LBird wrote:’Science’ claims
November 2026 › Forums › General discussion › Pannekoek’s theory of science › LBird wrote:’Science’ claims
September 9, 2013 at 2:13 pm
#95579
Keymaster
LBird wrote:
'Science' claims to produce, by a socially-neutral method, the 'truth', by 'discovery'. This 'discovery method' is claimed to produce 'scientific knowledge' which is 'true', once and for all.Pannekoek (and Dietzgen) claim that this can't be done, and I agree with them.
So do I, though I'd prefer to say that this is not what "science" does even if some think that it is. To tell the truth, I don't think that this is what science these days claims to be doing either.
LBird wrote:
One's choice of 'cognitive method' makes clear which 'method' one is using in science.
This is a play on the word "method". We are all agreed (I think) on the theory of what knowledge is (a description of a part of the passing world of phenomena) but what we don't seem to be agreed on is the method by which to decide if a description is adequate, maybe because you won't be drawn on what you think this is.
LBird wrote:
The issue of 'relativism' (as I've already said) can only be addressed, I think, once we have some 'agreement', because the form of that agreement will be used to build an answer to the concerns of those (like me!) who don't agree with 'relativism'.
Ok, assume that you've got agreement and set out your refutation of "relativism".
