Sotionov wrote:Ed wrote:This

#94740
Ed
Participant
Sotionov wrote:
Ed wrote:
This is a sweeping generalization. Who's to say what is dirty? Who's to say what is hard?

Watch the show Dirty Jobs. Anyone who thinks that such work could be done solely by volunteers is simply utopian. Anyone who thinks that mining necessary for a society with the present kind of needs could be done by volunteers, is beyond delusional. Sorry, but that's just a fact. If you give people free access to fulfull their needs and leave them to do only what they want, when they want it and how much, that kind of system would collapse within days, his has been shown on the example of communes, and is to even more true of the society at large. The only people who would volunteer to mine, when they can do anything else or nothing at all- would be the ones that have some sort of masochistic disposition, and that part of the population is surely not going to mine enough to sustain an industrial economy. It just brings us back to what i already said- the only way one could imagine that a free access system would be sustainable is to dream about technological utopianism or the utopian concept of a 'new man' comming into being. 0

I have seen that show, it's where I got the sewer cleaning example I used earlier. You posit only two outcomes either technological advancement or coercive forces as the only way that certain jobs will get done. Here's something you don't seem to have considered. That jobs are worse now because they are run in such a way as to maximize profit at the expense of the workers doing those jobs. Improving the conditions under which we produce has been a major factor of class struggle under capitalism. From the eight hour day to health and safety legislation fought for by unions. It seems clear that if workers decided how to produce and under what conditions they produce, they would take every opportunity to minimize risk of injury and maximize enjoyment of production. Making these so called bad jobs….not so bad. (Even though good and bad are still completely subjective terms). There is also a hierarchy under capitalism of what jobs are good and bad, for instance doctor = good, hospital cleaner = bad. Yet one cannot do without the other. A doctor working in a filthy environment would lose patients and put himself at risk. While the hospital cleaner will at some point in their life need a doctor. This idealist notion of good and bad jobs will be done away with. Production can be made safer right now without the need of extraordinary technological advances. An example could be deadlines. The owner must have enough of a product produced in a certain amount of time to make sure he has enough profit left over after paying the workers their wages. So losing days maybe even weeks to ensuring workers safety let alone enjoyment of their jobs is not his priority. It's not even the workers priority under capitalism to stay safe. They need the money and to get the job done as quickly as possible so they can get a few hours with their families in between sleep and getting up for the next shift. That's the way it must be under capitalism, but it's not the way it must be. What if workers main priority in producing was health and safety? What about if a priority was enjoyment while producing. What if hours were cut short so they weren't at work for so long, weren't as tired. Would all of these things lead to safer and more enjoyable workplaces?