For info, some quotes from

November 2026 › Forums › General discussion › Pannekoek’s theory of science › For info, some quotes from

#95463
LBird
Participant

For info, some quotes from article mentioned by ALB and DJP.

ALB wrote:
…Alison Assiter who was then a member of the SPGB. About the same time she wrote an article in Radical Philosophy 23 (Winter 1979) on "Philosophical Materialism or the Materialist Conception of History"…

These have been taken from p. 14 of that article, from the section ‘Reasons why Marx’s materialism should not be seen as philosophical materialism’. Thanks to DJP for providing a copy.

Assiter wrote:
The conception of materialism to which Marx is sympathetic, in that work [ie. The Holy Family], is one which ‘coincides with humanism’.
Assiter wrote:
…humanism does not coincide with ‘reflective materialism’, for the latter is about what there is, quite generally, while the former is specifically about human beings.
Assiter wrote:
Throughout the Holy Family, then, the thrust of Marx’s remarks about materialism is towards a concern with human beings and their productive activity.
Marx (article p 14, fn 4) wrote:
…communism in the practical field represents materialism which coincides with humanism.

From the argument that Assiter makes, it seems that she agrees that Marx’s ‘materialism’ was of the ‘human practical’ sort, which I’ve also argued for here (the tripartite model of interaction of subject and object, which produces knowledge). This also seems to be the same argument as Pannekoek and Einstein make, too.This is very different to the bourgeois myth of the ‘neutral scientific method’, which supposedly produces ‘objective truth’. What the ‘human practical’ method does is put society at the active heart of the explanation, rather than making ‘science’ a passive method of ‘discovering The Truth’.Truth is an attribute of ‘knowledge’, not the ‘object’. Truth thus is a social product and has a history. Hence, ‘truth’ can be wrong, and can be shown to be wrong by a re-examination of the object by social subject.Perhaps this is also the place for me to re-quote Pannekoek, for the benefit of any comrades reading this thread and coming to these issues for the first time.

Pannekoek, Lenin as Philosopher, wrote:
The most important product of brain activity, of the efficient action of the mind upon the world is science, which stands as a mental tool next to the material tools and, itself a productive power, constitutes the basis of technology and so an essential part of the productive apparatus.Hence Historical Materialism looks upon the works of science, the concepts, substances, natural Laws, and forces, although formed out of the stuff of nature, primarily as the creations of the mental Labour of man. Middle-class materialism, on the other hand, from the point of view of the scientific investigator, sees all this as an element of nature itself which has been discovered and brought to light by science. Natural scientists consider the immutable substances, matter, energy, electricity, gravity, the Law of entropy, etc., as the basic elements of the world, as the reality that has to be discovered. From the viewpoint of Historical Materialism they are products which creative mental activity forms out of the substance of natural phenomena.

[my bold]https://www.marxists.org/archive/pannekoe/1938/lenin/ch02.htmScience is not the passive discovery of the really existing external world (reality, the object), but the production by society of knowledge, through the active interaction of the human subject with the object. Truth is not identical with, or a reflection of, the object. The ‘truth’ is a social product, based upon human praxis with reality.