China and Statism

November 2026 › Forums › General discussion › China and Statism

Tagged: ,

Viewing 15 posts - 61 through 75 (of 92 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #267258
    LBird
    Participant

    Thanks to those comrades who expressed their caring for my medical trauma!

    Regarding China, its party, and its democracy, what do other posters think of this:

    From Yan’an to the Fifth Plenum: the CPC’s commitment to self-reform

    Is it just ruling class bluff, or does the CCP widely believe this?

    #267276

    Don’t forget their adoration in China of Thatcher and Idi Amin.

    ———————————————————————-

    That is only one of the few reactionary governments and leaders that Mao and his gangs supported, including Pin. The situation is obvious, and still many groups continue supporting Mao and the government of China, and until now they are calling China a socialist country, which means that they do not have a clue of what socialism really is

    After Salvador Allende was overthrown by the military in combination with the USA, the CIA and Henry Kissinger, who was the creator of the death squad and the Condor operation that killed thousands of people, including members of leftist groups, they kept diplomatic and commercial relationships with Augusto Pinochet; they expelled all the ambassadors that supported Allende; they offered military and logistical aid, and financial and economic aid to Augusto Pinochet.

    They just wanted to expand their own market as they are doing now, proving what Luxembourg said that all capitalists countries are imperialists, the commercial relationship with Latin America, was started during the time of Mao and they expanded it more when the gangs of four was removed by a coup conducted by Ping and his gangs of gangsters, the gangs of four ( called the gangs of five by some Maoist groups ) belonged to the old Maoist circles, all of them became powerful during the cultural revolution including the wife of Mao.

    Ping had previously been attacked by Mao and after the death of Mao Tse Tung they conducted a coup and all of them were arrested, some went to prison others were executed, all these actions were published on Albania Today during the time of Enver Hoxha, and the magazine was distributed around the whole world by subscriptions, they initiated the so called four modernizations introduced by Enlai and Ping to convert china into a world capitalist power, the capitalist development of China started during the time of Mao and after his death, the four modernization included the military expansion of China, and a long process of deregulation was started.
    .

    They supported the military dictatorship of Pakistan and the genocide committed against Bangladesh to weaken India, which was an ally of the Soviet Union. They provided military and financial aid to Pakistan; Mao himself advised the peasant leaders to support the Pakistan army.
    .
    In Africa, they supported several reactionary and anti communists groups and governments, including he government of Mobutu; they supported reactionary regimes in Angola, Laos, and the Shah of Iran, and all of them received military and financial aid from China during the time of Mao.

    They were just competing against the Soviet Union to expand and establish their own spheres of influence.

    This group is still one of the dinosaurs left that is defending China and calling China a socialist country; many Maoist groups do not support China anymore. They have recognised that it is just another capitalist country; some ex-pro-Albanian groups who rejected Maoism completely are forming alliances.

    This is an ex-Maoist, Stalinist, and still-Leninist group that has written several articles about China; the so-called regulation is a myth; there is a large privatisation process showing that state capitalism is not so efficient. They are using Leninist jargon to explain their analysis. The same process is taking place in Vietnam under their so-called market socialism. In reality, that process started to take place in Yugoslavia under Tito, who was a friend of the Western powers, like Pol Pot
    . https://www.communistvoice.org/00China.html

    The CPC has been in a self-adjusting process since it started under the leadership of Mao; they are like the evangelicals: they have been on a revival mission for many years.

    The Maoists themselves are saying that the Congress of the CPC is just a congress of capitalists adjusting themselves to the cyclical crisis of capitalism, and the central committee is conducted by capitalists; there is no difference between the internal capitalist struggles of the US republican party and the Democratic Party

    #267307

    @LBird,
    When Richard III became king he set about decrying abuse of justice and calling for fair courts (see propaganda here: https://richardiii.net/richard-iii-his-world/reputation/a-man-of-the-people-richard-iii-the-pursuit-of-justice/), yet before he was king, he was as capable as any feudal magnet of engaging in lawfare to hoover up manorial estates and revenues.

    By which, I mean, all authorities have always been against corruption, especially while trying to win support.

    #267312
    twc
    Participant

    From Yan’an to the Fifth Plenum: the CPC’s commitment to self-reform

    This communiqué is a panegyric to the Chinese Communist Party’s minority rule — in perpetuity — over its majority working class.

    Its assurances to its working class are indistinguishable from Lenin’s of 1920. Thus, Mao: “Only when the people are allowed to supervise the government will the government not slacken”.

    The communiqué claims to have “found two answers to the question of how [the Chinese Communist Party] can escape the historical cycle of rise and fall?”

    Its answer is by “the people’s oversight over government, and the Party’s self-reform.”

    The Party “tolerates no corruption”, and “has no special interests of its own besides the interests of the working class.”

    It reassures us with: “Vietnam’s “blazing furnace” anti-corruption campaign shows that other ruling communist parties are drawing similar conclusions, and many parties in Africa, Asia and Latin America study the CPC’s experience closely.”

    So how can it “stay in touch with the masses?”

    This is a sticky question when the Chinese Communist Party is the government and forbids its “masses” the use of a democratic franchise.

    Yet Mao already solved this problem in 1943, describing his solution — not one of cooperation — but as a “method of leadership”.

    “Take the scattered and unsystematic ideas of the masses, concentrate them through study into systematic ideas, then return to the masses to propagate and explain them “until the masses embrace them as their own”, testing them in action. “From the masses, to the masses” means that leadership is a continuous, two-way, dialectical relationship between Party and people.”

    And so, in the words of its communiqué, the Party’s objective is to ensure that it “always remains a vibrant Marxist governing party that stays at the forefront of the times, enjoys the wholehearted support of the people, and is able to withstand all tests”.

    That should reassure the masses.

    #267316
    LBird
    Participant

    @LBird,
    When Richard III became king he set about decrying abuse of justice and calling for fair courts … yet before he was king, he was as capable as any feudal magnet of engaging in lawfare to hoover up manorial estates and revenues.

    The political question is, though, did he set up a justice system that was widely recognised as ‘fair courts’ for the majority of people regarding laws that most people would have been involved in going to court for, in defence of their own judicial interests, like theft and murder? Obviously leaving aside the issue of what the minority of great landowners also used the justice system for, ie. their own class interests.

    If a ‘fair court’ system was set up, surely this was a positive progression for the majority on an earlier lawless society?

    #267317
    LBird
    Participant

    <strong class=”d4pbbc-bold”>From Yan’an to the Fifth Plenum: the CPC’s commitment to self-reform
    ….

    That should reassure the masses.

    That’s the political question that I’m asking – does it ‘reassure the masses’?

    • This reply was modified 2 weeks, 6 days ago by LBird.
    #267323
    Thomas_More
    Participant

    Confused. Why are we talking about Richard III here? And the word is magnate.

    #267330

    @LBird, the point was, twas ever thus, he does get some credit for a stated purpose of fighting corruption in his short lived regime (but when need arose, he didn’t shirk from corruption). Pretty much every authoritarian regime is against corruption, nominally (indeed, without law and regulation, in some ways it is difficult to be corrupt).

    #267337

    Without understanding Mao Tse-tung’s thought, which is an extension of Leninism-Stalinism and Blanquism, it is very difficult to understand what is taking place in China and what happened before and after the formation of the Chinese republic. Statism has always existed in China since the time of the dynasties; the despotic Asiatic mode of production is older than British capitalism

    Maoism is the most brutal application of the vanguard party to lead over the workers; the Cultural Revolution is one of the few examples that turned Maoism into a fanatic religion, similar to the Spanish Inquisition, and Mao was the Chinese Torquemada

    The cult of Mao was even stronger than the cult toward Stalin; cultists do not use reasoning; they just follow their leaders blindly

    That is one of the reasons why the cult toward Donald Trump is so strong; in this case, the ruling class has used Christianity or nationalist evangelicals. In China, the ruling class used Maoism, which is also a bourgeois nationalist conception

    The Albanian tendency and Hoxhaism debunked Maoism completely; the problem was that they were Leninists too, like Trotskyism and left communists were not able to break away from Leninism; everything goes back to the vanguard party concept; that is the reason why the SPGB correctly call it the Russian Machiavellian manipulation, manipulation from the top to the bottom

    Maoism is not gone; it is still there, and they continue manipulating the workers,s and after the incident that killed thousands of workers and students, the grip over the workers has been increased; their control over the workers is stronger than Stalinism. It is like saying that Stalinism was gone during and after Kruschev; the head was gone, but the ideology was left

    Lenin and Stalin knew the real meaning of socialism, and they used certain Marxist phraseology, but Mao did not know the real definition of socialism; he is an empty suit. I do not know how some groups have been able to find Marxist conception in Maoism; there is nothing in Maoism.

    The answer is that they never knew anything about Marxist theory ( as Adam said, the world only knew Stalinism) and state capitalism; nobody has ever had the same Marxist background as the socialist party, including the most famous theorists; it was like citing Bible verses. Any ex-Maoists that try to join the socialist party must first obtain a political exorcism.

    It is a Chinese nationalist conception applicable to third-world countries. That is the reason why it became so popular in Latin America and Africa, and many groups became guerrilla fighters, and all of them were completely wiped out by the state because they did not have any support among the peasants; they only had peasant support in China and Vietnam. Some groups, like the missionaries, sent cadres to work in the rural areas; it did not work either

    Just look at the Maoist parties that were formed outside of China; they followed the same pattern: they created a cult, and their leaders were like gods. Bob Avakian is the best example, and the COUSML also had a strong cultist leadership; Klonsky was like a god, and he had bodyguards

    In Peru, Sendero Luminoso was a religious cult; in the Caribbean, it was the same pattern, and they attracted most of the young university students who became cadres, and most of them were killed; they did not know the character and the power of the capitalist state, and the whole movement vanished, and they left in a stampede or became an attachment of the capitalist governments. They did not leave a socialist legacy.

    The whole Maoism movement has been a failure as a political tendency. China has evolved as an economic powerhouse because it is a hybrid of state capitalism and market capitalism, and the whole CPC is controlled by strong oligarchs, and the workers are forcibly submitted to the despotic plan of the assembly line, and they have produced an enormous amount of surplus value, able to compete with a powerful country like the USA, but still they have not surpassed American capitalism.

    #267339
    #267340

    Debunking the myth of Mao Cultism, China’s state capitalism and market capitalism, and the fallacy of Chinese socialism, and its so-called regulated economy for the benefit of the workers

    Maoism, state capitalism and market capitalism

    #267349

    Mao, his close collaborators, and his followers called China a feudal society, but in reality, during that period of time, feudalism did not exist in China; it existed in Russia but not in China. Karl Marx called it the Asiatic mode of production, a system different from European feudalism, applicable to Asia ( some historians have excluded Japan), the Mediterranean lands, Egypt, and India, an agrarian society based on centralised state power. The Soviets rejected the concept because their society was similar to Soviet society; other members of the Frankfurt School called it Oriental despotism

    #267354
    Thomas_More
    Participant

    Japan was feudal but I say it with good reason, because the Japanese Emperor was removed from all power with the downfall of the Fujiwara clan and the end of the Heian era.
    The feudal (and permanently feuding) provincial retainers (samurai) took the reins of government and moved their seats of government accordingly (as different clans triumphed over each other). They owned serfs, whose loyalty was to the clan. Clan leaders were installed as shōguns, who were the heads of state. The Emperors had no say in this system and their role was purely religious.

    The Christian missionaries knew they couldn’t head European armies in Japan, which would have been exterminated in the pre-industrial age by the samurai armies. Their plan therefore was to convert clan leaders (daimyō) and back their fight to become the shōgun. They failed, and Christianity was outlawed for 250 years, but not before it had seduced thousands of serfs and then left them to their bloody fate at the hands of their masters.

    The last ruling clan was the Tokugawa clan which, after 250 years of rule was overthrown by western Japanese clans who re-installed the Emperor as head of state but were in turn expropriated following the failure of the Satsuma Rebellion in 1876. Ex-shōgunate forces were mopped up by the new, national, Imperial army, equipped with modern 19th century firepower. The lowest (beneath the serfs) and for centuries the most despised class, the bourgeoisie (not a middle class, as it had been in Europe), came to the fore as the new nation-state (even its flag taken from a US merchant ship) oversaw rapid industrialisation and militarisation and took its place alongside the European and US powers.
    Evicted from the land like their European counterparts had been, the peasantry and former serfs were herded into the towns and cities to be the wage-slaves in Japan’s new factories and sweatshops, resulting in immense suffering, and also in a ruthlessly extirpated nascent socialist consciousness (see Crump: The Origins of Socialist Thought in Japan.)

    • This reply was modified 2 weeks, 5 days ago by Thomas_More.
    • This reply was modified 2 weeks, 5 days ago by Thomas_More.
    • This reply was modified 2 weeks, 5 days ago by Thomas_More.
    #267358

    I have read part of his book, I have not finished yet. I have the apple digital format . I was able to transform it into a PDF format

    #267360
    Thomas_More
    Participant

    I am fortunate. My father has left me his first edition hardback.

    Does anyone here know if the book has been translated into Japanese? If it hasn’t, then it needs to be. Japanese workers need to read it!

    • This reply was modified 2 weeks, 5 days ago by Thomas_More.
    • This reply was modified 2 weeks, 5 days ago by Thomas_More.
Viewing 15 posts - 61 through 75 (of 92 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.