twc

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 791 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: China and Statism #267450
    twc
    Participant

    LBird: The SPGB claimed to [stake its political credibility upon absolute democracy].

    Fantasy of a Crank

    The SPGB has never supported any variety of LBird’s absolute democracy — his conception of socialism as a regime of “democratically” compelled thought, where every scientific conception and artistic expression is surveilled for absolute conformity by everyone, “democratically”.

    What the SPGB stakes its Political Credibility on

    The SPGB has staked its political credibility on its Object and Declaration of Principles from its inception in 1904.

    Object

    The establishment of a system of society based upon the common ownership and democratic control of the means and instruments for producing and distributing wealth by and in the interest of the whole communit.

    Declaration of Principles

    The Socialist Party of Great Britain holds

    1. That society as at present constituted is based upon the ownership of the means of living (i.e., land, factories, railways, etc.) by the capitalist or master class, and the consequent enslavement of the working class, by whose labour alone wealth is produced.
    2. That in society, therefore, there is an antagonism of interests, manifesting itself as a class struggle between those who possess but do not produce and those who produce but do not possess.
    3. That this antagonism can be abolished only by the emancipation of the working class from the domination of the master class, by the conversion into the common property of society of the means of production and distribution, and their democratic control by the whole people.
    4. That as in the order of social evolution the working class is the last class to achieve its freedom, the emancipation of the working class will involve the emancipation of all mankind, without distinction of race or sex.
    5. That this emancipation must be the work of the working class itself.
    6. That as the machinery of government, including the armed forces of the nation, exists only to conserve the monopoly by the capitalist class of the wealth taken from the workers, the working class must organise consciously and politically for the conquest of the powers of government, national and local, in order that this machinery, including these forces, may be converted from an instrument of oppression into the agent of emancipation and the overthrow of privilege, aristocratic and plutocratic.
    7. That as all political parties are but the expression of class interests, and as the interest of the working class is diametrically opposed to the interests of all sections of the the master class, the party seeking working class emancipation must be hostile to every other party.
    8. The Socialist Party of Great Britain, therefore, enters the field of political action determined to wage war against all other political parties, whether alleged labour or avowedly capitalist, and calls upon the members of the working class of this country to muster under its banner to the end that a speedy termination may be wrought to the system which deprives them of the fruits of their labour, and that poverty may give place to comfort, privilege to equality, and slavery to freedom.

    Wavering Absolute Democratist

    For over a century the SPGB has never wavered.

    But how about LBird, the absolute democratist who spent a fruitless decade foisting his regime of absolute democracy upon the SPGB, and now [in his tendentious phrase] “if his posts are to be believed” is visibly wavering about absolute democracy.

    I gently asked LBird how could he fall in love with the anti-democratic Chinese regime to the extent that he now openly agonises over the inability of its 5th Plenum communiqué to mollify its ruled masses?

    No answer. Silence…

    So low has the mighty absolute democratist fallen!

    • This reply was modified 2 weeks, 4 days ago by twc.
    • This reply was modified 2 weeks, 4 days ago by twc.
    • This reply was modified 2 weeks, 4 days ago by twc.
    in reply to: China and Statism #267370
    twc
    Participant

    LBird: Does it reassure the masses?

    Well, the CPC leadership hopes it does.

    But my “reassurance” comment was purely satirical.

    What else could I take from your Orwellian document which, for a world socialist, is political satire?

    It reveals the leadership’s acute awareness that its class rule is fragile and ultimately rests upon mass support.

    Hence the leadership reveals its guilty past to the masses.

    Will its mea culpa reassure the masses? Probably not.

    You can’t reveal closeted skeletons and punishment schedules without fuelling suspicions about the prevalence of conditions that sparked the revelations.

    LBird, you once staked your political credibility upon absolute democracy.

    Now you agonise over a political leadership’s inability to mollify its ruled masses!

    You and GrandpaGP are soulmates.

    in reply to: China and Statism #267312
    twc
    Participant

    From Yan’an to the Fifth Plenum: the CPC’s commitment to self-reform

    This communiqué is a panegyric to the Chinese Communist Party’s minority rule — in perpetuity — over its majority working class.

    Its assurances to its working class are indistinguishable from Lenin’s of 1920. Thus, Mao: “Only when the people are allowed to supervise the government will the government not slacken”.

    The communiqué claims to have “found two answers to the question of how [the Chinese Communist Party] can escape the historical cycle of rise and fall?”

    Its answer is by “the people’s oversight over government, and the Party’s self-reform.”

    The Party “tolerates no corruption”, and “has no special interests of its own besides the interests of the working class.”

    It reassures us with: “Vietnam’s “blazing furnace” anti-corruption campaign shows that other ruling communist parties are drawing similar conclusions, and many parties in Africa, Asia and Latin America study the CPC’s experience closely.”

    So how can it “stay in touch with the masses?”

    This is a sticky question when the Chinese Communist Party is the government and forbids its “masses” the use of a democratic franchise.

    Yet Mao already solved this problem in 1943, describing his solution — not one of cooperation — but as a “method of leadership”.

    “Take the scattered and unsystematic ideas of the masses, concentrate them through study into systematic ideas, then return to the masses to propagate and explain them “until the masses embrace them as their own”, testing them in action. “From the masses, to the masses” means that leadership is a continuous, two-way, dialectical relationship between Party and people.”

    And so, in the words of its communiqué, the Party’s objective is to ensure that it “always remains a vibrant Marxist governing party that stays at the forefront of the times, enjoys the wholehearted support of the people, and is able to withstand all tests”.

    That should reassure the masses.

    in reply to: Jesus. #264545
    twc
    Participant

    I know, but I cannot understand why atheists like Bart Ehrman and others say there is lots of evidence for him, when there is none, and why most classicists are saying the same, and calling the minority who say otherwise a fringe few.

    Karl Kautsky’s Foundations of Christianity (1908) is a materialist-conception-of-history study of the origins of Christianity.

    By analysing the irrational (whitewashed) biblical accounts of the arrest, trial and execution of “Jesus” for their rational kernel, Kautsky unearths evidence that points to a rebel leader of a failed attack (coup d’etat) on Jerusalem against Roman domination.

    See ”Foundations of Christianity”, Chapter 10

    • This reply was modified 4 months, 2 weeks ago by twc.
    in reply to: Arguments for Socialism #264407
    twc
    Participant

    I think our ideas of ‘socialism’ are different. I’m happy with that.

    You know where we stand on Socialism. Here’s our Object and Declaration of Principles.

    Where do you stand? What are your “ideas on socialism” that you are “happy with”?

    in reply to: Tricentenary. #264405
    twc
    Participant

    Thanks for the Swift memorial.

    And, yes, it does take intellectual fortitude to stand—as GBS said of William Morris—on the side of Karl Marx contra mundum.

    in reply to: Arguments for Socialism #264381
    twc
    Participant

    If only…. 😀

    You want capitalism without its “disadvantages”. Fair enough?

    What if capitalism’s “disadvantages” aren’t bugs but features, expressions of its heartless heart and soulless soul.

    OK, suppose you can’t eliminate capitalism’s “disadvantages” then you’ll soften their effects with a “minimum” proposal:

    Let the “rich man/woman have their 10 cars, but there should at least be a minimum.”

    If you understood Marx’s Capital, you’d realise that giving workers more to spend on commodities is not “disadvantageous” to the accumulation of capital. It’s beneficial.

    Your “minimum” would usher in a capitalist paradise of increased profits for capitalists, and bread and circuses for workers.

    Perhaps you don’t realise that you are mouthing capitalism’s perennial anxiety over the risk and uncertainty that is part and parcel of capital accumulation.

    You suffer anxiety paralysis “I no longer think”.

    This is evident in your naive expectation that Socialists will rush to soothe your unavoidable insecurity within a social system that is totally dominated by risk and uncertainty.

    Meanwhile you blithely continue to tolerate capitalism’s exploitation of the working class, and its attendant anti-social machinery (“advantageous” to capital because it is solely productive of capital accumulation)—wage labour, hiring and firing, buying and selling, banking and insurance, advertising and manipulation, stocks and shares, policing and gaoling, military and armaments.

    Let’s hope your own insecure wealth remains safe.

    • This reply was modified 5 months ago by twc.
    • This reply was modified 5 months ago by twc.
    • This reply was modified 5 months ago by twc.
    • This reply was modified 5 months ago by twc.
    in reply to: Arguments for Socialism #264346
    twc
    Participant

    I don’t think [about becoming a socialist].

    I don’t think, therefore I am not.

    ‘..to make life better for all who dwell in it?’ But that is subjective. What you consider a “better life” might be different to my definition.

    I imagine that you and your partner seek a “better life” for each. That is the analog of what world-socialists seek for humanity on a global scale.

    World socialists, following Marx (especially in Capital), seek to get rid of capital’s socially-necessary machinery for extracting surplus-value from the working class and carving it up among the capital-owning class.

    What will vanish is wage-labour, hiring and firing, buying and selling, banking and insurance, advertising and manipulation, stocks and shares, policing and gaoling, military and armaments.

    Removing the machinery of capital will render “intellectual” mediocrity and moral vapidity, indispensable concomitants of a lifetime of self-serving anti-social activity, socially unnecessary.

    [In passing, on abilities and needs, you may get inspiration from Marx’s Critique of the Gotha Program.]

    Finally, your limited horizon of “living standards of the average middle class American” is poor Oliver Twist in the workhouse daring to ask “Please sir, can I have some more [gruel]”.

    Socialists demand so, so much more—a far, far, better world!

    in reply to: Arguments for Socialism #264279
    twc
    Participant

    I notice you’ve made no attempt to address my original point that Socialism tends to be associated with sharing out the misery.

    Oh, I addressed it, alright. Either you didn’t notice, or you ignored me.

    1. I asked you point blank whether you also shared that popular mindset?—which you refused to answer, i.e., it was you who “made no attempt to address”.
    2. In the absence of a shared basis for dialog, I asked you why you dragged in a commonly agreed fact unless you assumed that your popular fact was the killer demolition of Socialism?

    Your reticence indicates that, at minimum, you do incline toward the proposition that “Socialism universalises misery”.

    Here’s a scientific warning for you: an immediately observable fact is not, of itself, mediated science (read Marx on scientific method—essence and appearance).

    An observable fact begs scientific comprehension. For example, it is immediately observable that the Sun moves across the sky from sunrise to sunset, and yet, contrary-wise, mediated science compels us comprehend the phenomenon as the Earth rotating on its axis.

    Waxing lyrical about the disadvantages of capitalism, and surmising what Marx might have thought about the present, doesn’t address the point.

    You threw down a provocation—your “surmise” that Marx would be totally clueless about certain modern phenomena—and I met it by evidencing relevant counter-clues that Marx has left us.

    Being found out as a pontificator bereft of knowledge of the subject matter on which he pontificates, reduces you, the pontificator, to a mere clueless “surmiser”.

    You accuse me of “waxing lyrical about the disadvantages of capitalism”, which only proves that it is you who desperately desires to wax “lyrical about the advantages of capitalism”.

    In passing, maybe you should follow through to the actual class that mostly suffers the [your word] “disadvantages” of capitalism. I assume you also belong to it, but are nevertheless inhumanly tolerant towards capitalism’s disadvantages.

    Your limited horizons and inability to notice the huge strides that humanity has taken over the last few centuries has blinded you to the progress that has been made.

    In short, you are claiming that my inability to notice progress blinds me to progress—tautological drivel. And any remnant content about “inability to notice progress” is patent nonsense.

    There are people out there now trying to tackle these scientific and engineering problems. Yes, they’re probably doing it so a company somewhere can make a profit.

    Have you ever stopped to consider why these [unspecified] “scientific and engineering problems” are driven by the inhuman need for commercial profit instead of by the thoroughly human drive to comprehend the world we inhabit, and to make life better for all who dwell in it?

    Have you ever stopped to consider that our social lives are conditioned by the class-divided society we spend our lives under, subject to a ruling class that owns and controls the means of our social existence.

    As old Shylock, who knew a thing or two about commerce, says “You take my life when you do take the means whereby I live”.

    But it is my opinion that socialists should be harnessing those strides forward and make the case that all people can benefit from them.

    Yes. When humanity ceases to meekly condone and justify capitalist exploitation as humanly inevitable. Yes, when humanity turns the social means of life into our common possession under the democratic control of us all.

    Until then, it remains exploitative and profit-driven, not collective and humanity driven.

    Maybe think a little more about becoming a socialist.

    • This reply was modified 5 months ago by twc.
    • This reply was modified 5 months ago by twc.
    • This reply was modified 5 months ago by twc.
    in reply to: Arguments for Socialism #264268
    twc
    Participant

    Can you define ‘accepted devastation’?
    Companies usually seek out countries with weak regulations and a lack of institutions. They are usually countries in which corruption is rampant.

    If you can’t see ‘accepted devastation’ in the water and power guzzling AI data centres, or in mining/fishing/agriculture, then why bother?

    Companies seek out resources—means of production—read the Party’s Object and Declaration of Principles—that we seek to become the common property of all humanity under the democratic control of all humanity.

    They can’t choose where nature concentrates resources—that’s the province of geology. If deposits are found at home, they’ll be extracted there. Corruption is best when not carried out by a gun.

    At present, wars are being fought precisely over which capitalist powers own and control a large chunk of the world’s petroleum resources.

    And wars are among the most glaring example of “acceptable devastation”—sanctioned by governments and bolstered by nationalism—under world capitalism.

    Signing off.

    • This reply was modified 5 months ago by twc.
    • This reply was modified 5 months ago by twc.
    • This reply was modified 5 months ago by twc.
    in reply to: Arguments for Socialism #264266
    twc
    Participant

    It is past 2AM here, and so must turn in.

    in reply to: Arguments for Socialism #264265
    twc
    Participant

    We don’t know what Marx would think if he were alive today.

    Why triumphantly turn ignorance into a bludgeon against socialism?

    In fact, we do know what Marx (and Engels) wrote about environmental devastation in the pursuit of capital expansion.

    Maybe he would be amazed with the potential of A.I. to help tackle some of the world’s most pressing problems.

    While everyone (including its developers) is amazed by AI, we can be fairly certain that the Marx who wrote on Machinery in Capital would also be amazed, but that the scientist in him would immediately recognise the significance of AI’s provenance in training by machine learning.

    Therefore Marx might be expected to conclude that AI, just as money is tightly constrained to function reliably in exchange, so also must AI function reliably in universal cognition, with the major proviso that AI is subject to what it was trained on, but that—and here’s the big arrow at the heart of AI—it must also satisfy objective scientific/logical criteria.

    And so Marx might be expected to foresee that AI will ultimately spill the beans on the essential nature of capitalist exploitation—the source of capital expansion—as the basis of humanity’s miserable lifetime subservience to capital.

    Scientific logic must undermine capitalist ideology. That was Marx’s enterprise in writing Capital—to expose the materialist base of capitalist confusion.

    Finally, the class-conscious Marx would definitely stipulate that AI can only help humanity, rather than just help its ruling class, when it is wielded collectively by associated humanity in the interest of all humanity. That is, when it is wielded under socialism.

    We don’t know.

    The ignorance is all yours.

    • This reply was modified 5 months ago by twc.
    in reply to: Arguments for Socialism #264257
    twc
    Participant

    These are minor infringements.

    A step above the council park ranger dishing out littering tickets. And no-one has gone to gaol for it.

    What about the accepted devastation wrought by the big companies and their heads?

    Which countries?

    Countries like the UK/US/Australia—nationally and internationally.

    For capital, green pastures are wherever it can expand.

    • This reply was modified 5 months ago by twc.
    • This reply was modified 5 months ago by twc.
    in reply to: Arguments for Socialism #264252
    twc
    Participant

    People and companies are fined or imprisoned for breaking rules and regulations related to the environment”

    Can you name some instances?

    Most of the problems are happening in countries without adequate institutions to set and enforce laws.

    You mean countries like UK/US/Australia. Their inadequate institutions permit their national mining/fishing corporations to pillage their own and, even-more inadequate, international zones of depredation, indifferent to local punitive fines and imprisonment.

    The might of human disapprobation doesn’t cut it against the might of inhuman capital.

    You see, it’s capitalist law—by capitalists for capitalists—that is notionally “violated”.

    Accumulation of capital thrives in environments it finds congenial or else skedaddles to greener pastures, where it may rape without encumbrance, leaving behind human disapprobation along with environmental detritus in its wake.

    The working class is ineffectual in capitalist affairs, even if it bleats its disapprobation ever so loud and ever so plaintively to unrepentant capital.

    This was my original point, that in the mind of a lot of people Socialism is associated with sharing out the misery and imposing controls on what people want or need.

    Is that your mindset too?

    If not, why bring up a fact recognised by all—thanks to a century of labourist and communists exemplars?

    Why triumphantly turn ignorance into a bludgeon against socialism?

    • This reply was modified 5 months ago by twc.
    • This reply was modified 5 months ago by twc.
    • This reply was modified 5 months ago by twc.
    • This reply was modified 5 months ago by twc.
    in reply to: Marx and AI #261801
    twc
    Participant

    Yes, this is the essence of Marx’s scientific critique of capitalism:

    Capital itself is the moving contradiction, [in] that it presses to reduce labour time to a minimum, while it posits labour time, on the other side, as the sole measure and source of wealth.

    Leftist agitation can’t resolve the contradiction. The inexorable working out of capital can transcend it.

    Marx is saying that capital compels its puppets, the capital-accumulating class, to progressively devalue (in capitalist economic terms) the social means of production.

    Capital is inexorably ushering in the demise of its own mode of production — its own possibility of existence. That is Marxian materialist dialectics!

    Despite of, and in the teeth of, the liberal ‘philosophical’ doubters and academic ‘politico-economic’ deniers, Marx is here saying nothing more than the implications of his general scientific materialism and of his specific labour-time theory of capitalist value.

    To comprehend why Marx can say this is a sure-fire way of comprehending the necessity and inevitability of socialism.

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 791 total)