EETPU: a bosses’ union?

As expected this year’s TUC conference held in Bournemouth at the beginning of September voted to expel the electricians’ union (EETPU). Contrary to the impression given by much of the media the expulsion was not for making single union deals or for making no strike agreements. Regarding the former, these are accepted as legitimate by most unions and have a long history. John Edmonds of the General, Municipal and Boilermakers Union (GMB) outlined how the forerunner to this organisation signed its first single union deal 99 years ago at a gas works. The Transport and General Workers Union (TGWU) outlined in a recent memorandum to its members that it had no real objection to single union deals. The reason for the expulsion was that the EETPU broke the rules of the TUC regarding inter-union relations as contained in the Bridlington Agreement which dates back to 1939. The EETPU were in breach of this ruling in two cases. At Orion in Port Talbot the TGWU had members but the company gave the electricians sole negotiating rights in a single union agreement. The second case concerned two Christian Salvensen plants in Warrington and London where the company offered a single union deal to the EETPU without consulting three other unions with whom it also had agreements. Complaints from the other unions involved were investigated by the TUC disputes committee who found the EETPU in the wrong. Consequently the electricians’ union were asked to withdraw from these agreements and it was their refusal to do so which led first of all to their suspension and finally to their expulsion.

Hammond’s defence of his union s strategy was summed up in his speech to congress. No apology was made or intended for breaking the rules of the movement of which the EETPU had been a part. Instead Hammond outlined how those who were opposed to his way of thinking were out of touch with their members. The EETPU are, he said, the modern face of trade unionism. The union had an open door and any person was free to come in or walk out. Modern trade unionism was about communicating with its members and providing people with individual choice.

Hammond’s speech raised many queries. What kind of communication through trade union democracy does the EETPU offer? What does it mean by individual choice? In a society where the majority have to sell their ability to work to the owners of the means of production and distribution and need effective organisation, what sort of trade unionism is the EETPU offering to workers?

A member of SOGAT 82 in a letter to The Guardian, (8 September. 1988) notes how the EETPU’s claim that it is one of the more democratic unions is open to question. Of its 150 full-time officers only 15 are subject to election. This number includes the general secretary and the executive council (E.C.) with the remainder of the full-time officers being appointed by the E.C. A rule introduced in 1977 allowing appointed officials to stand for election to the E.C. makes it more difficult for lay members to successfully seek election to that body as full-time officers have more influence and are in a better position to gain support. Motions to the union’s conference have to be submitted first to the E.C. for their consideration. The E.C. also have some influence over delegates to the conference. Each branch can elect one delegate only irrespective of its size and additional delegates are elected by industrial conference, the number elected being determined by the executive council.

Hammond’s claim about offering workers more individual choice is based on the same type of hypocrisy as the present government’s supposed concern for trade union democracy. The EETPU have become renowned for single union deals in recent years. For example the two agreements previously mentioned; the choice of which union was to be given sole representation and negotiating rights was not made by the workers themselves but was decided over their heads by union leaders and the employers concerned. In such circumstances even if workers are given the opportunity to join an alternative union of their own choice, that organisation would not be able to exert any influence within the plant as it will be denied the right to represent its members. Also, single union deals mean that workers seeking a job in a plant which recognises only one union will, if that union is not the one recognised by the company, have to resign from the union of their choice and join the one recognised by the company. The truth is that single union deals, particularly the type pursued by the EETPU, offer workers less choice than multi-union agreements. In a society which offers the majority little choice in any respect it is important that workers should be able to decide which union represents them.

This leads on to perhaps the most important question: just what type of trade unionism is on offer from Hammond’s brand of new realism ?

Apart from the fact that it is left to union leaders and employers to decide which union should, in this case, misrepresent workers. this brand of unionism weakens the main weapon workers have in defending themselves their ability to withdraw their labour. Socialists whilst supporting the use of the strike weapon do not do so out of some idealistic belief that the right to strike is a fundamental human right which is the hallmark of any free society. Our experience shows us that such a perspective can only be supported by those with little understanding of the world they live in.

In a truly free and democratic society the means for producing and distributing the things we need to live will be owned in common and subject to democratic control and productive capacity will be used directly to satisfy self determined human need. In such a society the need to strike would not be necessary. However ability to withdraw one’s labour is not a right but an absolute necessity for the working class in a society where the majority have to sell their ability to work to those who own and control the productive capacity. Such a society is divided into two antagonistic classes. It is in the interests of the employing class to buy labour power as cheaply as possible and to be able to control it to realise a value from it in excess of that paid out in wages and salaries. On the opposite side of the class divide are the working class whose interest lies in getting as high a price as possible for the sale of their labour power as it is their only means of economic survival.

Workers also need to be organised to be able to resist, where possible, attempts to reorganise production since this may lead to a deterioration of working or economic conditions.

Hammond claims that he can overcome this inherent conflict of interest and forge a partnership between capital and labour. One idea is that instead of resorting to industrial action when a conflict cannot be resolved through the collective bargaining process both sides should agree to the contentious issue being put to pendulum arbitration. Under this method an independent’ outside arbitrator will examine the issue in dispute and decide in favour of one side or the other — a compromise solution is ruled out. This system is beneficial to workers, it is claimed, because it prevents management from being able to impose a unilateral decision on the workforce. The point is that providing workers have as a back up to the collective bargaining process the freedom to take industrial action, they will be in a position to prevent unilateral management action and what is more important their ability to do so here rests on independent self-organisation. Under no-strike pendulum arbitration agreements workers are left without the option of putting economic pressure on the arbitrator who is thus more likely to decide in favour of the dominant interests of capital.

Where does the expulsion of the EETPU leave the British trade union movement? A report in The Guardian (10 September, 1988) suggested that Tony Christopher, the new chairperson of the TUC, will be making attempts to get the EETPU back into the TUC. Such a move may include reviewing the Bridlington Rules, the breaking of which led to the expulsion. The fact that a merger between the Amalgamated Engineering Union (AEU). a member of the TUC and the EETPU now a non member, is still set to go ahead will create obvious problems. However the re-entry of the EETPU to the fold seems unlikely to take place smoothly. In reality what lies behind the split goes deeper than the breaking of the rules of the TUC even though that was the reason for the expulsion. Essentially it concerns the face of modern trade unionism. Such disagreements cannot be simply put down to a right-left division. Some unions considered to be right of centre are very much opposed to the methods of the EETPU. For example John Edmonds of the GMB, not renowned for adopting a militant standpoint and. in many respects, a keen supporter of ‘new realism’, made the following statement at the congress.

“I totally reject the hyped up notion that the only way to be a modern trade union is to forget our basic task of looking after people and to accept values handed down by multi-nationals based in Wapping and Detroit. We are not here to do a favour for Lord Hanson or to pout prettily for Rupert Murdoch. We are here to win dignity for working people at work.” (quoted in The Guardian. 6 September. 1988)

The working class have no need for organisations which in effect are little more than company unions designed to help companies pursue the efficient exploitation of their workforce. Effective, democratically controlled organisations are needed which can be put to use in workers’ struggles. There is a dangerous idea being developed, probably not for the first time, that to survive trade unions need to become more involved with company objectives. For example a recent study by David Metcalf. Professor of Industrial Relations at the London School of Economics, indicates that companies are better off without unions. Non-union companies, the study suggests, have both higher productivity and profits than companies operating with trade unions. Socialists wish to inform Professor Metcalf that unions, contrary to the impression he seems to have, do not exist to raise productivity and profits. In fact the study does provide (probably unintentionally) evidence of the usefulness of effective trade unionism in modern capitalist society. Firstly it states that in unionised firms wage differentials by race, sex and occupation are narrower than in non-unionised companies. Secondly it shows that employees belonging to trade unions are paid 7-10 per cent more than those not belonging to unions. The higher the density of union membership the greater is the wage mark up, with closed shops proving best of all. Less skilled and lower paid women and particularly black workers gain from union membership when compared with white male skilled workers in non-unionised firms. Unions have also had some success in protecting the under privileged at work and this has caused problems for the present government in its efforts to encourage more lower paid jobs in the services to mop up the unemployed. The benefit of trade unions to lower paid workers is shown by the fact that employers in the service industries such as hotel and catering are vehemently opposed to unionisation as they rely on imposing extremely low wages and long hours of work on their workforce which contains a high proportion of women and immigrant workers.

Thus the case for all workers belonging to and becoming active in trade unions is as clear today as it ever was. There are indications which suggest that amongst many groups of workers there is the beginnings of a rebirth of militancy’, meaning they are getting fed up with being kicked around. This has been notable in recent months amongst car workers, seamen and most recently postal workers. Even though a small sample poll conducted for the Sunday Times found that 42% of trade unionists backed the EETPU whilst only 32 per cent supported the TUC. the same poll, even more significantly, found that almost two thirds objected to a no-strike clause being included in single union deals. As Ian Aitkin, writing in The Guardian (5 September. 1988) suggests “without such a clause a good many employers would find Mr Hammond’s single union agreements a good deal less appealing. ”

The problems many workers face is the economic cost of taking industrial action in order to defend themselves. This very fact should reveal to workers that under the present organisation of society they are far from free but are. on the contrary, subject to a form of dictatorship — economic dictatorship. It is the organisation of present day worldwide society which makes it necessary for workers to combine to protect themselves. This society has also created a body of women and men who wish to go further than the defensive struggle within capitalism to which trade unionism is confined. Socialists have as their aim the ending of a system of wage slavery by removing the conditions on which it rests. Marx noted how the position of the free labourer under capitalism differs from the slave who sold his or her self to an owner, or a serf who was tied to the land. “The worker”. Marx explains.

“. . . belongs neither to the owner nor the land, but eight, ten. twelve, fifteen hours of his daily life belong to him who buys them. The worker leaves the capitalist to whom he hires himself whenever he likes, and the capitalist discharges him whenever he thinks fit. as soon as he no longer gets any profit out of him. or not the anticipated profit. But the worker whose sole source of livelihood is the sale of his labour power, cannot leave the whole class of purchasers, that is, the capitalist class, without renouncing his existence. He belongs not to this or that capitalist but to the capitalist class, and moreover. it is his business to dispose of himself, that is to find a purchaser within the capitalist class.” (Wage Labour and Capital)
RAY CARR

Leave a Reply