although formed out of the

#94816
Ed
Participant

although formed out of the stuff of natureFrom the viewpoint of Historical Materialism they are products which creative mental activity forms out of the substance of natural phenomena.Isn't that positivism in your book? As that is what I was saying earlier, or trying to, natural phenomena = evidence. Whereas you appeared to be saying that ideas occur spontaneously, independently from nature and material conditions. That was my main beef anyway.