ALB

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 6,001 through 6,015 (of 10,477 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Kent and Sussex Branch #87480
    ALB
    Keymaster

    Re County Council elections, West London branch are investigating the possibility standing a candidate in Guildford for the Surrey Council Council. Certain legal matters need to be sorted out before a final decision.

    in reply to: Whither France #123546
    ALB
    Keymaster
    in reply to: Stop Trump Protest #125172
    ALB
    Keymaster

    For the record, back numbers of the Socialist Standard were distributed to those attending. The report-back was that far less than the organisers anticipated turned up and that the Stop Trump Coalition is just another SWP front organisation. Nothing new — or interesting — there then.

    in reply to: Whither France #123545
    ALB
    Keymaster
    Capitalist Pig wrote:
    I like Le Pen

    Quelle surprise.

    ALB
    Keymaster

    This is what happened when Britain changed to the current calendar in 1752:http://www.historic-uk.com/HistoryUK/HistoryofBritain/Give-us-our-eleven-days/

    ALB
    Keymaster

    Because at the time Russia was using an old calender which was 13 days behind the one used (and still used) in the West, the Tsar was overthrow in March not February 1917 of course and the Bolshevik coup took place in November not October. So the "Great October Revolution" is a myth even on this level — it took place in November.

    in reply to: Kent and Sussex Branch #87477
    ALB
    Keymaster

    There are County Council elections in Durham too, which the Party has contested on a number of occasions.

    in reply to: Do machines produce surplus value? #124967
    ALB
    Keymaster

    This article contains an outline of Jevons's thinking and argumentation on this point:http://www.economictheories.org/2008/08/jevons-sunspots-and-commercial-activity.htmlI particularly liked this quote from him:

    Quote:
    If the planets govern the sun, and the sun governs the vintages and harvests, and thus the prices of food and raw materials and the state of the money market, it follows that the configurations of the planets may prove to be the remote causes of the greatest commercial disasters (Inves­tigations, p. 185).

    Is this a theory of what causes sun spots too?

    in reply to: Do machines produce surplus value? #124961
    ALB
    Keymaster

    What was absurd about Jevons's sun-spot theory of crises was not that crises (economic downturns) cannot be caused by some natural event (some obviously have been) but that a natural event explained the regular boom/slump cycle. Here's how Jevons set out his theory in his textbook Political Economy (1878):

    Quote:
    Good vintage years on the continent of Europe, and droughts in India, recur every ten or eleven years, and it seems probable that commercial crises are connected with a periodic variation of weather, affecting all parts of the earth, and probably arising from increased waves of heat received from the sun at average intervals of ten years and a fraction. A greater supply of heat increases the harvests, makes capital more abundant and trade more successful, and thus helps to create the hopefulness out of which a bubble arises. A falling off in the sun's heat makes bad harvests and deranges many enterprises in different parts of the world. This is likely to break the bubble and bring on a commercial collapse.

    As a statistician he was able to present figures showing some correlation between sun-spots and commercial crises, but this could surely serve as a classic case of the dictum that "correlation does not mean causation".The other objection to the theory is that it tries to explain the regularly recurring economic downturns that are a feature of capitalism by some event outside the system rather than by something inherent in the system itself.

    in reply to: Do machines produce surplus value? #124959
    ALB
    Keymaster

    At one time those who think that the exchange value of a product is determined by its "marginal utility" thought that utility could be measured in terms of some unit called perhaps a "util". They soon realised that this could not be done and now only argue that all that can be measured is whether or not  one thing is more useful than something else:https://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Principles_of_Economics/UtilityI'm not sure, though, how this helps them explain the different prices of different goods. I'd have thought it made it more difficult.

    in reply to: Do machines produce surplus value? #124951
    ALB
    Keymaster
    in reply to: Terry Barrett #125193
    ALB
    Keymaster

    There is something odd about this link as Terry Barrett died about ten years ago, so why is it being published now?. John Palmer, an IS original who would have known him personally, writing in 2009 said (scroll down to comment 4):

    Quote:
    Terry was an exceptional militant and socialist – who received his political education by the way NOT in the CP but in the SPGB.

    We'll need to check in our archives to see whether he was actually a member or just a sympathiser.

    in reply to: Ireland Elects #117085
    ALB
    Keymaster
    Young Master Smeet wrote:
    (I wouldn't be surpised if some London planner is looking at pulling Ireland out of the EU to resolve the border question).

    Maybe but I don't think the Irish ruling class is going to accept that.  The Republican tradition has always preferred to be dependent on Germany rather than Britain. Hence their support for Germany in both world wars and in 1978 the choice to join the European Monetary System breaking the 1 to 1 link between the Irish punt and the British pound, i.e in effect tying it to the DM. I can't see them going back on that.

    in reply to: Meanwhile, in Mosul #124358
    ALB
    Keymaster
    in reply to: Do machines produce surplus value? #124926
    ALB
    Keymaster

    What about "So buildings produce surplus value?" as a/the debate subject?

Viewing 15 posts - 6,001 through 6,015 (of 10,477 total)