I’ll open with a short

#94813
LBird
Participant

I’ll open with a short summary so far. There seem to be two conceptually separate, but practically related, issues being discussed.First, does science produce ‘The Truth’ by a neutral method (and so can be done by an individual or a small group of experts), or does it produce socially-related and thus biased ‘Truths’ (and as an activity done by a society is controlled by that society)?Secondly, if it is the latter (controlled social truths), then what is the nature of that control: democratic or elite expert?I’ve argued that ‘socially-produced truths’ must be ‘democratically-controlled’. The former is a philosophical issue, whilst the latter is a political issue.

ALB wrote:
OK, so in your view, it's going to be put to a show of hands at a mass meeting? Or what exactly do you have in mind? What structure are you proposing for making in communism/socialism a popular democratic decision on whether a scientific finding is "true" or not? …. I'm not too keen on referendums myself, but wouldn't rule them out completely as part of the democratic decision-making structure of socialist society.

I think that, at present, this discussion has to be kept at the level of a philosophical debate. Just as we can’t give detailed blueprints for the workings of communism, in an economic production sense, neither can we give detailed answers as to how humanity will control science. But … given a society in which a scientific education is freely available to all humans, from infant school to post-PhD research, where participation in scientific research is open to all, where all research papers are published openly for all to read, and where, as you said earlier…

ALB wrote:
Of course scientific research will be subject to overall democratic control in a socialist society. I can see the priorities for research and the resources allocated for it being the subject of a democratic social decision. Also decisions such as whether or not to allow vivisection, etc.

…then is seems obvious that science will be under the control of all humans, not just a few, self-selected specialists. If I were compelled to speculate, then I would imagine each commune would elect a delegate committee to keep oversight upon that commune’s scientific work, but that any controversial decisions would be referred to the whole community. I can’t imagine a socialist world where most people haven’t had a pretty high level of education, plus the comrades engaged in science would have a duty to explain their work to the community. Given that scenario, I can’t see any part of science being out of the democratic control of humanity. If, on the contrary, we still presume that science will be the preserve of an intellectual elite, engaged in work that the vast majority can’t comprehend, then I wonder how communism can work. It wouldn’t be long before the ‘science’ experts, working behind closed intellectual doors, would soon become ‘production’ experts, handing out ‘advice’ to the ignorant masses…No, I have to assume that communism would include democratic control of the entire process of human science.As part of this process of an emerging self-confident, class conscious proletariat, we must argue now for this future democratic control of science, both to strengthen our confidence and to undermine exaggerated respect for the bourgeois myth of a value-free scientific method. This notion has been undermined by bourgeois philosophers already, so we should be pushing at an open door, not bolstering outdated ideas of positivist science. While we hold that science produces the Truth, we are under the control of priests.

DJP wrote:
The truth of the matter always exists independently of those that observe it.

This is a positivist statement, as I explained in earlier posts. ‘Truth’ lies in the realm of human ‘knowledge’, not the realm of the ‘object’. Please see my post #76, which briefly describes a tripartite theory of cognition. ‘Truth’ can’t exist outside of its human production. And the ‘object’ must be understood within a framework of observation, so the same independent ‘object’ can be involved in the production of several ‘truths’. Please see my post #57, where I refer to Einstein’s ‘train’ explanation.

DJP wrote:
I don't really think it makes sense to talk about a "communist" science or a "bourgeois" science any more than it makes sense to talk of a "socialist" mathematics or a "capitalist" geology. All that would change with a change in the mode of production would be the direction in which scientific research and the application of technology is applied.

[my bold]I think that this is a very serious underestimation of the changes that will be wrought by the advance to a communist mode of production. If the ‘coming to consciousness’ of humanity results in so little change, it seems hardly worthwhile the struggle. Science, surely, will become a mass activity? As will all aspects of human thought, including the philosophy of science.

DJP wrote:
Does Pannekoek write about this stuff in Lenin as Philosopher?
Anton Pannekoek, Lenin as Philosopher, p. 15, wrote:
The real world, the material, sensual world, where all ideology and consciousness have their origin, is the developing human society – with nature in the background, of course, as the basis on which society rests and of which it is a part transformed by [hu]man[ity].

[my bold]Pannekoek’s ‘Nature, the real, consciousness (transformation)’ is my explanation ‘Object, subject, knowledge (interaction)’. Tripartite, as for Marx, not bipartite, as for positivism and idealism. Please see the Theses on Feuerbach.I hope this helps a bit, comrades.