LBird wrote:Since we’re

#95686
Brian
Participant
LBird wrote:
Since we’re trading ‘Marx quotes’:

Karl Marx, The German Ideology, wrote:
This method of approach is not devoid of premises. It starts out from the real premises and does not abandon them for a moment.

http://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1845/german-ideology/ch01a.htm

Karl Marx, EPM, wrote:
But also when I am active scientifically, etc… then my activity is social, because I perform it as a man. Not only is the material of my activity given to me as a social product (as is even the language in which the thinker is active): my own existence is social activity, and therefore that which I make of myself, I make of myself for society and with the consciousness of myself as a social being.My general consciousness is only the theoretical shape of that of which the living shape is the real community, the social fabric, although at the present day general consciousness is an abstraction from real life and as such confronts it with hostility. The activity of my general consciousness, as an activity, is therefore also my theoretical existence as a social being.

http://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1844/manuscripts/comm.htm'Not devoid of premises'.'the material of my activity [is] given to me as a social product', 'as is even language'.For Marx, something precedes practice. 'Premises' are 'given'.But, really, trading quotes is no substitute for comrades thinking for themselves, now, in this century, using the advances of the last 150 years since Marx wrote, made by both Communists and bourgeois philosophers

It appears there's a division over "I think therefore I am" and "I am therefore I think".  So it appears that LBird has dug himself into a corner where conciousness has no material base.  Which from whatever angle means its a logical fallacy.That's me thinking for myself. And means that logically our brain is not set in a vacuum for it requires something to think about which ultimately comes from our experience and practice of reproducing the species in a given environment.  This interaction between stimilus and response provokes thoughts and theories on what action and reaction is possible and also probable. And when a scientific mindset of a historical period develops the knowledge and understanding that a theory is found to be tainted by the political ideology of the ruling class they decide its time to put our collective thinking caps on.