Hi Steve Colborn,I was trying
November 2026 › Forums › General discussion › Free Speech and Socialism › Hi Steve Colborn,I was trying
Hi Steve Colborn,I was trying to ward off an acrimonious thread like the recent one over religion — a new one which might invite the intolerant to intolerantly defend intolerance. I was wrong to do so, and apologize for so doing.Hi TheOldGreyWhistle,I fear that you want to treat or turn "freedom of speech" into a social or political Absolute. All Absolutes are made by us. The Party only acknowledges two social Absolutes — common ownership and democratic control. They are absolutes for us, because we have conviction that they embody our class interest. Contravening them is contravening our class interest. It is contravening us.Does "freedom of speech" occupy a similar status for us — or do we hold it to be subservient to our class interest, or do we dare hold it superior to our class interest?The answer to this question tells us how to view "freedom of speech" from our standpoint, whether we like it or not.I believe that "freedom of speech" is very much a consequence of society's social base. It will be a non issue for a common-ownership democratic-control social base. It must be a perpetual issue for a class-ownership and class-control social base.So what we can say from our standpoint about "freedom of speech" is far more important than merely what our left-wing opponents do [or don't do] say about it — that's their problem. We have ours.1. Capitalism has mastered — under compulsion to mask its class-division — the art of non-authoritarian suppression of "freedom of speech" without legislating against it [on the contrary, by extending its domain].2. As consequence of our Object [class interest] we differ from left-wing groups because we confer on our whole membership "freedom of speech". The Party is not conspiratorial. Ultimately it belongs to the whole working class, but first it must belong to its membership.3. As consequence of our Object [class interest] we differ from left-wing groups because we do not open our membership to non-class conscious members of the working class — to that extent we currently deny "freedom of speech" to the vast majority of the working class, because they currently don't want to become members of the Party. [Our non-class conscious political opponents — like the Labour Party, etc. — appear to be far more democratic, but their internal hierarchical control structure puts democracy safely in its place.]So "freedom of speech", like every aspect of our case, must be considered through the contrast between the social base of capitalism and the social base of socialism, and their implications.You challenge "But you begin to see it [freedom of speech] as important when it is taken away." This is both obvious, and still posed at the level of capitalism.I retort "If 'freedom of speech' is taken away, what do you propose we do about it when we haven't got it? That is the only possible question for us to answer then.
