ALB wrote:And of course

#94793
LBird
Participant
ALB wrote:
And of course they'll need to be democratically self-organised.

As too will 'science'.When I argued this to the ICC, it seemed to go down like a lead balloon!In effect, I am arguing that 'scientific truth' must be a democratic decision, rather than the preserve of 'scientists', conceived as a separate social grouping from the proletariat. Marx warns about this, too, in his Theses."No omniscient 'Central Committes' in either politics or science", is my starting point. Democracy in science, as in the economy.

ALB wrote:
OK, today, when we're engaged in a battle of ideas with capitalist ideology, the minority of socialists/communists that we are do need a higher level of understanding, but I don't think that the majority that will establish socialism will have to be conscious "Critical Realists" or experts in Marxian Economics or the Materialist Conception of History or in fact even to have read a word of Marx.

You can probably guess that I'd disagree with what you've said, here!A conscious proletariat is going to have to be 'conscious' about lots of things, or we'll continue to have 'minorities' in charge. I'm not convinced that a 'three way' approach is much more difficult (than the seemingly easily understood 'two way') to understand, once explained and discussed.