Brent: cuts versus needs

The people of Brent have every right to be angry. The borough has been thrown as a living sacrifice upon the altar of profit. Basic services have been savagely depleted as the Council is forced to cut £17 million from its expenditure budget in order to please the vandals called economists.

What have these cuts meant in practical terms? One in five home helps has been sacked; let the old look after themselves. Four residential homes for the elderly are closing down. 600 workers in the school meals service are to go: let the kids bring their own food to eat. The refuse collection service has had its budget cut by 20 per cent; in future dustbins will only be emptied fortnightly, if that. There used to be 209 dustmen in Brent. Now there are 116; let the rubbish rot in the streets. The number of road sweepers has been cut from 142 to 96. An increase in street vermin is expected to follow the cuts; but cuts in Brent’s environmental health department mean that if they are to be removed it is likely to be in the more affluent streets, where residents can afford to buy the use of private firms. 233 teachers are to be removed from Brent education. This is in a borough where the lack of money for education and the high number of non-English speaking pupils has put a unique strain upon the schools. Last term 162 teaching jobs went as a result of the cuts, and now there are to be efforts to get rid of a further 233 unwanted teachers by voluntary redundancies. 60 primary teachers have so far agreed to go; 94 secondary school posts had to go by the end of October, or else, for the first time in the history of London education, compulsory sackings will take place. Brent’s youth and community services are to be cut to the point of virtual extinction. 17 youth and community centres will close down. An 80 per cent cut in this area of social service staffing will mean that 100 full-time jobs will go. and 400 part-time workers will have the task of carrying on with a budget reduced from £4.5 million to £450,000. The number of Brent’s social workers has been cut by nearly 20 per cent. In the next round of cuts in January many more jobs will go in the social services department, compulsory redundancies in schools will be inevitable and it is anticipated that several libraries will have to be sold off.

All of this has been carried out. not by Thatcherite monsters with top hats and cigars, but by a Labour Council. Indeed. Brent Labour Party is known as one of the most Leftist in the whole of Britain. It is a Labour Council that has wielded the knife which has hurt so many Brent workers. The leader of Brent Council, who claims to be a socialist, has a picture of Mikhail Gorbachev on the wall of his Town Hall office. The Brent East Labour MP, Ken Livingstone, whose political patronage was provided by the Labour Left who control the Council, has stated that the rulers of Brent reminded him of Pol Pot’s regime. Ron Anderson, a Labour councillor and long-standing Brent Leftist, has said that Brent is being ruled like a Stalinist state, with a small caucus of rulers running the finances. Harsh criticisms, but neither Livingstone or Anderson have been quick to explain how Brent could have avoided the mess.

Brent is different from most other London boroughs, and most non-London areas. Firstly, it has the highest number of workers living in it who were not born in Britain. Secondly, the borough has an unusually high number of homeless workers. Thirdly, the number of workers living on or below the poverty line in Brent (particularly in the south and east of the borough, which used to be Willesden before fusion with the more prosperous Wembley area in the north) is much higher than in most parts of Britain. Brent politics has long been dominated by Labour with the Tories having their own stronghold in Brent North, the constituency of the awful Rhodes Boyson. Like most London Labour parties. Brent constituency Labour Party (CLP) is highly factionalised. There has always been a strong hard left in Brent who have argued that the Council should make no compromises with the demands of the profit system for cheap services. Unlike most London CLPs. and more like New York politics, Brent Labour Party has. over the past decade, been divided into several ethnic sections: Afro-Caribbean, Indian Hindu, Muslim, as well as strong Jewish and Irish lobbies. (It is the latter that Ken Livingstone has had to play to in order to win votes with his posturing over the IRA. and the former who have ensured that Livingstone has of late made some uncharacteristically pro-Israeli noises.) These ethnic factions do not correspond in any particular way to ideological divisions. So, for example, five years ago there was the case of a Jamaican-born councillor, given her job with the strong support of the Trotskyist faction, who lost an argument in favour of having segregated education for West Indian children so that they could be taught Christian values and beaten when they misbehaved, and then joined the Tory party. At that time Labour only had a majority of one on the Council and power passed briefly to a Tory-Liberal coalition. Ironically, many of the policies of the mid-1980s which have been dubbed ‘loony leftist’ were initiated by the Tory rulers during their administration. The reason was that only by pandering to the various local interest groups can any administration retain power in Brent.

The main reason for Brent’s financial mess arose out of a failure on the part of its rulers to understand that capitalism cannot be run in such a way as to please workers living under it. Brent Council’s futile policy of trying to ignore the profit system, at least in terms of its public image, has resulted in overspending in order to win/buy votes. In a system where profit comes first, needs a distant second, the price to be paid for failing to be economically callous is economic collapse. Now the workers of Brent are having to pay the hard price of the populist antics of the political opportunists whose reformism promised capitalism without the cuts. New managers will be brought in. advised by pinstriped vandals from The London School of Economics and Human Misery, and they will see that the accounts are kept in order. The God of Profit must be fed; to hell with the human cost.

Paul Johnson started out life as a columnist on The New Statesman writing twaddle about how Labour governments could run capitalism well, leaving the workers contented. Experience showed him that he had been as wrong as all other reformist day-dreamers. Johnson’s condition deteriorated instead of improving. He became a Tory — an ultra-crazy Tory at that so mad, indeed, that he now writes a regular column for The Daily Mail. On 15 August Johnson wrote an article entitled ‘The blight Burma shares with Brent’. Both ‘collapsing regimes provide striking proof that the quest for socialist utopias invariably ends in nightmares.’ He tells his readers that in both Burma and Brent ‘socialist policies have been tested to the destruction.’ The reality is quite the opposite. What the current crisis in Brent proves is that you can never run a system of production for sale and profit, however sincere and ‘progressive’ the rulers, except by hurting the workers whose needs must come second to the profit priority. In neither Brent nor Burma have those who have had power won it on the basis of aiming to produce solely for use. not for the market. Indeed, as Labour’s national leader spelt out in Blackpool at the party’s conference, speaking of his party’s task ahead. ‘The kind of economy that we are faced with is going to be a market economy, and we have got to make it work better than the Tories make it work.’ In Brent the Council has tried to beat the Tories at the game of running capitalism locally, and they have ended up playing the same game according to the same old, despicable Tory rules. Tories like Johnson have no reasons to gloat: in Conservative-controlled Westminster Council they sold a local cemetery, workers’ graves and all, for under a quid to a property company who wanted to build offices on the land. And the only reason that Tory councils like Westminster and Merton are not cutting services as savagely as Brent is because the services were never there in the first place.

Many Brent workers have taken strike action against the Council. Social workers were shocked into striking when the Council cut provisions for dealing with local child abuse and closed down a home for handicapped kids. Teachers have also taken strike action. None of this will change anything. Brent’s administrators are being forced to learn the hard lesson that running capitalism in an area of particular poverty and ethnic deprivation is a job for heartless swines, not councillors who listen to the cries of the needy.

In Brent, as everywhere else, the real choice is between a system which puts needs first and one which puts the market profit first. We know from Kinnock’s words and Brent Council’s actions which side they are on. The alternative is presented by the socialists. Workers may ignore the socialist alternative at their cost — a human cost which in Brent is causing hardship and heartache which should not ever be voted for again.

Postscript
Since this article was written, the situation in Brent has deteriorated. The Town Hall and other municipal buildings have been mortgaged to a Japanese bank in order to raise money to maintain basic services. Compulsory redundancies of teachers and social workers have now been ordered. Brent’s only home for the part-time care of handicapped children has been closed. Parents have demonstrated against the Labour councillors but the Japanese owners are unlikely to listen.
STEVE COLEMAN

Leave a Reply