LBird wrote:The litmus test

November 2026 › Forums › General discussion › Pannekoek’s theory of science › LBird wrote:The litmus test

#95801
DJP
Participant
LBird wrote:
The litmus test of this, though, is my question about the 17th century sun/earth realtionship. To argue that it was 'untrue', because we now know the 'truth', is not possible.The only answer we can give is that "it was 'true' then', but it's 'untrue' now, and in the future we recognise the possibility that it could be 'true', yet again".

OK, we might be getting somewhere now.All you are saying here is that knowledge is that knowledge is uncertain, that's fine.The problem with your answer is that there is never a certain set of knowledge that is accepted by all people at all times. In the 17th century there where people who took either side of the sun / earth orbit. So when you say "it was true that the sun went round the earth in the 17th century" all you are really saying is that "in the 17th century more people thought that the sun went round the earth than thought the opposite", you are only referring to the relative truth.[In fact a poll taken in America in 1999 revealed that 18% of those asked thought that the sun revolved around the earth (3% had no opinion)]We need to have a critior to enable us to evaluate competing claims. This criteria will never give us 100% certainty. So whilst appreciating that we can (probably) never know the absolute truth when faced with two competing claims we should choose the one that offers the most explanatory and predictive power. Through the gradual accumulation of successes and failures the social venture that is science is gradually building up a body of knowledge that does for our practical purposes lead to a very high degree of certainty.BTW Classical physics is not wrong, it has just been shown to be a partial truth (so no surprise there). It still explains the movements of the celestial bodies, it's just that further interrogation of nature suggests that there is another granular level of existence going on..So "Science doesn't produce absolute truth therefore the Koran is equally valid" can be argued against because religious arguments do not hold the same predictive and explanatory power as scientifically arrived at ones.