DJP wrote:I didn’t reply to

November 2026 › Forums › General discussion › Pannekoek’s theory of science › DJP wrote:I didn’t reply to

#95748
LBird
Participant
DJP wrote:
I didn't reply to those post because I thought they where a bad anology. What you describing is how to fill a design brief. But a theory has to be able to make predictions of the future, an IT of the type you are describing does it system does not do that…

If you didn't understand my analogy, why not ask questions, rather than make erroneous assumptions?

LBird wrote:
In line with alanjjohnstone’s request for someone to try to ‘explain this thread to the rest of us in an easy to understand way so we know what it's all about’, and my suggestion that the world of computers might help, I’ll make an attempt to use the analogy of ‘building a computer system’. Of course, the problem with analogies is that, if they’re taken too literally, they obscure rather than illuminate the real issue. So, please bear this in mind, and ask questions if something seems to present a problem, rather than take something which is irrelevant to the explanation and erroneously try to follow that wrong turn and completely misunderstand.

The 'theory' that you mention, within this analogy, would be the theory that the computer system builders employ to enable them to build a computer system. So, for example, Jackson Structured Progamming might be used to design and write the code.The finished system represents 'knowledge', in this analogy.'Knowledge' is produced by the human social subject, which employs theories to help select and construct, from the pre-existing objective.On a later iteration of this eternal process, previously formed 'knowledge' can form the basis of future 'theory', to once again help to select (what is deemed) relevant from an overwhelming reality.If this still doesn't click, please ask, rather than assume. I'm trying to capture the nature of an interactive process.What's more, even when it 'clicks' (in the sense that posters come to understand the analogy), it still doesn't follow that one has to agree with it.But it's only by comrades getting to grips with this example, that they can hope to elaborate the different theory of cognition that they are, inescapably, employing for themselves.