Classical Political
November 2026 › Forums › General discussion › Pannekoek’s theory of science › Classical Political
Classical Political Economy
Nonsense. Marx expressed supreme intellectual respect for the giants of classical political economy — Petty, Quesnay, Smith, Ricardo — and for the scientific foundation they laid for understanding the functioning of capitalism.His Capital pays them the greatest homage a scientist can ever extend to his scientific forebears — he takes their scientific achievement absolutely seriously, to the extent of rescuing forgotten achievements from obscurity.And he honours them by critiquing their intellectual labours from a later social time, and a vantage made possible from the theory they bequeathed him
Note, Marx’s crucial distinction between appearance and reality.But DJP is quite correct. Political economy is a social science not a natural science. We all expect social science to be consciously or unconsciously inspired by class positions. Every socialist is hourly reminded of that.But natural science is another matter. Please give us one example from the natural sciences so that we may understand your concerns.Confusing the Natural and the SocialSchaff’s “theory of cognition” expressly starts from natural objects that exist independently of cognizing society. Yet when you attempt to explain him, you deliberately start with a social object — the NHS — whose [disgusting] existence is entirely dependent on society.In the case of Adam Smith, you deliberately — against your mentor Schaff, who is a historian openly conscious of working outside the natural sciences — make the same identification of the natural and the social.And, as usual, in your treatment of scientists you look down on, you savagely malign them from a position of prejudice and, it seems to me, complete ignorance.[That’s just like Lakatos — if Ptolemy is pseudo science then so is Copernicus, because they adopt identical scientific methodology. In which case, our central Sun is Lakatosian pseudo science, something the philosopher never intended to imply.]I haven’t the reference to hand — it’s possibly in Marx’s Theories of Surplus Value — where he praises Smith as the great representative of capitalism in its developing stage, as a fearless pursuer of scientific truth, and a man endowed with [and this is the highest praise] genuine scientific naivety and wonder, willing to follow the science honestly wherever it leads him.[What changed, in the interim, was the rise of the working class and its equally fearless political economy that homed in on the class vulnerability of Smith and Ricardo.]You trivialize Marx’s Capital, which he offered to the world as his critique of political economy, if you dismissively consider for the sake of your argument that classical political economy “should have been rejected”. You unconsciously accuse Marx of wasting his time.The irony is that those — who did believe in private property in the means of production — did reject classical political economy because it failed to develop the [abstract] concept of marginal utility, which was less vulnerable to working class attack.Please make the necessay distinction — as your Schaff clearly does — between the natural and the social, and show us any natural science that has survived professional scrutiny merely because the scientist and the profession “believed in private property in the means of production”.
