DJP wrote:LBird wrote:Rovelli

November 2026 › Forums › General discussion › Pannekoek’s theory of science › DJP wrote:LBird wrote:Rovelli

#95784
LBird
Participant
DJP wrote:
LBird wrote:
Rovelli wrote:
 Newtonian physics, despite its immense effectiveness, is actually wrong,

So what makes it false? The fact that people don't believe that it is true?

You really have to start reading things in their full context, DJP.In fact, the answer to your question is in the third extract above, from Rovelli's introduction:

Rovelli wrote:
But answers given by natural science are not credible because they are definitive; they are credible because they are the best we have now, at a given moment in the history of knowledge. (p. xvi)

A historical, and therefore social, approach to the issue of 'what is the scientific method?'.If you have a method that tells you that Newtonian physics is eternally TRUE, rather than a human social construct based upon our interaction with the external, really-existing, world (and therefore can be explained historically), please describe your method.Pannekoek, as we have seen (numerous times so I won't quote him yet again), agrees with this socio-historical approach, as does Marx. It's called Historical Materialism, not 'Discovered once and for all, and done with!'.If you don't agree that Historical Materialism does this or, more profoundly, that it doesn't apply at all to the method of science, say so.