SocialistPunk wrote:Hi TomYou

November 2026 › Forums › General discussion › Race, Gender and Class › SocialistPunk wrote:Hi TomYou

#91525
Tom Rogers
Participant
SocialistPunk wrote:
Hi TomYou keep referring to human instinct, yet when I challenge it you fail to provide any answer.Instinct has a meaning, it describes fixed behaviour in animals, behavour that can not be controlled. If what you call instinct can be overridden then it is not instinct. It is not rocket science, just a bit of basic scientific description.As for "race" the early "racial scientists" thought they were recording actual biological "races" of humans. If you now say a biological definition of "race" is irrelevant, then what basis for "race" do you have?All you give is the fact we can see physical differences of skin colour.Again I ask you to define the number of "races" of humanity and perhaps show how we can explain the classification?If you fail to do so all you are left with is a vague idea that skin colour etc makes us a specific "race" and is therefore a social construct.

I would define instinct simply as an inherent inclination towards a particular type of behaviour.  Instinct might manifest itself in reflexive or volitional behaviour.  The problem with your writings about instinct in this thread is that you seem to be confining your application of instinct to reflexive behaviour only, hence your assertion that instinct cannot be overriden.  I dispute that assertion and I can very easily and quickly produce examples of human behaviour which demonstrate the untruth of the assertion.  Turning to the definition of 'race', my tentative thoughts are that 'race' is less than a sub-speciecal classfication but more than a mere social construct of science and academe.  I would define race specifically as a biological, sociological and physiological expression of local variation within a human population which aggregates into sufficient discrete commonalities among the sub-population that it can be distinguished to a greater or lesser extent from other human populations, near and far, but with sufficient plasticity that the subject population shall remain, above all, human and still able to breed within other human populations and otherwise share the universal human experience.  The local variations should be measurable so that the expressions of race can be classified, recognised and falsified using accepted scientific methodologies.  In that respect, race is both a social construct and a physical and material reality and can be deployed conceptually using various modes and means.  Now, I am not an anthropologist, and this being my own definition, it should be treated as provisional as I am sure it reflects an imperfect understanding of the subject.  I am not going to use this home-brewed definition to enumerate the different races for you, but I do think the definition above is testable.  As with any test, the definition has to be applied with a degree of practical nous.  For instance, sometimes nationalities and sub-nationalities are referred to, colloquially, as 'races' – for e.g. we could say that Scots are a 'race' by the above definition, but in practical terms they are more accurately seen as a sub-racial ethnic group.