ALB wrote:
I think this makes you some sort of an "instrumentalist" as described hereand here(like you described Bogdanov as being). This is not meant as a criticism as I think Pannekoek could be placed in this broad tradition.
ALB, I know nothing about instrumentalism, but I offer the following comments on the links that you provided.
Britannica wrote:
instrumentalism,also called experimentalism, a philosophy advanced by the American philosopher John Dewey holding that what is most important in a thing or idea is its value as an instrument of action and that the truth of an idea lies in its usefulness.
Isn’t Dewey a liberal individualist? I’m not sure that he would agree that ‘importance’, ‘value’ and ‘truth’ are socially-determined concepts, and thus open to democratic control. Scientists and philosophers who believe in private property in the means of production are suspect.
Wikipedia wrote:
Instrumentalism denies that theories are truth-evaluable; instead, they should be treated like a black box into which you feed observed data, and through which you produce observable predictions. This requires a distinction between theory and observation,…
In a Communist society, the notion that theories would not be ‘truth evaluable’ would be nonsense, because ‘truth’ and ‘theories’ are human creations, and thus would be under the control of our society. ‘Instrumentalism’ assumes a humanity that accepts ‘black boxes’, perhaps like ‘the market’. Communists wouldn’t accept such a concept; we assume humans can understand our society and its products. ‘Black boxes’ are for ruling classes, and their class-based purposes.I suspect that instrumentalism is a form of naïve realism, as far as I can tell.Given what I’ve tentatively expressed above, I don’t agree with you that “Pannekoek could be placed in this broad tradition” of instrumentalism.
ALB wrote:
To tell the truth, though this discussion is interesting (at least to those taking part), I'm beginning to wonder whether a socialist party needs to take sides in the debates on "the philosophy of science" beyond defending a general "realism" or "materialism". In other words, do we really need to take sides in the more detailed debates that go on between various schools of realist/materialist philosophies of science?
In my opinion, it is of fundamental importance that a ‘side needs to be taken’ by Communists, ‘beyond defending a general "realism" or "materialism"’. The issue is one of ‘authority’. That is, ‘Is there an authority (like ‘science’ or ‘the market’) which is (or should be) outside of our democratic control?’.If ‘truth’ lies in the object, then by definition there is a neutral scientific method, not influenced by humans and their ideologies, which can give us that ‘truth’. This ‘neutral method’ is thus available to individuals, especially ‘experts’. On the contrary, following Marx and Pannekoek, if ‘truth’ lies in the human-created ‘knowledge’, then science is always a socially-biased method, and we must democratically control that activity.The test of one’s position on these issues, it seems to me, is the question of the respective paths of the sun/earth, that we’ve discussed on this thread. Those who believe that the ‘paths’ we now ‘know’ are an ‘eternal truth’ of the object, are taking a different position to Pannekoek. That is, they are taking the position of ‘discovery science’.
Pannekoek wrote:
Man is in the first place an active being. In the Labour process he utilises his organs and aptitudes in order to constantly build and remake his environment. In this procedure he not only invented the artificial organs we call tools, but also trained his physical and mental aptitudes so that they might react effectively to his natural environment as instruments in the preservation of life. His main organ is the brain whose function, thinking, is as good a physical activity as any other. The most important product of brain activity, of the efficient action of the mind upon the world is science, which stands as a mental tool next to the material tools and, itself a productive power, constitutes the basis of technology and so an essential part of the productive apparatus.Hence Historical Materialism looks upon the works of science, the concepts, substances, natural Laws, and forces, although formed out of the stuff of nature, primarily as the creations of the mental Labour of man. Middle-class materialism, on the other hand, from the point of view of the scientific investigator, sees all this as an element of nature itself which has been discovered and brought to light by science. Natural scientists consider the immutable substances, matter, energy, electricity, gravity, the Law of entropy, etc., as the basic elements of the world, as the reality that has to be discovered. From the viewpoint of Historical Materialism they are products which creative mental activity forms out of the substance of natural phenomena.
[my bold]If an activity or its products are human, then they have to be under our democratic control.No ‘experts’ who have a special access to ‘the Truth’. That is bourgeois science.