Marx and Schaff LBird
November 2026 › Forums › General discussion › Pannekoek’s theory of science › Marx and Schaff LBird
Marx and Schaff
The answer is, of course, practice!
Why Schaff gets it WrongBefore society has the freedom to theorize, it is compelled to practice. It must practically reproduce its own conditions of existence.Schaff forgets that his own privileged academic freedom to ‘select’ whatever theoretical object of cognition he so desires, rests upon the social unfreedom that removes this freedom of selection from the working class.Instead, the working class, which performs the indispensable practice of reproducing society, spends its working life cognizing objects that are thrust upon it by its ruling class.Consequently the working class’s objects of cognition are not of its own freely active ‘selection’. To that extent, the working class can be said to start out as reluctant passive selector of its objects of cognition.In the course of performing society’s necessary social labour on behalf of the whole of society [including performing privileged Schaff’s social quota for him] the working class is forced to settle for cognizing objects that directly oppose its desires.Of course, the working class must eventually come to actively cognize its alien capitalist objects of cognition out of social necessity for its own survival as a working class. But those objects themselves are not there to be cognized in the working class’s direct interest but in the indirect interests of the capitalist class.To consider working-class cognition as comprising “moments of selection”, informed by ‘theory’, is to abuse the terms selection and theory. Theirs are moments of taking orders, subservient to expanding capital. ‘Prior theory’ turns out to be post-festum rationalization of class rule.Nature’s CompulsionBefore man has a chance to theorize what he’s doing, he must act to reproduce his conditions of existence.This compulsion holds for all living creatures — even those unconscious ones and those stationary ones that are rooted to the spot, like limpets. It is nature’s dominance over life, or life’s dependence upon nature.The most that man can do, as sentient creature, is for him to comprehend nature and to wield that comprehension in his own interest. As mere part of nature, he can never circumvent it.Materialist Conception of HistoryMarx has no time for this thread’s tripartite formula — the traditional philosophical trinity of cognition.For Marx, man doesn’t freely set out to seek theory — knowledge of [concrete] objects. Man’s theory is part of the social superstructure.For Marx, man’s life is practical. Man is above all compelled to reproduce his conditions of living.The social relationships, that society forms out of necessity to reproduce itself, constitute Marx’s social base, upon which arises society’s theoretical superstructure.All such social relations, that are formed and sustained in order to reproduce society, can only be the necessary “forms of appearance” of social determinism — of nature compelling society to reproduce itself.The most fundamental of these social relations are those of ownership and control of the means whereby society must reproduce its conditions of existence. They form the core of the social base, since they continually reproduce themselves as the true invariants of a social formation.So long as the relations of ownership and control of social reproduction persist, so too does their particular mode of relaying determinism, and hence so too does that form of society.As we all know, the history of society, since the advent of private property in the means of social reproduction, has consisted in long periods of stasis in class ownership and control of the means of reproduction. Or looked at actively, it has consisted in long periods of stasis in which ruling classes have robbed and ruled the rest of society in their very own characteristic way.We should never forget that history has turned out this way, not by chance, but deterministically, precisely because rule and ownership are always and everywhere aided and abetted by the social determinism for society to reproduce itself.Comprehend that, and you comprehend the necessity for socialism, and the necessity for socialism to reproduce itself.The social relations that nature imposes upon society to reproduce its conditions of existence are appropriately compulsive relations in class societies. In a society, in which the means of social reproduction are common property and democratically controlled, these indispensable relations are deterministically cooperative.In other words, common ownership and democratic control keep on reproducing social cooperation at the same time as they keep on reproducing socialist society as socialist society.Comments on SchaffThe following thoughts arose from reading Chapter 1 of Schaff. The book is hard to find, and I have only read his first chapter on cognition.Schaff knows practice, and so insistently characterizes man as relating to objects through practice as “reflecting interaction”. In other words, cognition remains for him merely cognition of the object that is external to him. In that way Schaff preserves vestiges of Lenin’s cognition of objects.I have no idea how close Schaff approaches Marx’s discovery of the social foundation in the necessity for society to act collectively [though not necessarily cooperatively] to reproduce itself, whether society comprehends what it’s doing or not, and in so doing comes to comprehend its own practice.I have no idea how close he comes to recognizing that society comprehends its own practice when it perceives the necessity of its own practice.Finally, two minor points …Marx identified human essence with “the ensemble of social relations.” [Thesis VI]. Schaff, at times, asserts that Marx identifies the human individual with the ensemble of social relations.Schaff’s [concrete] objectivity would seem to rule out his ostensible concern — history and truth — whose content does not lie “outside of any cognizing mind and independently of it”.
