The trouble with your theory
November 2026 › Forums › General discussion › The ICC way and our way › The trouble with your theory
The trouble with your theory of alienation is that it is a psychological one, a state of human existence, even a quasi-religious one. Humans were originally at one with themselves and the rest of nature, then with class society they became separated from this, but will be reconciled with their true nature again in socialism/communism. Indeed a "grandiose" project. In Hegel of course it was explicitly religious: Man was once united with God, then became separated and at the end of history will become re-united with God.I think it's better to regard "alienation" as sociological rather than psychological and see it as the separation (divorce, alienation) of the producers from the means of production and from what they produce. Ending alienation then becomes more prosaic and simply means bringing the means of production under the collective ownership and control of the producers. Which needn't take long.As to the rotation of tasks envisaged by Marx and Engels, this could be implemented very soon after the means of production have become the common heritage of all. I can't see this as justifying a decades-long transition period.
