Correspondence [religion]
To the Editorial Committee.
In the August issue Mr. John Wyatt, in answer to the criticism of the report of the debate on “Socialism versus Religion,” as reported in the June issue, writes: “If the New Testament is read right, one can find very much to support Socialism.” In so far as our understanding of Socialism is concerned, it arises out of capitalism through the class struggle. There is no “turn the other cheek” about it. Many of the teachings of Christ were devoted to telling the people (the slaves) to put up with the conditions in which they lived for treasure to come in heaven. We are determined to wage a struggle against labourites and alleged Socialists as well as avowedly capitalists—so different from the pacifism of the New Testament.
Mr. R. Smith writes—quoting the report of the debate above: “The existence of religion presupposes a belief in the existence of God.” Then he takes me to task because I asked my opponent for proof of the existence of God. What’s wrong with this? Nobody will doubt that religious people believe in God, but because they believe in God this does not prove that He exists. Socialists believe in Socialism, but that does not prove that Socialism exists.
H. JARVIS
Editor, THE SOCIALIST STANDARD.
Dear Sir,—John Wyatt’s letter in [the] August issue shows a complete misunderstanding of Jesus Christ. He states (truly enough) that he was poor, but it is false that he was executed for opposing the state church.
At his trial before Pilate, the current Encyclopedia Britanica says his answers were “ambiguous” (not strictly truthful). Despite that, Pilate opposed his execution and, literally, washed his hands of the whole affair.
Yet, significantly enough, after he was crucified Pilate insisted on allowing a sign to remain above his head derisively entitling him “the King of the Jews”!
The real reason for Christ’s condemnation was his obstinate mystery policy which he practised. Hence, he compelled the Jews to ask him: “How long will you make us doubt? If you are the Christ, tell us plainly.” (John X, 24). This policy so infuriated the contemptuous masses that when Pilate gave them a Passover chance to release him they unanimously chose to save the robber-murderer Barabbas !
Finally, the Christian dogma that Jesus died to save humanity from their sins is completely contradicted by his very last, despairing words: “My God, why hast thou forsaken me.”
Inasmuch as all events are rigidly determined, Christ’s cry was both philosophically false and religiously blasphemous!
Yours truly,
HENRY MYERS, London
