ALB wrote:I don’t know why

November 2026 › Forums › General discussion › Pannekoek’s theory of science › ALB wrote:I don’t know why

#95473
LBird
Participant
ALB wrote:
I don't know why you are so touchy about this.

Perhaps I owe you an apology, ALB, but I'm getting 'touchy' because of a lack of considered replies, and the seemingly general resort to 'common sense' approaches to the issue of the philosophy of science (especially cognition). I've posted numerous quotes from Marx, Pannekoek, Einstein, Dietzgen, et al, over a number of threads both on this site and elsewhere, and yet there seems to be no taste for an informed discussion by communists. I'm touchy and surprised.

ALB wrote:
I was trying to make a general philosophical point about your "theory of truth" and to tease out how you distinguish between a "true" and a "wrong" statement.

And I'm trying to discuss social understanding of science, including how we distinguish between 'truth' and 'the object'. This is not about 'a general philosophical point' or my opinions about another comrade's post. Or indeed 'statements'.

ALB wrote:
Because I've not yet re-read the article and was out all day yesterday helping to run a Socialist Party literature stall. But I will contribute something later on the SPGB Education Bulletin I mentioned.

Can you provide email copies of this bulletin (and any earlier relevant ones)? Or publish it on this site, which would be best.

ALB wrote:
PS. I hope that quoting that Anderton bloke doesn't mean you believe in UFOs. Please tell us that you don't and that this was just an unintended own goal.

This is the most worrying thing yet. I give a quote, from some bloke I've never heard of, who's words just happened to pop up when I googled Einstein's famous quotes, and I assume that everyone will focus on Einstein's words, which are central to the issue. What Anderton said, though, is exactly what most people think when confronted with Einstein's ideas on science, so I left them in as context, so that other comrades could see that most people would react as they normally would do, to such a 'revolutionary' statement.I'm a Communist, trying to defend science, looking to the SPGB for comradeship, and some clown, who keeps pestering me, tries to ignore what's being said, and drags all eyes to 'UFOs', insinuating I'm a 'weirdo'.And even given the endless quotes from Marxists, including Marx himself, the 'UFO question' takes centre stage. It wasn't an 'own goal', but the 'intended' irrelevant point-scoring of a [censored].Yes, ALB, I'm too 'touchy'.