ALB wrote:What about: It is

#94874
LBird
Participant
ALB wrote:
What about: It is now known that the Sun did not move round the Earth in the 17th century and before?

As long it is mirrored by: It was then known that the Earth did not move round the Sun in the 17th century and before.'Known' is in the realm of 'human understanding', as Pannekoek argued, not in the realm of the 'nature'.

Pannekoek wrote:
…from the point of the scientific investigator, [who] sees all this [ie. Sun, Earth, nature, etc.] as an element of nature itself which has been discovered and brought to light by science.

The relative paths of the Sun and Earth are not 'discovered', but…

Pannekoek wrote:
…are products which creative mental activity forms out of the substance of natural phenomena.

If they are 'human products', they can be wrong. What's 'scientific truth' in one era can be shown to be 'untrue' in another era. That doesn't mean the external world of nature changes in either.For Pannekoek, 'mental activity' and 'natural phenomena' have to be combined to 'produce' 'the works of science'.Theory + reality = truth.'Truth' is not 'reality'.