alanjjohnstone

#95117
Hrothgar
Participant
alanjjohnstone wrote:
 “people will organise themselves on both class and racial/cultural lines and that there is an interaction between the two aspects of identity. ” i think if you ask ant real estate agent for the motive the answer will be property investment potential.

 And on what basis are judgements about ‘property investment potential’ made?  What is the root of this?  

alanjjohnstone wrote:
it was not my intention to misrepresent you. .. you want to have modish views and impress people with your ’empathy’.  If you call for integration, then you are calling for the eradication of indigenous cultures, for the genetic displacement of a unique people, and for people to be generally pushed around. ” Of course its not misrepresentation of my views to impose your own interpretation on them!

 You think people should integrate, don’t you?  If not, then deny it.  But if that’s what you do think, then what have you to complain about?  There is no misrepresentation here. 

alanjjohnstone wrote:
“but by the end of the nineteenth century they [the Irish]were fully integrated” Not from Scotland , are you? Yes, mostly integrated except in a few towns, but your not aware of the official Church of Scotland propsal to deport the Irish back to Irealnd in the 1930s , are you? http://socialist-courier.blogspot.com/2012/06/give-orange-lodge-their-marching-orders.html?q=church+o+scotland+irish+catholics

 Right, so you admit that they ARE integrated.  So you basically admit that I am right about this point, but you can’t admit it explicitly.  You don’t have the honesty to do that, so you try and muddy the waters and keep banging on about fringe Irish issues.  Ok, fair enough, but they are largely integrated, so I am correct that the Irish are a bad example for this discussion.  The reason you keep mentioning them is because you don’t want to discuss the obvious fact that alien immigrants into Britain in the last sixty years have largely NOT integrated.  That’s empiracal evidence of your wrongness, so it’s a no-go area in this discussion. 

alanjohnstone wrote:
Q: You point out that at one point the Irish were known as “white Negroes” and black people were referred to as “smoked Irish.” What did those terms reflect?A: They reflected the scorn and disdain with which both were regarded by the better situated, by the leading elements of American society. There was speculation that there would be some “amalgamation,” that is, that Irish and black would blend into each other and become one common people. That didn’t happen; in fact, the opposite happened. How the Irish Became White by Noel Ignatiev

 Yes, this is what I mean by the interaction between class and identity, and the persistence of tribalism and ‘divisionism’ as a natural impulse.  There are examples of this all over the case.  Another example would be the reference in the present-day United States to poor English (and other Anglophones) as ‘white Mexicans’.  The term is superficially racial in nature, but in reality it refers to socio-economic status. 

alanjjohnstone wrote:
Black Irish, a term similar to Bog Irish, used in a derogatory and racist manner. There is also leprecoon and shanty Irish. In America’s class system pecking order that saw some Irish labelled as ‘black’.  http://www.pitt.edu/~hirtle/uujec/white.html “Irish and Africans Americans had lots in common and lots of contact during this period; they lived side by side and shared work spaces. In the early years of immigration the poor Irish and blacks were thrown together, very much part of the same class competing for the same jobs. In the census of 1850, the term mulatto appears for the first time due primarily to inter-marriage between Irish and African Americans. The Irish were often referred to as “Negroes turned inside out and Negroes as smoked Irish.” A famous quip of the time attributed to a black man went something like this: “My master is a great tyrant, he treats me like a common Irishman.” Free blacks and Irish were viewed by the Nativists as related, somehow similar, performing the same tasks in society. It was felt that if amalgamation between the races was to happen, it would happen between Irish and blacks. But, ultimately, the Irish made the decision to embrace whiteness, thus becoming part of the system which dominated and oppressed blacks. Although it contradicted their experience back home, it meant freedom here since blackness meant slavery.”

 Why do you think it is that, in spite of this, the Irish were, in time, able to integrate into American society while ordinary blacks largely remain segregated to this day?  It would be nice to have an explanation from you about this other than just that you think people are racist. 

alanjjohnstone wrote:
i also refer you to a post on the party blog http://www.socialismoryourmoneyback.blogspot.com/2013/10/one-world-one-people.html#more A racist white union leaders’ testimony before the Louisiana state legislature following a 1907 strike:‘I guess before long you’ll call us nigger-lovers, too. Maybe you want to know next how I would like it if my sister married a nigger? I wasn’t always a nigger-lover. I fought in every strike to keep black labour off the dock. I fought until in the white-supremacy strike your white-supremacy governor sent his white-supremacy militia and shot us white-supremacy strikers full of holes. You talk about us conspiring with niggers. But let me tell you and your gang, there was a time when I wouldn’t even work beside a nigger. You made me work with niggers, eat with niggers, sleep with niggers, drink out of the same water bucket with niggers, and finally got me to the point where if one of them blubbers something about more pay, I say, ‘Come on, nigger, let’s go after the white bastards.’”

 It seems that integration didn’t work very well in this case.  Do you think it will work better in Britain?

alanjjohnstone wrote:
During a 1910 strike by the Brotherhood of Timberworkers (BTW), the lumber operators’ association tried to use blacks as strike breakers and baited the BTW for violating the norms of Southern society with its 50 percent black membership‘The BTW takes the Negro and protects him and his family along with the white wage worker and his family on an industrial basis. As far as we, the workers of the South, are concerned, the only “supremacy” and “equality” they [the employers] have ever granted us is the supremacy of misery and the equality of rags … No longer will we allow the Southern oligarchy to divide and weaken us on lines or race, craft, religion, and nationality.’

 Moving back to Britain, and the present day, I have a few questions for you that arise from the theme in the above passage.   Do you think that ordinary British workers (or workers in Britain, if you prefer) benefit from mass immigration?  If so, please explain how. Do you think that mass immigration, and with it the displacement of white people, assists in building class consciousness?  If so, please explain how this happens. I’m referring here not to your pet theories, but to what happens in the real world and to real people. The migrants who move here are not class conscious and have no regard for the interests of the working class in the international sense. I accept that what is called ‘racism’ is often really just the expression of alienation among workers as to their plight in being denied jobs in a particularly fluid form of capitalism.  That being the case, why does this alienation not lead  workers in larger numbers to enlightenment about capitalism and consciousness about their class interests?  You think it is because of ‘racism’, and that racial propaganda (and other forms of capitalist propaganda) keeps people from seeing their own interests.  It divides the working class into artificial categories, so on.   On the face of it, this seems cogent.  However, we have just spent a large part of this discussion considering whether race exists at all.  It seems to me, whatever the truth of the matter, in the real world you have won that argument resoundingly.  I would maintain that people are impulsively tribal, hence the phenomenon of ‘white flight’ and the soft apartheid I refer to whereby large swathes of ethnic minority groups live in their own distinct ghettoes and communities and are not integrated.  I raise these points not because I doubt the socialist argument that reactionary racism divides the working class – to the contrary, I accept it and I consider it to be truth – but because I question the wisdom of giving support, as you do, to social forces that divide workers rather than unite them. I also accept people are not race conscious in considerable numbers.  There is a propaganda campaign in operation: in the workplace, in public spaces, in schools and so on, which supports mixed-racial integration.  That campaign is working.  Very few people articulate themselves in racial terms now, even in private conversations, and even in the sanctity of their own homes – even in their own heads.   This is what you wanted, isn’t it?  Well, you’ve got it – but that leaves us with a puzzle.  People still will not integrate fully, despite all your bullying, threats and assaults to make them.  Maybe this is because mixed-racialism is a regressive rather than a progressive social phenomenon, its true purpose being to promote the fluidity of capital regardless of human nature, and so (as I explained above) it can only worsen alienation among the working class while leading nowhere in the revolutionary sense.   You think it will, but I doubt it.   ‘False consciousness’ will not disappear just because human races disappear.  The capitalists will just find other ways to divide people, and if anything, it will be easier.  Having accepted the repressive measures of mixed-racialism, people will be all the softer and more pliable the next time round.  I would argue that a mass of people who have no auchtonomous identity will be much easier to manipulate and control than a coherent , homogenous group.  Conversely, it will also be harder to spread socialist consciousness among a group with no sense of identity or strong cultural reference points.  

alanjjohnstone wrote:
Take a look at the Roma thread i posted, while you are at it , how assumptions were so easily made that were turned out false…and how the real problem is submerged by racial stereotyping.   http://www.worldsocialism.org/spgb/forum/general-discussion/roma

 I haven’t been following the story – I just assumed it was an extension of the Madeleine McCann carnival and ignored it.  Having reviewed the news stories (albeit superficially), it seems to me my initial suspicions were correct.  What these idiots are looking for is a little blonde girl.  It’s an extension of a Zeitgeist story.  In the case of the girl in Ireland, as soon as they realised their mistake, she was handed back.  In the case of the girl in Greece, there is no explanation at the moment for the fact that the parents have a child with whom they are not biologically-related.  Personally, I’m not very interested in any of it as I know it’s all driven by the silly media – but you’re wetting your pants about it all, so here’s a question for you: The idea of swarthy gypsies kidnapping nice white children is age-old folklore.  Why do you think that might be?