Jesus.
November 2026 › Forums › General discussion › Jesus.
- This topic has 323 replies, 7 voices, and was last updated 2 weeks, 3 days ago by
Thomas_More.
-
AuthorPosts
-
October 31, 2026 at 10:25 pm #267235
Bijou Drains
ParticipantCDM – “ The monastic nuns and sisters who took care of us were good women dedicated to their beliefs”
The ones that taught me were rather different.
They were generally, Small, bearded and vicious.
One had a “fragment of St Peter’s finger” (probably a chicken bone originally sold in the 14th Cerury) that we had to kiss and revere.
Catechism was beaten into you with a stick, left handed pupils were forced to use their right hand, infants were beaten with canes and rulers, etc.
In senior school many of the highly devout teachers were totally psychologically damaged. Teachers beat you up regularly, assembly involved standing for an hour, reciting novenas, rosaries and other devotional prayers. Movement or twitching resulted in bearings from our 6 foot 3, Glaswegian maniac headmaster and we were taught history only up to the reformation, as if Protestantism was a myth.
Our “houses” were More, Maine, Campion and Fisher, all Catholic martyrs from the reformation.
We were taught the facts of life, including contraception by the School priest. My mate John, at the age of 15 put his hand up in the sex education lesson and said “Father, surely if you don’t play the game, you should make up the rules?”
🤣
The priest was so gobsmacked he forgot to cane him!This waa not from private or public schools, just a normal Catholic education in the North of England.
Lots of the kids were 2nd generation immigrants from Ireland, Poland, Italy, Spain, etc. so they didn’t say anything about the violence and abuse they faced because their parents were devoted Catholics.
One of my local parish priests was moved to another parish, I later found out that there we’re allegations of sexual abuse made against him. One of the teachers we had was moved to our school because he’d been touching children in another school. The Catholic Church did little or nothing to stop the abuse of children, placing the organisation in front of the victims (a bit like the SWP).
De Valera’s Ireland is what the Catholic Church wanted, subservience, funding, control.
I find it amazing that many leftist groups idealise the Irish Revolution. It led to 70 years of working class oppression
October 31, 2026 at 10:43 pm #267236Thomas_More
ParticipantNow I understand your hatred for Catholicism in particular. You have good reason.
October 31, 2026 at 11:35 pm #267237Bijou Drains
ParticipantI dislike Catholicism, but not Catholics as such.
I have a cousin who is a Catholic Monk and he’s one of the nicest people you could meet. My father was a devout Catholic, and as a man he will always be one of my heroes.
I think there’ll always be a bit of the Stockholm Syndrome for a lot of ex Catholics.
I also heard parts of the Latin Mass a few months ago and I was moved by the beauty of it (man made beauty by the way).
But I also counter balance that with things such as the Tuam Babies Scandal
November 1, 2026 at 10:27 pm #267287Movimiento Socialista Mundial
ParticipantBD
My experience was different, and I have good memories of the catholic and the episcopal church, and of liberation theology and their members working with the poor workers and with the peasants, and some went to jail; in Argentina, many of them were killed and tortured.d
Some La Salle brothers that I met left because they wanted more social and political activities;s, for them, it was not enough. They were limited due to religious views, but they were trained to become teachers, and that was their mission, and they supported natural sciences, humanities, literature, and personal analysis; one of them became an atheist.
We did not experience any sexual violations or personal harassment; probably, it is a cultural thing and a sense of community and respect. They treated us like their own children. We cried when some of our teachers died because we loved them, and sometimes we wanted to be like them; teachers were an extension of our family.
-
This reply was modified 2 weeks, 5 days ago by
Movimiento Socialista Mundial.
November 3, 2026 at 12:03 am #267341Movimiento Socialista Mundial
ParticipantI am really dismayed that atheist academics of renown are saying there is lots of evidence for an historical Jesus. This translates to the kind of “fact” on internet searches too about the “proven existence of Jesus.”
These academics then quote Paul’s epistles as proof! They also rehash the Josephus interpolations, and the remarks on Christians in Pliny the Younger, Tacitus and Suetonius. All these do is report the existence of Christians, not of Jesus.
How can such bright people repeat the claim of “lots of evidence” for Jesus?
—————————————————————————–
Many medical doctors go to church every Sunday knowing that Medicine (especially medical embryology) has proven the natural origin of life. For more than 50,000 years, medicine was influenced by magic, cranium trepanation, and blood spilling to remove the spirits, and shamanism.
They believe in the divinity of Christ, the so-called Holy Trinity, the transmutation from wine into blood and bread into flesh (cannibalism or anthropophagy). Drinking blood was an old pagan ritual; there are still people drinking turtles’ blood for sexual stimulation, to stimulate manhood ( afrodisiac ). Also, autovampirism, or autohemophagia, is an old pagan ritual and mental disorder. There is an alcoholic drink ( mamajuana, guavaberry, prepared by shamans and behiques ) that contains turtles’ testicles, roots, and fruits to boost libido, which is only an old myth without any scientific basis
November 3, 2026 at 8:37 am #267350Thomas_More
ParticipantMost medical doctors also look down contemptuously on fellow animals, the result of training in vivisection, for which they were desensitized in their youth. Which is also why so many were recruited for human vivisection and torture by vicious regimes.
November 3, 2026 at 10:35 pm #267406Thomas_More
ParticipantThere was genuine herbal knowledge too. I would rein in any 100% support for the modern medical business. US pharmaceuticals flooded Chile following the Pinochet coup, profit-driven and mostly unnecessary.
Yes, there was superstition before modern medicine, but there was also much more of a holistic approach of respect for the patient and the potency of many herbs is well documented. A lot of knowledge available to medieval monastic herbalists suffered from the dissolution of the monasteries. Hippocrates recognised the importance above all of hygiene. Today’s capitalist-controlled and vivisection-based medical business is about profits, and there is profit to be made from disease. Not only “alternative medicine” is to be blamed.
In socialism there would be more diversity in medicine and unnecessary pharmaceuticals which cause further problems in the patient would be dispensed with, as profits would no longer exist. This would apply alike to both allocentric and “alternative” medicine, which categories would no longer separately exist, but all would have to scientifically work. Vivisection will be abolished because it is a blind for profit-driven medicine, not to mention utterly repugnant to any ethical person.THE NAKED EMPRESS, OR THE GREAT MEDICAL FRAUD by Hans Ruesch.
AI: ” • Publication Year: 1982 (first published by CIVIS Publications in Zurich, Switzerland).
• Core Subject: Unlike his earlier 1978 book Slaughter of the Innocent—which primarily focused on the moral, medical, and scientific arguments against animal experimentation (vivisection)—Naked Empress heavily targeted the profit motives of the pharmaceutical and medical-industrial complex in perpetuating the practice.
• Publisher: CIVIS Publications (founded by Ruesch, who also led the Centre for Scientific Information on Vivisection).
You can find copies or editions of the book through platforms like AbeBooks.”A copy was also donated to the SPGB library.
-
This reply was modified 2 weeks, 3 days ago by
Thomas_More.
-
This reply was modified 2 weeks, 3 days ago by
Thomas_More.
-
This reply was modified 2 weeks, 3 days ago by
Thomas_More.
November 4, 2026 at 2:47 am #267411Movimiento Socialista Mundial
ParticipantYo have a wrong conception about medicine and doctors. To understand medicine you must study medicine because somebody gave an opinion about medicine and doctors is not enough to be understood .
You are getting involved in a very complicated medical field, which is pharmacology, which requires knowledge of general chemistry and organic chemistry. That is why the curriculum of medicine includes organic chemistry, also known as biological chemistry, and it also requires knowledge of mathematics.
I was talking about scientific medicine, not commercial medicine, and many doctors are not business people; they are dedicated to their profession, saving human lives and curing treatable diseases. Medicine cannot cure incurable diseases, and thousands of diseases can not be cured.
Most doctors do not prescribe opioid medications, and there are many alternatives within the field of pharmacology.
Most doctors cannot memorise the whole list of medications; there are books used for that, and most drug books have the original name and generic names, the description of the medication, the chemical components, the secondary effects, and the interaction with other medications.
Most doctors do not know everything; they must consult with more experienced doctors or with internists, and doctors, like any human, can make mistakes too. People think that doctors are infallible
Most medications have secondary effects because medications travel the whole human body and interact with different organs and systems; sometimes patients abuse the use of certain medications looking for rapid solutions, and doctors cannot work miracles.
Depression can be socially produced, and chemical imbalances and some medications are prescribed to balance chemicals like serotonin
Many doctors have lost their license due to over prescribing opioid medications to produce more profits and more income.
My comments about the psychoanalysts who was a member of the spbg is about his connection of medicine with the external world and his connection with materialism which is the proper ways to treat diseases, there is a connection between our brain and our organs functioning , that is the reason why doctors study semiology to see the relationship between patients signs, culture and their own world
November 4, 2026 at 8:21 am #267430Thomas_More
Participant#267406: Edit button removed too quickly. Please change “Most doctors look down …” to “Allocentric medicine looks down ..”
Again, written by me in the heat of the moment. -
This reply was modified 2 weeks, 5 days ago by
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
