twc, since you seem to have

November 2026 › Forums › General discussion › Pannekoek’s theory of science › twc, since you seem to have

#95482
LBird
Participant

twc, since you seem to have re-thought your method of 'personal attacks' upon me, I'll now engage with you.

twc wrote:
I have not been attacking you, personally.

Well, I beg to differ, but I'll leave bygones to be bygones, and leave the historical record of two threads to answer.

twc wrote:
But, please check the personal epithets you once flung at members of this forum from a confident bastion of assumed superiority.

‘Superiority’?

LBird, post #31, wrote:
These attempts of mine don't mean that I'm right…

… and I’ve apologised for being ‘touchy’, and I’ve read, listened to, requested an email copy, and bought a book, on various recommendations of other posters. Surely the sign of ‘inferiority’, in that I didn’t know what those posters did. But I’m trying to get up to speed.What’s more, I, unlike others, have clearly given signposts to my ideological biases and thinkers I consider can teach me something.There’s nothing ‘superior’ in my approach, just a thirst for learning. I’m actually looking to be corrected, if someone can point me to, for example, some work that overrules Schaff’s model. I just haven’t found one yet, either here, in a book, or from pub discussions. But I’m open to it.

twc wrote:
Why we need science so that we may reliably comprehend our consciousness’s [this-sided] immediate appearance in terms of our consciousness’s [this-sided] mediated reality.You see our consciousness has this dual character. The interpenetration of this-sided immediate experience and this-sided mediated reality remains a mystifying dual for a tripartite model of consciousness.

This is more like it!You’ll have to explain a bit more about this concept of ‘dual consciousness’. If you haven’t read Schaff, I can explain that a little further, to try to see if the ‘immediate’ and the ‘mediated’ division can be sustained, within this model.Over to you: what is ‘dual (immediate and mediated) consciousness’?[ps. We’ll have to leave the rest of your points till later; I presume they relate to the matter in hand, somehow]