ALB wrote:It is a “historical

November 2026 › Forums › General discussion › Organisation of work and free access › ALB wrote:It is a “historical

#94870
LBird
Participant
ALB wrote:
It is a "historical fact" that up to the 17th century it was generally believed to be true that the Sun moved round the Earth.The external reality of the relation between the Sun and the Earth has not changed. It was the same up to the 17th century as it is today.Today, in the light of further evidence and theorising, a better interpretation of this reality is that the Sun goes round the Earth and always has done.So, it was not true that the Sun went round the Earth in the 17th century and before.

[my bold]Can't you see that your two uses of 'true' here are different?The first relates to epistemology (knowledge, a human creation), whereas the second relates ontology, to the 'object', which is 'discovered'.Pannekoek's statement clearly relates to the first use, and the second relates to his view of 'materialism'.Simply put, you're using 'true' to mean 'objective'. But 'truth' relates to 'knowledge'.

ALB wrote:
Ah, but does that mean that the Pisciatello was the "true" Rubicon?

Quite frankly, taking the piss does your case no favours. Why you won't engage with the arguments is a mystery to me.