ALB
Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
All of the reprint, with a new title, having now been distributed. North West members report:
“Our leaflet was called ‘YP – Labour 2.0?’ and argued that even if Your Party was ever able to form a government, it would inevitably suffer the same fate as the original Labour Party, meaning that YP would not change capitalism, capitalism would change YP. It’s quite possibly no coincidence that we handed Zara Sultana a leaflet in person, after which a YouTube video appeared in which she specifically denied that Your Party would turn into Labour 2.0.”
Others had been handing out leaflet about the YP becoming like the Labour Party, but they – in fact like our first leaflet – wrote of “Labour Mark 2”.
In any event, as far as we know, only our reprinted leaflet wrote of “Labour 0.2”.
https://x.com/zarahsultana/status/1994692841554247979/photo/1
Our leaflet was handed out yesterday in Liverpool and also on the Palestine March in London. Today it will be in Liverpool again and also at a trade union event in Frome in Somerset.
The SWP are reporting that they have been expelled from the new party:
Meanwhile the choice of names has been announced:
https://www.urban75.net/forums/attachments/img_7748-png.510594/
Are they serious? At least they won’t be mistaken for socialists.
They will fail at the first question “what is socialism?” as they will define it as a transitional society with wages, market, money, etc between capitalism and “communism” as a society of common ownership, democratic control, production directly for use and distribution according to needs, with no market, wages, money, etc — which is the correct answer to the question. The best description of what they call ”socialism” is “state capitalism”.
Distribution of our leaflet has been continuing. At a Corbyn meeting in Manchester on Tuesday and another in Oxford yesterday.
More have been printed, with a different heading — “Labour Party 0.2?” Instead of “Same Old Same Old?” — ready for handing out to those attending the founding of the new party this weekend in Liverpool. The first of these were distributed in Manchester on Tuesday.
The text of the leaflet remains the same arguing that as the new party will be pursuing reforms “it will become a Labour Party Mark 2”.
Others have been taking up this theme, with the SWP in Oxford handing out a leaflet saying “Your Party must not be Labour Mark 2” but a meeting on “Why Lenin Matters Today” advertised on the leaflet suggests that their alternative is a Bolshevik Party Mark 2. Or maybe it’s to outbid their main Trotskyist rival, SPEW, which has been calling for years for a Labour Party Mark 2.
For the record, our Corbynite reformist opponent in the local by-election in Islington Junction Ward a year ago has just defected to the Greens:
Wild speculation. Judging by her recent statements she’d be more likely to join the SWP than the Greens!
But it does seem that the Greens have won the left of Labour electoral franchise. If there’s any deal between them and the new Corbyn party they are in far the stronger bargaining position. We’ll see next May but I imagine they will reserve the council sears with the best prospective for themselves leaving the Corbyn party to take on Labour in the council estates and Muslim areas.
One straw in the wind is this defection from Corbyn to the Greens in his own fiefdom
https://x.com/jackson_caines/status/1991890532172452065
Jackson Caines stood as an “independent” candidate with Corbyn’s endorsement and support in a council by-election almost exactly a year ago:
https://www.islingtontribune.co.uk/article/mp-backs-independent-challenger-to-labour
We stood in that council by-election too:
https://www.islington.media/news/junction-by-election-result
The cautious position towards the new party of the CPB (the pro-China grouping that runs the Morning Star):
Zara Sultana says it again. This time in Durham on Saturday:
“What I’m saying is, we need socialism. We need to be explicitly socialist.
“That is not tweaking here and there. It’s not just lowering a few bills and a wealth tax just sprinkled on top, but it is a fundamental transformation of our society: the working class controlling the wealth that they produce and the means of production in their hands.” (Zarah Sultana, Durham, 15 November).Of course, as we say in our leaflet the new party is highly unlikely to pursue socialism as its aim but rather only sprinklings and end up a Labour Party Mark 2.
London branch leafleted two meetings this weekend. The SPEW annual weekend school and rally on Saturday at which Sultana was billed to speak and the East London member-only assembly to discuss the documents for the YP founding conference at the end of this month.
Not sure why Sultana is hobnobbing with them. Also there was one of the more way-out Trot groups, the Spartacist League and their paper “Workers Hammer”.
The East London meeting was held somewhere in the Olympic Park in Stratford that was not easy to get to and the venue management (not the organisers) did not allow leafletting outside the meeting place. So conditions were not ideal for leafleting those attending but we managed to hand out some though not as many as intended. The SWP suffered the same handicap.
Report from Gillingham (Kent) on meeting there yesterday:
“A fairly small meeting of about 20. I’d planned on leafleting as they went in, but I couldn’t see anyone around when I arrived so I went inside and was ushered into the meeting hall. I felt unsure if I should pretend to be there for the meeting and wait till the end to give out leaflets. I decided to come clean about my motive for attendance and they were really nice about it and offered tea and biccies and a table for my literature. So I did sit through the 90 mins of meeting and then gave them all a leaflet at the end. They had a table selling literature from the Socialist Alternative.”
Report from Doncaster;
“went to leaflet. was there early, hung around until well after the appointed time – no bugger turned up / building locked.”
This was a meeting advertised on the official Your Party site here:
https://in.yourparty.uk/en/events/279-doncaster-your-party-meeting
It looks like they haven’t quite got their act together yet.
Report from South Wales Branch;
“The Cardiff YP meeting was a flop. I reckon there were 40 attendees at the most [in a venue booked for up to 500], some may have been there already before I turned up around 10.15, I counted 35 going in over the next hour or so. The SPEW/Militant members I spoke to didn’t explicitly say they were planning to infiltrate YP, but their leaflets and paper gave me that impression. I missed a few people, so only handed out 30 leaflets.”
London branch members went to Brighton this morning to leaflet the members only YP assembly there. 5 Trotskyist groups were there too, the new one being “Socialist Alternative” (apparently a breakaway from SPEW). The RCG stall was flying the Venezuelan flag.
The previous evening a meeting in Putney in South West London addressed by Corbyn was leafletted. One of the SWP paper sellers said his grandfather had been in the SPGB. He has since contacted us for any articles written by his grandfather.
The striking thing about these various meetings we have attended is the age composition, with retired people being over-represented. Maybe the younger anti-Stamerites have joined the Green Party.
Party members were also out today leafletting YP meetings in Cardiff and Doncaster. Reports later.
