DJP wrote:I’m not sure what I
November 2026 › Forums › General discussion › Pannekoek’s theory of science › DJP wrote:I’m not sure what I
September 16, 2013 at 12:07 pm
#95641
Participant
DJP wrote:
I'm not sure what I think of that quote. Would it not be "naive realism" to think that "real individuals, their activity and the material condition under which they live" can actually be a "premise"? I'm not sure that passage really makes sense.
I think that your valid concerns, here, can be answered by looking to Lakatos' 'research programmes' and their 'hard cores'. That is, a 'premise' is part of an ontological 'hard core' that can't be questioned. This makes for a 'strange' account of science, for those who employ 'induction', as do naive realists, I think, and want to produce 'objective knowledge'.Theory always preceeeds observation, as Einstein pointed out!Theories don't emerge from data. Theories define their data. Selection is inescapable, from an infinite stream of sense-impressions from the object.Humans predetermine which 'sense-impressions' count.
