ALB wrote:Agree that science

#94785
LBird
Participant
ALB wrote:
Agree that science does not produce "The Truth" but not that it produces "competing truths'. It is more useful to think in terms of science producing a tentative "truth" about some phenomenon, subject to revision in the light of further experience, empirical research and practice. There is only one such tentative truth at any time, which is not a matter of choice or point of view.

[my bold]Any study of the actual practice of science will show that this can be proved to be an untrue statement. Kuhn, Feyerabend or Lakatos show that 'competing tentative truths' just about sums up the actual practice of science.

ALB wrote:
OK, but his theory of human nature is not just a competing truth but is untrue, i.e a faulty theory for prediction, action and problem-solving.

Are you trying to claim that no anthropologists would support Sotionov's position? If some do, and also claim themselves to be doing 'scientific anthropology', how do we decide between these competing claims about 'human nature', if not through our ideological position as Communists? Don't forget, I share your viewpoint, not Sotionov's, but I'm claiming the basis of this is not some long-disproved notion of 'truth from science', but our shared ideological scientific assumptions. All scientists have assumptions – we should expose these through discussion, rather than deny them.