DJP wrote:Brian wrote:Again
November 2026 › Forums › General discussion › Pannekoek’s theory of science › DJP wrote:Brian wrote:Again
I don't think this is fair. Complex issues like this do require a more extensive background reading than can be gleamed from reading a few forum posts. LBird says he is impressed by Schaffs theory of cognition and agrees with it, that is fair enough. The trouble is Schaff's work is hard to find and not available online. So most of us can't discuss Schaff, hence the references to Deitzgen and Pannekoek. You don't think we are Deitzgen or Pannekoek idolizers do you?
I can't speak for other posters or members but not having read much of either Deitzgen or Pannekoek i have no wish to detract further from the discussion by nailing my flag to the mast. That said I agree that this is a very complex subject area and there are extreme difficulties in obtaining the essential reading material but speaking from a Joe Blogs standpoint it would serve mine and other's understanding of the subject if LBird approached Schaff from a critical perspective, albeit by using 'proper english' to explain where and why he disagrees. If any that is?For example twc rather unwisely started off with posts which were way out for my comprehension, thus the filters came down on auto pilot! However once it became plain to twc that this was the incorrect approach to take their most recent posts are far more understanding and accommodating for poor old Joe Blogs. After all is said and done if the likes of myself are failed to be persuaded by the arguments on this thread by any poster who are into the subject of the philosophy of science the discussion is in danger of becoming sterile by remaining within the confines of a select few. I would hate to see that occurring just because a few posters fail to accommodate poor old Joe Blogs. At long last twc has done it in my estimation. Its now down to LBird to come forth with the same line of approach towards Schaff, e.g. become critical. Otherwise my comments on "idolatry" stands.
