It was a good meeting. There

November 2026 › Forums › General discussion › More waffle from Peter Joseph… › It was a good meeting. There

#90741
Hud955
Participant

It was a good meeting. There were about 30 people there.  The main part was a talk by a guy called James Phillips who describes himself as the Project Co-ordinator for TZM Education.  Apparently he does a lot of work going into schools and talking about TZM.   It was pretty standard fare, introducing the organisation and its views for newcomers.  He was pretty hot on the Venus Project, which interested me.  In fact most of his promotional material – big displays all round the room were Venus Project stuff, not TZM.  His repeated theme was that science (measurement) provided the only real basis for a rational system of values – a claim which lead directly into the technocratic/anti-democratic argument.  I raised the question what would happen if the population or a section of it asserted values other than purely technocratic ones, things that couldn't be measured.  He eventually conceded that as there could be no public power of coercion within a resource-based economy that technocratic values could not be imposed – implying that there must be some alternative way for the population to express their collective will.  His back-foot arguement though is that through education, people would naturally come to accept technocratic decisions as the only rational ones.  It hadn't occured to him that maybe some people might disagree and be doing a bit of education of their own. This opened up space for a discussion about democratic control which Danny pressed home chatting to some members after the meeting.  One other interesting thing he said, apparently in passing, was that 'Of course we don't expect everyone will follow us'  which suggests he envisages some sort of enclave of TZMers in a largely capitalist (?) world.  And yep, he kicked it off with a funny money argument, and referred repeatedly to it throughout the session.  (So much for Michael Joseph's attempt to distance the movement somewhat from those early claims).  James was  clearly one of the faithful.  It's really quite amazing that, for an obviously intelligent bloke he couldn't (or didn't want to) see the huge flaws in his really rather simplistic argument.  It wasn't challenged. There was an extended attack on 'the money economy' aka capitalism much of which could have come from one of our own speakers, followed by a description of what a resource based economy might look like.    'Transitioning' – getting from capitalism to a resource based economy – took up a fair bit of his discussion afterwards, and seemed to be what exercised the concern of a lot of visitors.  His answer seemed to be: learn as much as you can and find out what you are good at so you can contribute.  Vague enough.  But he clearly believed that capitalism (or should I say 'the money economy') was in the process of collapse partly because of the proposed spiralling system of debt created by the banking system and  partly because of so-called technological unemployment (people being forced out of productive work by machines). Which all goes to show that a rationalist understanding will take you a fair way to understanding the inefficiencies and destructiveness of capitalism, but it won't help you to understand exploitation or  power structures, or give you a clear view of  where to go from here.  (He expressed the old utopian hope that TZM would eventually get funding/investment to start building their circle cities and that the movement would grow from there.  Presumably, all it will take is for the capitalist class to see how sensible their proposals really are.It was interesting though to have a discussion with people whose compass was pointing in roughly the same direction as ours without being overlaid with tons of leftist elitism.  Most of the people there were looking for a collective and social solution to the problems of capitalism, free from property and property values.  Though they are mired in some pretty unhelpful mindsets, they are miles ahead of the occupy movement.