50 years in the Party

December 2023 Forums Socialist Standard Feedback 50 years in the Party

Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)
  • Author
  • #210518

    There’s a discussion going on about this article with a member of the Socialist Labor Party of America. Before the great hacking such comments used to be automatically posted here too.

    Anyway, here’s the link if anybody wants to follow the discussion or join in:

    50 Years in the Party

    Cde Bortnick … it has got to be the same person … has a website. He’s an artist. An 88 year-old artist at  that. http://www.bernardbortnick.com/#Bio%20and%20Contact.html

    Bernard Bortnick visited our Conference in London a couple of years ago and got into trouble with the SLP for saying something there without authorisation. Although the SLP and us are relatively near on political positions and the language we use, there seems to be a huge difference when it comes to internal political culture. We are open, equals and democratic.


    The SLP was imbued with an element of American nationalism and what appears to be a respect for the US Constitution

    It may be anecdotal but i recall hearing of a multi-party conference which included the SLP but another party had laid the Stars and Stripes on the ground at the entrance so it meant walking over it and no doubt wiping your feet on it. The SLP delegation declined and departed.

    Worth a quick read on the SLP

    Socialist Courier: Rab – Part 3 (socialist-courier.blogspot.com)

    At the Mound in Edinburgh when i first joined during the 70s there was an elderly lone SLPer who attended the outdoor meetings. I should have been more attentive to his conversations.

    Personally i think De Leon’s ‘sword and shield’ analogy of the political and the industrial organisation of the working class is a good one, i’m even amenable to the switching of what is the sword and what is the shield  depending on the situation.


    In switching you’d be in good company. At one time De Leon argued that political action was the sword and economic organisation the shield (his position at the time the SPGB was formed in 1904 and basically ours if you like). But when the IWW was formed in 1905 he switched to saying that economic organisation and action was the sword and political action the shield.

    I think I’ve got it the right way round.


    The SLP of America has a web page on Facebook and Twitter. I do not know if they are coming back or they are again getting some muscles

Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.