LBird wrote:So, logically

#95574
ALB
Keymaster
LBird wrote:
So, logically flowing from this statement, ALB, you accept that:17th century conceptions/scientific knowledge/truth of 'sun/earth' dynamics were 'true', then;but that 'truth' is not 'true', now, from 21st century conceptions/scientific knowledge/truth of 'sun/earth' dynamics;and that, in the,say, 24th century, our conceptions/scientific knowledge/truth now will potentially be 'untrue' from their conceptions/scientific knowledge/truth?Thus, 'truth' is dynamic, social and has a history.'Truth' is not a fixed, one-off, reflection of 'reality', which science produces by a neutral method.If you can agree with this clarification, ALB, I think that we've come to some point of agreement.

Not so fast !Your statement above about 17th century "scientific knowledge", eg of 'sun/earth' dynamics, origin of 'humans', etc being true would only be valid if the "scientific method" is also variable and relative. Is this what you are claiming too? If you are, this would be a recipe for rampant relativism.As you know, I've suggested not using the word "true" (which does, as you say, refer to knowledge and not the world of phenomena) and using something like "valid", "adequate"or "able to predict more accurately". But sticking to your language, you are right: "'Truth' is not a fixed, one-off, reflection of 'reality'". But why add "which science produces by a neutral method"?Surely, the sort of "truth" Dietzgen, Pannekoek and we here are talking about is also produced by some agreed method? Which is what DJP is trying to get you to say what it is. Me too.