LBird wrote: The complete

#94837
twc
Participant
LBird wrote:
The complete democratic control of the entire process of science, no ‘ifs’ or ‘buts’.

Thought PoliceCensorship of human thought is LBird’s gross misunderstanding of Marx’s thesis III on Feuerbach.Materialist Feuerbach imagines he can change man by changing his conditions of existence, independently of [because he is ignorant of] the determinism inherent in existing social conditions.As Marx put it: Feuerbach, the philosopher, raises himself superior to [above or outside of] the actual process of society. Consequently he, and his philosophical plan, will be brought to earth by the actual social determinism he tries to flout. Marx’s charge against him is not elitism per se.LBird misreads thesis III through his anti-Leninist eyes, with vestiges of Leninism clouding his vision. He is alarmed by imaginary social determinisms in socialism that relate to actual social determinisms in a different social formation, capitalism.Consequently, despite himself, he raises himself superior to the actual process of socialist society, whose determinism he lacks confidence in. He doubts the efficacy of our Party Object to maintain socialism as socialism.Instead he insists the SPGB sign up to instituting the ultimately futile. He wants it to outlaw dangerous thought, to imprison thinking within socially-safe bounds.If the tortured history of science proves anything conclusively, it is that shackled scientific thought will burst its shackles. It cannot be tamed. Science is inherently subversive. “Eppur si muove”.LBird intends to slap social surveillance and re-education upon that part of the social superstructure that is science, in blithe ignorance of the social and scientific determined processes. By thwarting the social superstructure that spontaneously arises from the free untrammeled workings of the socialist social base, he and his imaginary plan will be brought to earth by those very processes.Of course LBird only wants an innocuous “lite” version of Torquemada’s Inquisition, Robespierre’s Terror, Stalin’s Purges. He forgets that those worthies started out thus innocently, inspired by noble intent. Paranoia has always fueled social control.He forgets that if science can subvert socialism, then so can his democracy be manipulated to distort science. In other words, if you can’t trust scientists, you can’t trust any of us under socialism. He comes with vestiges of Leninism that see only authoritarianism as the counterpoise to opposition. He is dangerous.Determinism and TruthMarx adopts the formal structure of deterministic science:  Base → Determinism → Superstructure ≡ ObservationThe base is pure abstraction from a material ensemble.The determinism is abstract formalism from that material ensemble.The superstructure is derived by formal determination from the abstract base — it is still abstract, but it purports to be a mentally concrete instance of the abstract base.The observation is a materially concrete measurement of an instance from that material ensemble.The truth of a base–superstructure deterministic science over the domain of its material ensemble consists in its ability to derive mentally concrete instances that measure in abstraction [within bounds of contingency] the same as the materially concrete instances they purport to be.The truth of a base–superstructure system, and its instances, is the only sort of truth we know. The formal determinism of the system is the only determinism we know.Crucially, base–superstructure determinism proves [or disproves] itself because of its essential feedback between theoretical determinism and practical observation.Theory ⇄ Practice.Such truth is partial. Such determinism is partial. Such base–superstructure determinism is itself a process.The material ensemble, which is only determined for us by the science, is ultimately the thing that subverts the science [by analogy with Marx’s account of social revolution in his famous Preface to the Critique] and forces scientists to rethink the scientific base and determinism.Outsiders can easily gain the false impression from reading the famous 1960s debates on scientific revolutions that science is perpetually revolutionizing itself. But the scientific process is, as Stephen Gould [following Thomas Kuhn] described for evolution, essentially one of stasis, punctuated by revolution.If it weren’t for the stasis, daily life and formal science would be impossible. The working truths and working determinisms of daily life persist, or we could not navigate their instances in our daily lives. They hold for us. Likewise, the formalized truths and formalized determinisms of science persist, or scientific research would be meaningless.It is sheer elitist blather to smear science by sneering at its partial truths instead of celebrating its working truths — the only ones we know and can ever know — that persist for us within a conditional but comprehensible stasis. We all live through such stases. Capitalism is one such.Just as we must agree on daily conventions, so too must science agree on conventions in order that its practitioners may communicate and collaborate. That is not elitism. That is spontaneous deterministic human practice.Abstraction or AssumptionIn LBird’s opinion, the scientific base is an ideological assumption, and the scientific superstructure is an ideological consequence. Presumably, the determinism [couched in mathematics and logic] is also an ideological assumption.On the contrary, the base and determinism of modern sciences have long histories of descent from precursor abstractions that were successively teased, thrashed and filtered out of experience [observation].Take Newton’s laws of motion that are so refined they no longer correspond to measurable [observable] material. Only their deterministic concrete instances do. The student who doesn’t know their history is condemned to take them on trust, or ignorantly mistake them for mere assumptions.In actuality they are distilled residues of abstractions that predate civilization, that were crystallized out by the Greeks — in particular by the anti-religious, and so socially embarrassing, particle materialists — refined by the priestly medieval Schoolmen, and mathematized by Kepler in his three “laws of planetary motion” abstracted from Tycho’s observations of the planet Mars from a Copernican moving Earth.Newton acknowledged the abstraction spadework of his predecessors: “if I have seen further than others it is because I have stood on the shoulders of giants”. He also taunted philosophers who build upon formally explicit assumptions: “I make no hypotheses”.[In reference to “bourgeois science”, it might be noted that Newton entered the House of Lords, rising to Master of the Royal Mint. Not one of his precursor giants was a class-conscious proletarian.]The abstract bases [laws] and abstract determinisms [couched in mathematics and logic] of our deterministic sciences are mankind’s supreme achievements.Abstraction and determinism are the substance of our consciousness, and the secret of the efficacy of our human practice. As such, they cannot be mere assumptions.RelativityLBird proffers his account of Einstein’s thought experiment as a perfect analogy of social ideology.A physicist would recognize that LBird is merely describing the [Galilean] relativity of classical physics, that Einstein is here expressly refuting.Thanks to James Clerk Maxwell, classical physics deterministically implies a constant velocity of light — a constancy that Einstein recognizes must violate the addition of velocities of classical relativity, and so has subversive implications for the classical measurement of space and time.Einstein is primarily interested in determinism. Classical relativity stands in its way, and so ends up as determinism’s casualty. [In a very real sense, the comparison of observations across inertial frames is very special indeed, as no such inertial frames actually exist.]But in fact, LBird’s example would not defeat most mammals that navigate the world guided by stereoscopic vision. You see, the ball will never move forward from the man, only up and down beside him. Einstein’s dog would take that into account, and snatch it.Fail to see how that proves science is based on ideological assumption.[In reference to “bourgeois science”, James Clerk Maxwell, as Elder of the Church of Scotland, as avowed opponent of Darwinian evolution, and as proponent of the impossibility of scientific sociology, seems a perfect representative of this detested type. Presumably that neatly explains the elite privileged velocity he assigned to light.]Democracy of ThoughtLBird, wants to subject scientific thought to global democratic decision making lest elite scientists take over the world of socialism. That is imaginary science fiction.LBird has proven that he has no idea of the way science works. Many of his pontifications have the false emphasis of partial truths — the things he scorns.He has demonstrated that he cannot contribute at the leading edge of a specialist science. Of course, no scientist can hope to contribute at the cutting edge of all scientific knowledge as is falsely supposed possible even as recently as the Renaissance.It’s never been possible to do so. The favorite polymath Leonardo the man, not Leonardo the myth, could not have contributed to, say, then current Ptolemaic astronomy.Science is, and probably will always remain a cooperative human enterprise conducted by specialists.Science is definitely elitist in the human sense that it takes dedication, imagination, often extraordinary ability, motivation and sheer hard work to master and conduct it. Consequently it must rely on specialist division of labour, and so implicitly on scientific trust — on scientific integrity.But we have also seen that science’s base–superstructure determinism is itself self checking.Perversion of ScienceThe issue of “bourgeois science” is a complex one. Never forget that Marx [like Hegel before him] developed a theory of human consciousness: “social being determines consciousness”.Marx has explored ideology in deeper ways than just class-perverted science [which he was really the first to expose]. For him, material things like money are ultimately ideological in extraordinarily interesting ways. But such deeper matters are for another thread.I hereby oppose LBird’s insistence that the SPGB subscribe to controlling the meaning of scientific research.