Young Master Smeet

#95041
Hrothgar
Participant
Young Master Smeet wrote:
Hroðgar, Ic ne sægd þæt þær bið "cynnisc todal", Ic sægd se ongean, soþlice.  Ond, hwi sprichst þu Frencisc? Ic spreche hit to for þe…My comment in fact was pointed at the fact that there is no category boundary, and human populations bleed one into the other.

There is a category boundary and your own post implied it.  Apostrophising words may make you feel clever, but it doesn't change the fact that you have made reference to the categories and that your thinking is framed by them.  You are inherently adopting a comparison: in this case, between white and black people, or what you imagine those people to be.  Our exchange would be meaningless unless you were able to make such a comparison, and thus you have accepted the categorisation that you seek to deny.  The paradox you fall into here is resolved very simply.  You can just accept that there must be a reason for you having adopted the categorisation, albeit unintentionally, reluctantly or unwilling.  You may dispute the essentialism of the respective categories and argue for their relativity – i.e. your 'bleeding' point – but that imputes an acceptance of the category themselves, which again leaves you contradicting yourself.If it is your contention that the categorisation is false, then that is a different point and you need to produce real arguments to support that.  I doubt you will because that would actually require you to engage in some real thought and come up with some robust arguments for a change.  Instead, your tactic here is to parrot facile tautologies along the lines of "there is no category boundary", while feigning intellectual superiority.  Neither you nor your colleagues have been able to demonstrate the non-existence of race or provide support for your assertion that racial types are nothing more than skin colour.  Quite the opposite.  Hardly surprising, given there is no scientific basis in what you are saying.