It’s my opinion that the

November 2026 › Forums › General discussion › Pannekoek’s theory of science › It’s my opinion that the

#95691
LBird
Participant

It’s my opinion that the longer-term purpose of these discussions between Communists (cognition, nature versus humanity, matter versus mind, methodology, etc.) is to produce a ‘scientific method’ that can be applied to all aspects of ‘natural humanity’. Thus, there can’t be a separation, which some comrades seem to think is necessary, between the ‘physical’ or ‘material’ world and the ‘social’ or ‘philosophical’ world. As I have shown, Marx thought that the unification of nature and humanity into one science was possible, and I think that we Communists should be attempting to do this. I see my current discussion about ‘theories of cognition’ as a very small step on the winding road to that distant goal.Any method, that we can come up with, has to be applicable to the full range of ‘science’, from physics to sociology, and taking in astronomy, chemistry, biology and psychology (and all the other disciplines), along the way.To do this, we have to take on board the best of both Marxist and bourgeois thought on the subject, and, given any suitable recent advances originating from either source, to also ditch any baggage produced by earlier Marxists, which we now consider to have been mistaken. And baggage does exist, not least starting with Engels, in my opinion.These tasks cannot be approached from the perspective of ‘individual common sense’, which is always anything but! To do so, would be similar to approaching Marx’s works on political economy from the viewpoint of today’s ‘individual consumer’ and their ‘personal free choice’. Since I assume most readers on this site will have seen through the bourgeois mystification of the so-called ‘free market’ and its ‘free choice’, and will have come to realise that we are all brainwashed within our society into its ways of thinking from birth, then I think that it should be easier for comrades to come to appreciate the similar problems facing us Communists when it comes to ‘science’. We have to actively question ‘common sense’, as much in ‘science’ as in ‘the market’.Once more, it’s my opinion that ‘science’ and ‘the market’ are the central bastions of bourgeois authority, and that production, both scientific and economic, must be put under our democratic control.One of the things that I find attractive about the SPGB is its insistence on ‘democracy’, and that the class, not a party or sect, should be the final arbiters of all decisions that affect our world society. Within this scope, I include ‘science’, and I’m hoping that comrades, perhaps given some further explanations, discussions and study, will also come to take this position.