LBird wrote:But, Hrothgar,

#94951
Hrothgar
Participant
LBird wrote:
But, Hrothgar, ‘inheritable differences’ include all sorts of attributes, including ‘ear size’ and ‘uneven teeth’. Why select ‘skin colour’ for special consideration?

Race is not merely a matter of skin colour or any other isolated attribute, so your point here is a non-point.

LBird wrote:
No, this issue is nothing to do with ‘genes’ or biological traits of any sort.It’s simply an ideological issue.

Of course it's ideological.  Socialism is also an ideology.  Science, too, has ideological underpinnings, and to an extent, serves the political and social objects of the time.However, the ideological nature of an idea or perspective is not, in itself, any commentary on its validity.

LBird wrote:
To be a ‘racialist’ is to be burdened by an outdated ideology, which has no meaning other than as a political aim to separate workers from each other.The origins of this ‘racial ideology’ come from a class that has property and steals from those it employs to do the work, and wishes to ‘divide and rule’ those it exploits, so that they remain separated and thus weak.

This is all true.  Racialism has been and is used to divide workers, but again, that is no commentary on its validity.  It is still true that there are races and there are important differences between racial groups.

LBird wrote:
Are you an owner of a business, Hrothgar?If not, you don’t ‘hold a rational position’. You are an ‘irrational’ proletarian.If you do own a firm, and steal from your employees, then it’s also entirely ‘rational’ to point out to those workers that they have different sized ears, some have crooked teeth, and some are black and others white. Any 'division' will do.

I am neither.  I am a self-employed professional.I agree with the classical Marxist critique of capitalism (allowing for some inevitable archaisms in Marx and Engel's analysis given the era in which they wrote), and I also happen to agree with your comments here about how capitalists manipulate workers using 'identity politics' in the workplace: be it sexism or racism or whatever else.  However, if I were an employer, it is unlikely that I would seek to divide and rule in the workplace by subtlely infusing some National Socialist ideology into the induction procedure.  I think discrimination is used to serve the interests of the capitalist class and employers generally.  That has little or nothing to do with my beliefs.  People live in separate racial groups as a matter of course.  It doesn't follow that workers cannot and will not recognise common economic interests across national and cultural lines. I accept that national allegiance can act as an inhibitor, but much depends on the circumstances.  

LBird wrote:
'Rationality' is related to class position.

Only?  I would say that rationality is the state of mind of being open to reasoned argument.  A reasoned argument can be made as follows:-(a). history shows us that regardless of economic modalities, people will still divide along tribal lines in some way; (b). the most natural division among human beings (and many other mammals) is according to genetic closeness and kinship; (c). it follows that racial groupings evolve to reflect geographic proximity and sexual selection;(d). these racial groupings will develop their own 'culture', i.e. distinct laws, customs and traditions of social and political organisation, as a reflection of their shared consciousness;(e). most people will become attached socially, financially and emotionally to their kin groups, of which 'racial groups' are an extension;(f). the existence and preservation of these 'racial groups' (races) is positive and beneficial for humanity in that it promotes diversity;(g). to denounce those who believe in racial preservation as 'racist' or 'stupid', etc., is irrational as it ignores the reasoned basis for the existence and preservation of racial groups and that they exist for a purpose; (h). any attempt to eradicate distinctive racial groups is, by its very nature, oppressive and wrong – even dangerous;(i). but most of all, it is futile because history shows people will always seek to divide and sub-divide socially and distinctive racial groups will evolve again.