ALB wrote:I think Marx and

November 2026 › Forums › General discussion › Pannekoek’s theory of science › ALB wrote:I think Marx and

#95639
LBird
Participant
ALB wrote:
I think Marx and Engels meant simply that this was the "object" of historical studies (just as the passing world of phenomena is the "object" of the natural sciences), but the passage as worded (or, rather, as translated) could be seen as a bit positivistic.

[my bold]FWIW, I do think that Marx can be 'read' in a 'positivistic' way, but I think that goes against many other ways he phrased his ideas. Marx is a poor writer, in my opinion, and very unclear on many issues. But… he is suggestive…Again, FWIW, I think Engels erroneously latched onto this 'implicit' positivism, and under the influence of his times, moved ever closer to an 'explicit' view of science that Marx didn't hold. Who was it who said, 'social being determines social consciousness'? But this would be an entirely new thread, so I'd rather not pursue this 'Engels was a positivist' line, here now. If we sort out our 'cognition', I think then is time to query Engels.