DJP wrote:I thought you said

November 2026 › Forums › General discussion › Pannekoek’s theory of science › DJP wrote:I thought you said

#95613
LBird
Participant
DJP wrote:
I thought you said you where a realist? In that case the concept that is "the law of gravity" also has to refer to something that is real in the universe. Therefore the "law of gravity" is not just a human construct but also something real in the world.

Yes, as I have been saying for the whole thread, a 'law' is a human construct based something in the real world.Law = knowledge; human = subject; real world = object; construct = interaction between subject and object.If you don't accept the necessity of an active subject, just say so.If you do accept the necessity of an active subject, say how this active subject interacts with the object to produce 'knowledge' of the object that isn't tainted by human thought. This is what positivists believed they were doing: gaining untainted access to the 'object', to produce 'objective knowledge'.

DJP wrote:
I don't see how you can claim to be a realist and disagreee with this statement. Unless I've misunderstood what is meant by "realism"…

I'm a realist, I agree with the statement, and I think you've misunderstood what is meant by "realism". Critical realism doesn't produce 'objective knowledge'. Naive realism claims to, though

DJP, post #15, wrote:
An 'object' does not have a truth value in and of itself, only propositions about an object can have a truth value.

Here, you seem to accept that 'truth' is about humans, not simply the object.I don't know how I can say this any clearer: science is an interaction between object and subject, and produces knowledge.You can't keep accusing me of ignoring the object (reality), when in fact you ignore the subject (society).Cognition requires both object and subject. Their interaction produces knowledge. Knowledge is not simply a product of object, so can't be 'objective'. Knowledge always has a social component.Hope this helps.