LBird wrote:What do you

#95723
ALB
Keymaster
LBird wrote:
What do you think, ALB? Is it a fair reflection of Bogdanov’s views, in your opinion?

Not really. It's from an ICC pamphlet written by someone who was one of their members at the time and reflects their ambiguous position towards Lenin, seemingly endorsing his criticism of Bogdanov. Although Bourrinet is a socialist/communist in our sense and Kolakowski a declared anti-socialist, I think we can have more confidence in Kolakowski's summary of Bogdanov's views as he would have read Bogdanov in the original Russian while Bourrinet would probably not have done.It is true that Bogdanov wanted to incorporate some of the ideas of Mach and Avenarius into socialist theory (as did Pannekoek) but I don't think he saw this as "going beyond Marx's limitations" (any more than Pannekoek did). More like filling a gap both perceived in socialist theory by adding a theory of the nature of knowledge (epistemology) to it.Anyway, (for what it's worth) here is Kolakowski's summary of some of Bogdanov's views (he devotes 11 pages of his Main Currents of Marxism to discussing them). Referring to a book Bogdanov wrote in 1899 Kolalowski writes:

Quote:
In this work he displays the relativist tendency which he regarded as a cornerstone of Marxism: all truths are historical in the sense that they express man's biological and social situation; truth is a matter of practical applicability, not objective validity.

And on what Bogdanov got from Mach:

Quote:
According to Bogdanov, Mach's philosophy supports Marxism inasmuch as they both treat cognitive processes as instruments of man's fight for existence and reject the possibility of ideas not derived from experience. The 'objectivity' of acts of cognition lies in the fact that they are valid for human societies and not only for the individual. This collective aspect distinguishes physical phenomena from "subjective" ones. "The objective character of the physical world consists in the fact that it exists not for me personally but for all, and has for everyone a definite meaning, the same, I believe, as it has for me" (Empiriomonism, i, 25). Nature is "collectively organised experience". Space, time, and causality are forms in which men co-ordinate their respective perceptions; but this co-ordination is not as yet complete. There are experiences, socially significant and with a social origin, which nevertheless conflict with other experiences. This is due to social antagonism and the class division, which have the effect that human beings only understand one another within certain limits, while their discordant interests inevitably produce conflicting ideologies. In an individualistic society like ours each person's experience centres on himself, whereas in primitive communist societies the "self" was merged in the community. In the society of the future it will be different again, when work is collectively organized and there is no possibility of conflict between my own self and another's.

By which I take Bogdanov to mean that in socialist/communist society all humans will share a common "ideology".He does seem to have been a bit of a technological determinist but to accuse him of prefiguring "the stalinist view" is grossly unfair. After all, while he regarded the Russian Revolution as "progressive" he did not regard it as socialist and realised that what the Bolsheviks (Lenin and Trotsky as well as Stalin) were building in Russia was state capitalism not socialism.