein, the key protein in milk, instead of alcohol. Jevan says this is the same technique used to produce insulin without having to harvest it from pigs.

    Other companies also use bacteria or fungi to produce casein.

    Once the casein is made through this precision fermentation, it is mixed with plant-based fat and the other components of milk needed for cheese, and then the traditional cheese-making process ensues.”

    in reply to: How to found a party #260070

    https://rebelbrit.substack.com/p/rebel-britannia-063

    This is wonderful, a list of defunct unions and party names. I particularly liked
    “Committee of the Useful Classes”
    and
    “The London Corresponding Society of the Unrepresented Part of the People of Great Britain”

    in reply to: How to found a party #259955

    Absolutely fine, I did think of looking there first…

    in reply to: Surplus value in non-productive work. #259785

    Shop staff, train drivers, security guards don’t directly produce surplus value, but they are a cost and an essential part of the overall realisation of value: the collective working class produces the surplus value.

    To take my usual example of a cricket ball factory, some of the team will be directly involved in creating the ball, some just put it in a box, or move the boxes to the loading bay for collection. None of the directly productive staff can say how much value they added, since it is a collective act, and the box fillers and movers are essential to getting the product out.

    in reply to: Israel strikes Iran militaries and nuclear sites #258896

    It’s disheartening to see so many people online cheering on Iran’s bombardment of Israel (just as much as any cheering for the bombing of Tehran is abhorrent). the loss of life is a loss of potential for all humanity, mute inglorious Miltons (or future cancer researchers, AI specialists, or whatever) are dying, useful housing is being destroyed and the environment despoiled and resources depleted. It’s awful to watch.

    in reply to: Sunday Mail discovers how banks work #258660

    On money as a token. That token is a claim to wealth: when a government issue a token, it has the force of violence behind it. “Use this money, or face the consequences”, hence why taxation is an essential part of issuing money.

    Anyone can issue an IOU, and that IOU might circulate (if people trust you sufficiently), but for it not to be fraud, you have to be capable of making good the promise on the IOU if it ever gets called in. Of course, it is not fraud if you don’t have the goods to redeem the IOU in your pocket at the moment of its creation, if you have a reasonable expectation that you will be able to pay when the note gets called. An IOU does not transfer money from one person to the next, it transfers a claim to money.

    Whilst a good solid IOU is written on paper, properly notarised, signed, counter signed and stamped, there is nothing to stop an IOU being electronic, so long as the eIOU can be validated and verified.

    When a bank issues a loan they (should) carefully check that the borrower is capable of paying it back, they are creating a sort of IOU for their customer saying ‘they are capable of paying for an asset worth ÂŁX thousand.’ depending on the nature of the loan, they’re also certifying that the borrower has sufficient wherewithal to cover the loan in the event of default through cash flow issues. If anything, it would be the borrower (and their work) that creates the money, not the lending bank.

    But the borrower hasn’t created the wealth yet, and needs time to realise that, which is where the bank comes in, the bank covers the IOU, to prevent it being fraudulent. But, in turn, the bank has to be good for that over the counter demand, or it is committing fraud. Only the state, which gets to define fraud, can issue money without needing to back it from elsewhere: but, of course, when a state issues unbacked currency to appropriate resources, that is a form of taxation, so even then, it is only taking from wealth already created elsewhere.

    (Final wee point, in the UK many banks don’t pay interest on current accounts, but in lieu of interest they also don’t charge for services).

    in reply to: Mod Log #258651

    #258635 from Film thread Binned, off topic, advertising.

    in reply to: The Communards beyond Paris. #257115

    “Limousin, the archetype of an unchanging peasant land, experienced the Commune of 1871 intensely. We do not know it. The Limousin workers paid a heavy price. We do not count the dead on the barricades, nor the shot, nor the imprisoned, nor the deported to New Caledonia and Guyana. We have almost forgotten them.

    The Communard uprising of the spring of 1871 has long been treated as a brief convulsion of history, a very Parisian anecdote without consequences, quickly erased by the indifference or hostility of rural France. Recent work has challenged this preconceived idea and it is in this research perspective that this book is set: the Commune is also a Limousin story.”

    That actually sounds very interesting: seems there was an earlier book on the subject:
    https://www.abebooks.co.uk/Oubli%C3%A9s-lHistoire-Limousins-Commune-Paris-1871/30975808480/bd

    Sadly, can’t find anything in English on the subject.

    in reply to: Boxing and moral judgments #257001

    A bit late to the party: I revised my view of boxing some years ago, there was a fight on the telly in the pub, and some flyweights were giving each other welly. I realised at any moment either of them could stop, just walk away: its a sport not so much of inflicting damage but of demonstrating resilience in the face of damage and carrying on. It’s also a sport, at the top level, about the skill of not being hit, and having tremendous reserves of energy and fitness.

    Partly that’s why I’ve shied away from MMA, although they’ve (mercifully) stopped head kicks on the floor, they still have ground and pound punching, which is unpleasant to watch.

    I’ve been along to some exhibition chess boxing matches (yes, really), but the chess players, even with some moderate boxing skill, didn’t have the energy to have any power in their shots by the third round.

    All that said, I think in socialism, where we won’t have police or armies to settle disputes like this, we will have some terrific arguments, and one town or village might take a different view than another for how their venues might be used. There won’t be money to gamble, prizes to give out, advertising, pay-per-view, or anything of that sort. If people still wanted to test themselves in this way, I imagine they’d find a way.

    in reply to: Music worth listening to #256890

    Mod note:

    I’ve moved this thread to off-topic, where it belongs, could people please calm down.

    in reply to: How we could live #255794

    DSL table

    in reply to: The Definition of an Economy #255303

    From Raymond William’s Keywords (only as an aside, really):

    “It is from rw oikos , Gk – household, with the familiar ending logy from logos – discourse, thence systematic study. Economy shares its reference, with the alternative ending nomy (cf. astronomy) from nomia , Gk – management and nomos , Gk – law. Economy had developed from its early sense of management of a household (C16) to political economy (from F, C16-C17) and to economics in its general modern sense from 1C18. Ecology (Haeckel’s ökologie) developed the sense of habitat (a noun for a characteristic living place from C18, from the form of the Latin verb ‘it lives’), and became the study of the relations of plants and animals with each other and with their habitat.”

    (an interesting coupling with ecology, really)

    See also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chrematistics

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 3,097 total)